Tech experts divided on social media surveillance

A recent controversy involving an Ontario-based software company losing access to Twitter

TORONTO — A recent controversy involving an Ontario-based software company losing access to Twitter because of its marketing practices is just one salvo in an ongoing battle around online privacy, analysts say.

Experts are divided on whether actions taken against Media Sonar of London, Ont., were justified, but are united in the view that the case highlights the elusive balance between public safety and basic privacy rights.

Media Sonar touts its social media monitoring software and algorithms as ideal tools for police and corporations to aggregate and filter data to improve safety and protect corporate assets.

But a U.S.-based investigation turned up marketing language that ran afoul of Twitter’s policies, which state that posts on the popular social network should not be mined for surveillance purposes.

Media Sonar’s emails to past clients explicitly stated that the software, which allows officers to comb through publicly available posts on the likes of Twitter and Instagram, could help police search for “criminal activity” and “avoid the warrant process” when flagging people who have come under scrutiny.

Twitter responded by cutting off the company’s access to its application program interface (API), saying its policies explicitly state that no third party can make use of Twitter data for surveillance purposes.

Media Sonar did not respond to requests for comment.

Analysts agree that Twitter’s stance will do little to limit surveillance on its own, since numerous products on the market perform the same function.

They anticipate, however, that Media Sonar will be one of many companies to find themselves caught in the crosshairs of an increasingly complex and heated debate.

Tamir Israel, staff lawyer with the Canadian Internet Policy and Public Interest Clinic, said there’s a disconnect between what law enforcement feels it’s entitled to do with data and what citizens believe may be happening.

“The challenge is that our privacy norms have not necessarily caught up to this new and dynamic environment,” Israel said. “A lot of this social media monitoring occurs in kind of a grey area.”

Many people contend that third parties have every right to comb through data that’s been shared voluntarily on platforms widely known to be public.

Information such as hashtags and geolocation tags, they argue, can be invaluable investigative resources to police.

Ryan Duquette, who runs digital forensics company Hexigent, believes Twitter’s actions against Media Sonar were misplaced.

He contends the onus is on individuals to control the content they make available online, not on companies to curtail the use they make of publicly available data.

He argues that while companies ranging from tech providers to public relations firms routinely dive into the “treasure trove” of publicly available data, he argues that law enforcement agencies have a particularly compelling reason to do so.

“Everybody else wants that immediate information,” he said. “Law enforcement is no different, except they’re using it for public safety, not to market the latest and greatest coffee to somebody.”

Privacy advocates acknowledge that police forces have valid reasons for combing through data, but caution that current techniques can be more insidious than they first appear.

Israel said most social media monitoring companies rely on algorithms to parse the vast amount of data and pull out meaningful information for clients. Those algorithms, he cautioned, can be misleading.

Israel said they often analyze posts out of context and are unable to account for slang, cultural norms or other factors that give a post meaning.

He cited a recent example of a British tourist who tweeted about his intention to “destroy the United States” on an upcoming trip. His post raised alarm bells with U.S. security, but the tourist had been trying to express his plans to party while abroad using common British slang.

Just Posted

Doctor first in Red Deer to offer Mohs surgical suite for skin cancer

A local doctor says a skin cancer surgery newly offered locally will… Continue reading

Methamphetamine, THC found in half-million dollar seizure and Bowden Institution

Nearly half a million dollars worth of drugs and other contraband was… Continue reading

Community support needed to bring Canadian Finals Rodeo to Red Deer

Bid from Westerner Park and Red Deer & District Chamber of Commerce

Long-tenured former Blackfalds mayor recognized by Alberta Urban Municipalities Association

After 19 years serving on Blackfalds council, Melodie Stol was thrilled her… Continue reading

Preserving Innisfail pioneer home means Isabella Sinclair’s story will live on

House from 1890 will be moved next month to historical village

VIDEO: Red Deerians taste what the city has to offer

Red Deerians sampled some of the finest foods Central Alberta restaurants have… Continue reading

New columnist joining Advocate team

Market Gypsy starts on November 30

Volunteer with victim services in Red Deer

Learn more at info session on Nov. 27

Updated: Missing Sylvan Lake women found

Women were reported missing earlier this week

Liberals propose billions for affordable housing, including individual benefits

A Liberal government fond of promising help for those working hard to… Continue reading

Alberta Party sees growth in Central Alberta

Greg Clark addressed health care needs addressed in Red Deer

Ponoka council freezes Ponoka Fire Department spending

All discretionary spending frozen until full budget numbers are presented

WATCH: Ponoka’s Festival of Trees sees continued support

Three days of celebration and fundraising held at the Calnash Ag Event Centre

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month