After Keystone XL denial, a boom for crude-by-rail is not a foregone conclusion

Now that the Keystone XL pipeline has been rejected, it's not a foregone conclusion that much of the 830,000 barrels a day that would have flowed through it will move on trains instead, industry watchers say.

CALGARY — Now that the Keystone XL pipeline has been rejected, it’s not a foregone conclusion that much of the 830,000 barrels a day that would have flowed through it will move on trains instead, industry watchers say.

“I think that rail certainly will play a part, but a lot has to do what happens to the price of crude and happens to oilsands projects,” said Dirk Lever, an analyst at AltaCorp. Capital.

Proponents of Keystone XL and similar proposals frequently trumpeted the benefits of moving crude by pipeline over rail — safety-wise, economically and environmentally.

“This denial will result in more oil moving by rail along with an increase in (greenhouse gases),” TransCanada warned after U.S. President Barack Obama announced he’d be denying a permit for the US$8-billion cross-border pipeline.

The safety of shipping crude by rail has been top of mind since a fiery crash in the summer of 2013 killed 47 people in Lac Megantic, Que.

Canada’s crude-by-rail exports have fallen this year, according to National Energy Board data.

The industry finished off 2014 shipping an average of 158,532 barrels a day across the border. In the first quarter of 2015, that dropped to 119,755 and in the second quarter it plummeted to 83,605.

Shipping crude by rail is significantly more expensive than pipeline — think US$10 a barrel versus US$5 a barrel, though it does vary depending on market conditions, said Lever.

The West Texas Intermediate crude price, the main U.S. benchmark, is around US$42 a barrel. But that’s not even the price oilsands producers get for their heavy, trickier-to-refine product.

“If you’re getting US$120 a barrel, you might not care about that US$5. But when you’re getting US$30, you care very much,” Lever said.

There’s also a question mark hanging over the outlook for how much crude output is coming, given some projects have been cancelled or delayed. The barrels Keystone XL would have shipped aren’t being produced today the idea was to build the pipeline in time to carry crude from expansions that are in the works, said Lever.

Afolabi Ogunnaike, a Houston-based analyst at consulting firm Wood Mackenzie, agrees rail is “less desirable” because of the dent to producers’ bottom lines — at least in today’s market.

“Many of these projects, they are long-lived projects and between now and 2020, we would expect that the price of oil will rise some,” he said.

Joshua Axelrod, a policy analyst at the U.S.-based Natural Resources Defense Council — one of the environmental groups that campaigned against Keystone XL — said it’s not well understood that the boom in U.S. rail traffic hasn’t been originating from Canada, but rather from the Bakken oil deposit centred on North Dakota.

“Keystone XL would not have relieved that problem,” he said.

There are a number of crude-by-rail facilities planned for the Pacific Northwest that would surely be attractive to oilsands producers, but those are contentious. So between mounting opposition, the costs of rail and the lack of certainty on new oilsands projects, the prospects for crude-by-rail filling the Keystone XL gap aren’t good, said Axelrod.

“With all those caveats, there’s no way that Alberta oil is going to be put on trains and come to the U.S. It would be such a loser for the industry that it would basically sink it.”

Just Posted

Red Deer Express to publish final edition Wednesday

Black Press strengthens commitment to Red Deer Advocate

Red Deer County ponders garden suite proposal

Property owner’s garden suite plans exceed county regulations

Make Parsons house preservation an election issue, Red Deer city councillor suggests

Coun. Michael Dawe says candidates can be questioned about where they stand

PHOTO: Everybody Loves a Sale

Dozens of people wanted a chance to scoop up some discounted Canada Winter Games merchandise

Red Deer County posts big surplus

2018 operating budget came in with $5.8 million surplus

Slow cooker or Instant Pot?

Now that the viral craze surrounding the Instant Pot has quieted down… Continue reading

Millennial Money: There’s more than one way to slay a debt

The saying that debt is easy to get into and hard to… Continue reading

Bianca Andreescu’s win streak ends after early exit because of injury

MIAMI — The injury bug has derailed Bianca Andreescu’s impressive run. The… Continue reading

CONCACAF teams to learn Nations League draw on Wednesday in Las Vegas

Canada will learn its next CONCACAF Nations League opponents at Wednesday’s draw… Continue reading

Alanis Morissette announces pregnancy in Instagram photo

Alanis Morissette is pregnant with her third child. The Grammy-winning singer posted… Continue reading

“MLB The Show 19” allows video gamers a chance to relive baseball history

TORONTO — From Babe Ruth’s debut as a pitcher to Jose Bautista’s… Continue reading

Canada Revenue Agency tax services back online after ‘hardware’ problems

OTTAWA — The websites Canadians use to file their taxes online were… Continue reading

Roof structures failed before Radiohead stage came down, inquest hears

TORONTO — Metal structures meant to hold a roof over a stage… Continue reading

Most Read