Business innovation has continued to fade despite billions in federal cash: memo

Spending billions of public dollars over two decades has done little to reverse Canada’s long decline in the key economic category of business innovation, the federal government acknowledges in a newly released document.

OTTAWA — Spending billions of public dollars over two decades has done little to reverse Canada’s long decline in the key economic category of business innovation, the federal government acknowledges in a newly released document.

The self-assessment, contained in a “secret” memorandum to Finance Minister Joe Oliver, underlines how chronically sluggish business innovation remains “of great concern” for Canadian productivity.

“Canada’s productivity performance, a key determinant of economic growth, continues to lag significantly behind that of the United States, eroding our relative standard of living,” says the October memo, signed by deputy finance minister Paul Rochon.

“The innovation performance of Canadian firms has continued to fall relative to the previous two decades, despite considerable federal efforts in recent years.”

That push included more than $11 billion spent by the Harper government between 2006 and 2014 on new resources to support research and innovation, the document says.

On top of that, the note said the government also pumped $10.9 billion into science, technology and innovation activities and provided another $3.3 billion in tax relief for scientific research. In 2014, the memo said $1.6 billion was dedicated over five years to promote research and innovation.

The reluctance of Canadian companies to allocate more resources into innovation, thereby helping to improve efficiency and create new products, has been a long-running challenge federal and provincial governments.

With the economy set to become a central issue in the fall election campaign, federal parties have already begun hammering innovation-related planks into their platforms.

The NDP has promised to introduce a tax credit to encourage manufacturers to boost R&D through investments in machinery, equipment and property. In the April budget, the Conservatives earmarked $119 million over two years for research and development activities.

The memo to Oliver also warned how tougher competition in the knowledge-based global economy could leave Canada behind. Boosting innovation, it said, is key to helping Canadian companies create “high-quality, value-added jobs.”

The note, titled “Canadian Business Innovation Landscape,” was obtained by The Canadian Press under the Access to Information Act.

On the positive side, the document said Canadian businesses perform well at the international level when it comes to primary research, but they trail their global counterparts in R&D despite “some of the most generous government incentives by world standards.”

The memo explores the possible reasons why Canadian firms appear to have shunned innovation.

Among the potential explanations, it pointed to findings in a 2013 report by the Council of Canadian Academies: overdependence on high commodity prices and over-reliance on the North American market, which encourages firms to save cash by acquiring innovation from the U.S.

The memo also lists other possibilities, such as the absence of tough competition in Canada, the smaller market here and the higher risk aversion of Canadians.

In general, the document said Canadian companies rely more on “imitation than on innovation” and are less likely to collaborate in R&D with public institutions than firms in other G7 countries.

Several organizations have noted Canada’s weak performance in business innovation.

The Conference Board of Canada, an Ottawa-based economic research group that has carefully studied the issue, has released an innovation report card every few years for the last two decades.

The reports have compared Canada’s performance with 16 “peer” countries on innovation-related indicators.

“Canada’s been a ’D’ performer basically since the time we started doing this thing,” said Daniel Munro, the board’s principal research associate for public policy.

“We’re just about the bottom of the barrel … our performance since about 2001 has gone in the complete opposite direction of the 16 peer countries that we look at as well as the OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development) overall.”

One of the biggest changes, Munro said, has been the decline of Canada’s manufacturing industry, which has historically invested significantly in R&D. The void was largely filled by oil, gas and mining sectors, known to spend less on research, he added.

Munro said innovation — and, by extension, productivity — help boost per capita gross domestic product, making them key to ensuring Canada can sustain its high standard of living and social programs.

But even if government investments have been unable to halt the decline in innovation, the extra cash may have helped soften the blow, he said.

As a potential solution, Munro suggested Canada consider following leading countries by offering more direct measures to promote innovation, rather than continuing to rely heavily on indirect methods, such as tax credits.

Both the Conference Board and the federal government agree it’s ultimately businesses that will decide whether innovation improves.

“While governments need to provide the right conditions to foster business innovation, private sector decisions by individuals and businesses are the primary determinant of Canada’s innovation performance,” the memo said.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Updated: Red Deer doctor killed at clinic

The RCMP’s major crimes unit is investigating a fatal attack on a… Continue reading

Vigil scheduled Friday for Red Deer doctor who was killed

A candlelight vigil is scheduled for Friday at Red Deer City Hall… Continue reading

Alberta reports 257 new cases of COVID-19

The Alberta government reported 257 new cases of COVID-19 in its latest… Continue reading

‘Is this a town garden?’ Sylvan Lake resident has been gardening for 7 decades

Most summer days, Sylvan Lake’s Joel McCutcheon is in his garden pulling… Continue reading

QUIZ: Do you know the truth?

In what has been described as a post-truth era, how much do you know about truth and lies?

Cast your votes for Best of Red Deer

The Advocate’s Best of Red Deer Readers’ Choice Awards are back. Community… Continue reading

Singer Salome Bey, known as Canada’s first lady of the blues, dies at age 86

Singer Salome Bey, known as Canada’s first lady of the blues, dies at age 86

Pro wrestling star James ‘Kamala’ Harris dies at 70

Pro wrestling star James ‘Kamala’ Harris dies at 70

Powerful derecho leaves path of devastation across Midwest

Powerful derecho leaves path of devastation across Midwest

In virus talks, Pelosi holds firm; Mnuchin wants a deal

In virus talks, Pelosi holds firm; Mnuchin wants a deal

Hate crime victim arrested at protest won’t be prosecuted

Hate crime victim arrested at protest won’t be prosecuted

Confirmed coronavirus cases in the world reach 20 million.

Confirmed coronavirus cases in the world reach 20 million.

1 dead, 6 rescued after gas explosion levels Baltimore homes

1 dead, 6 rescued after gas explosion levels Baltimore homes

Most Read