Walkom: Trump’s NAFTA plans should be no surprise

It’s clear now that, regardless of what he told Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Donald Trump wants to do more than tweak the North American Free Trade Agreement.

But it’s not at all clear how far the U.S. president intends to go.

A draft letter to Congress leaked to the media on Thursday lays out broad aims for the U.S. in the upcoming NAFTA renegotiations.

These aims can’t come as much of a surprise to the Canadian side. Some echo U.S. demands acceded to by Canada during talks for the now defunct 12-nation Trans-Pacific Partnership pact. These include reducing or eliminating protection for Canadian dairy and poultry farmers.

Others echo concessions Canada made during its free trade talks with the European Union, including opening up more government procurement contracts to American firms.

The letter suggests this would be married to a demand that U.S. governments continue to use Buy American policies in their procurement.

A nonjudicial dispute resolution system that allows governments and firms to challenge one another’s trade penalties would be eliminated. That so-called Chapter 19 system often favours Canada.

But another nonjudicial dispute resolution system that allows corporations to challenge laws, such as environmental statutes that interfere with their profitability, would be kept. That so-called Chapter 11 system tends to favour U.S. firms.

In other words, the letter represents a deliberately lopsided partial wish list. Still, it is the partial wish list of the most powerful member of the agreement binding the economies of Mexico, Canada and the U.S.

So it should be taken seriously.

Does the letter mean Trump is mellowing? Many in the U.S. media thought so – largely because it didn’t reflect the usual apocalyptic language that the president likes to employ when discussing what he likes to call “the single worst trade deal ever.”

Fox News even used the “tweak” to describe Trump’s latest approach to NAFTA.

But I took Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross at his word when he said on CNBC Thursday that Trump’s thinking about NAFTA hasn’t changed.

“The letter simply describes in broad terms the topics we will be discussing,” he said.

Interestingly, the draft letter includes long-standing Democratic demands that a renegotiated NAFTA include enforceable labour and environmental standards directly in the agreement.

Depending on how it is done, a labour standards provision could make it harder for firms exporting goods to the rest of North America to exploit Mexican workers. By reducing the wage differential between Mexico and the rest of the continent, that in turn could benefit Canadian and American workers.

In sum, the draft letter tells us three things.

First, Trump is not quite the wild man he purports to be. The draft letter is vague enough to encompass much of Trump’s make America great again campaign aims. Canada and Mexico could still emerge from these talks badly mauled.

But the U.S. president has signalled that he intends to achieve these aims through the bland and bloodless practices of standard trade negotiation. There is no longer any talk of the U.S. simply abrogating NAFTA.

“It looks like an all too familiar, although arguably even more aggressive, corporate-driven TPP-style agenda,” Scott Sinclair, a trade expert with the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, told me in an email.

Second, Trudeau’s charm offensive – aimed at convincing Trump and other Americans that NAFTA is beneficial for them – has only half-worked. Trump appears to have accepted that NAFTA can be good for the U.S. His aim now is to make it work even better for his country – at the expense of Canada if necessary.

Third, Canada is still in the same old bind. Now that we have restructured our economy around NAFTA, we can’t easily do without it. The Americans are in a better position to go it on their own in North America.

In short, we don’t have much bargaining power. Without an alternative plan, we can’t just walk away from these talks if U.S. demands become too unreasonable.

Presumably, Trump knows this. He may think Trudeau the finest of fellows. But this ruthless deal-maker also knows that when it comes to NAFTA, the prime minister doesn’t have many options.

Thomas Walkom is a national affairs writer.

Just Posted

Red Deer seeks public input on coming changes to sign bylaw

A half-kilometre buffer zone could separate billboards in Red Deer under proposed… Continue reading

Innisfail man injured in home invasion

Police say the injury was non life-threatening

Credentials questioned man at Remembrance Day services

Veterans are crying foul after an alleged faker posed as a former… Continue reading

WATCH: Festival of Trees begins

A preview dinner and silent auction was held Wednesday night at Westerner Park

Volunteer with victim services in Red Deer

Learn more at info session on Nov. 27

Updated: Missing Sylvan Lake women found

Women were reported missing earlier this week

Liberals propose billions for affordable housing, including individual benefits

A Liberal government fond of promising help for those working hard to… Continue reading

Alberta Party sees growth in Central Alberta

Greg Clark addressed health care needs addressed in Red Deer

Ponoka council freezes Ponoka Fire Department spending

All discretionary spending frozen until full budget numbers are presented

WATCH: Ponoka’s Festival of Trees sees continued support

Three days of celebration and fundraising held at the Calnash Ag Event Centre

Creationist will speak at home-schooling convention in Red Deer

Ken Ham has debated Bill Nye on the Earth’s origins

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month