Constitutional challenge set for New Brunswick court in cross-border beer battle

A New Brunswick man is preparing to launch a constitutional challenge over the right to buy his beer in Quebec, a case the defence says could have wider implications for interprovincial trade.

CAMPBELLTON, N.B. — A New Brunswick man is preparing to launch a constitutional challenge over the right to buy his beer in Quebec, a case the defence says could have wider implications for interprovincial trade.

Gerard Comeau, 62, will appear in court Tuesday for the start of a four-day hearing in Cambellton, N.B., after being charged with illegally importing alcohol into his home province.

The Tracadie resident was charged following an RCMP sting operation in October 2012.

Comeau was stopped by police with 12 cases of beer and three bottles of liquor, which he bought in Point-a-la-Croix, Que., across the river from Campbellton.

Comeau said he’s confident he has a strong case heading into court.

“I think so,” he said in a telephone interview. “According to the Canadian Constitution you can go do your shopping anywhere you want in the country.”

Constitutional lawyer Arnold Schwisberg will be part of a team arguing against Section 134 of the New Brunswick Liquor Control Act, which limits individuals to 12 bottles of beer purchased outside the province.

Schwisberg contends the provincial law is unconstitutional.

“Section 121 of our Constitution Act … specifies goods, produce and manufacture should be admitted free into all the other provinces,” said Schwisberg.

He said in Comeau’s case the liquor wasn’t admitted to the province, nor was it admitted free because it was confiscated by police and his client was fined.

“That’s what makes this particular case such a cause celebre and such a wonderful test case for the purposes of making this (constitutional) argument.”

Comeau is also supported by the Canadian Constitution Foundation, which believes the case will eventually result in a challenge before the Supreme Court of Canada.

Karen Selick, the foundation’s litigation director who will be in Campbellton as an observer, said a favourable ruling in Comeau’s case would have implications beyond the trade of alcohol.

“There are lots of other ways the provinces have over the years set up trade barriers that prevent goods from flowing from one province to another and we’d like to see those fall as well.”

Selick said regardless of how the New Brunswick court rules, there will likely be an appeal process launched that could end up before the nation’s highest court.

“I can’t imagine any kind of compromise decision that would satisfy both parties,” she said.

Should the case make it to Canada’s top court, Selick said it would have to deal with a 1921 decision that essentially upholds laws such as the one in New Brunswick.

Comeau said his two-hour trip to buy Quebec beer was no different from than those trips made daily by people who live just across the border. He went two or three times a year to buy alcohol that is up to 50 per cent cheaper than in New Brunswick.

“I don’t see any reason for buying surtax beer here just to give the government revenue,” said Comeau. “If the province wants people to buy beer here then they can put the price down.”

Just Posted

Alberta’s high court won’t change life sentence of man who killed seniors

EDMONTON — The Alberta Court of Appeal has dismissed a sentence appeal… Continue reading

Red Deer Dream Centre opponents won’t appeal its approval

Red Deer’s subdivision and development appeal board approves project

Rocky Mountain House pursuing amalgamation talks with neighbouring municipalities

Rocky Mountain House council made motion to start amalgamation talks in special council meeting

Tough economy reflected in central Alberta municipal budgets

Municipal councils are keeping tax rate increases low to provide some economic relief

Drug bust: Red Deer RCMP seize drugs, cash, vehicles

Criminals are getting creative. Red Deer RCMP have seized cash and vehicles… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Friday The Annual Old-Fashioned Country Christmas is being held Dec. 13 at… Continue reading

Alberta’s high court won’t change life sentence of man who killed seniors

EDMONTON — The Alberta Court of Appeal has dismissed a sentence appeal… Continue reading

Survey results suggest Ponoka residents are happy to live in the town

Survey interviewed 400 randomly selected residents

Extension of Molly Bannister Drive is unwanted

Re: “Survey seeks public input on contentious plan,” Dec. 11. Congratulations to… Continue reading

Opinion by Joe Ceci: Jason Kenney is raising your taxes and hoping you won’t know it’s him

Re: “Rural Alberta RCMP detachments getting 500 new positions,” Dec. 5. Jason… Continue reading

Hamilton welder to carry Canada colours at World Darts Championship in London

Canadian Matt Campbell is expecting a wild scene when he takes centre… Continue reading

More rowers come forward with complaints about coach, criticism of UVic

Sarah Craven had her sights set on the Olympics. The 21-year-old was… Continue reading

Eastwood on ‘Richard Jewell,’ criticism and finding stories

LOS ANGELES — For his film “Richard Jewell,” Clint Eastwood takes aim… Continue reading

Most Read