Halting legal proceedings against tobacco companies key to ensuring fairness: judge

TORONTO — An Ontario judge says he suspended legal proceedings against three tobacco giants to ensure a level playing field for all parties as the companies try to negotiate a settlement with their creditors.

Ontario Superior Court Justice Thomas McEwen released his reasons Tuesday for last week’s decision to uphold an order that halted any existing or new proceedings involving JTI-Macdonald Corp., Rothmans, Benson & Hedges and Imperial Tobacco Canada Ltd.

The companies were initially granted the stay last month as they sought creditor protection following the loss of a multibillion-dollar appeal in Quebec.

In March, Quebec’s highest court upheld an earlier, groundbreaking decision that ordered the companies to pay more than $15 billion to smokers in that province who took part in two class-action lawsuits.

The tobacco companies said the stay was necessary but lawyers representing the Quebec smokers argued the creditor protection process should be stopped if the companies plan to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Barring that, the lawyers asked that the court partially lift the stay to allow them to respond to any appeal proceedings.

Lawyers representing Ontario had sided with Quebec, but those representing several other provincial governments — all of them seeking to recover health-care costs related to smoking — said that would give those in one province a leg up over the others.

Last week, McEwen ruled the stay would remain in place but noted it would also prevent any of the companies from seeking leave to appeal to the Supreme Court while the creditor protection process is underway, unless they obtain the court’s permission. Any deadlines to apply for leave would also be extended during that time.

In his reasons Tuesday, the judge said it was the best way to ensure a fair process for all parties as they try to reach a deal.

Case law “clearly establishes the significant need to preserve the status quo between all stakeholders to preserve a level playing field and maximize the chances of obtaining resolution,” he wrote.

Allowing the companies to pursue appeals at the same time as they enter into settlement negotiations — as two of them sought to do — would “alter the status quo in their favour,” he said. The companies would be able to challenge the Quebec ruling but the stay would prevent the class-action members from replying, he said.

“This not only would affect the status quo but add an impediment to resolution” through creditor protection because it would distract the companies from negotiations, he wrote.

Partially lifting the stay to allow the Quebec class-action members to respond to any appeal applications would be unfair to the other plaintiffs, because it would allow them “to move further ahead and closer to resolution when the other actions are stayed,” McEwen said.

A blanket stay on legal proceedings that pauses any appeal applications while preserving the possibility of such applications down the line “would best preserve the status quo as it existed at the time of the filings and provide for the level playing field needed to attempt a resolution of all claims,” he said.

A hearing to deal with other issues in the case is scheduled for Thursday.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Pfizer posts 4Q loss, misses Street views, on lower revenue

Drugmaker Pfizer reported a $337 million loss in its fourth quarter after… Continue reading

UK to allow Huawei equipment in 5G networks but not in ‘core’ parts

LONDON — Britain decided Tuesday to give Huawei limited access to build… Continue reading

Birds flocking to national parks in the Canadian Rockies

BANFF, Alta. — It turns out tourists aren’t the only ones who… Continue reading

Country music fans enjoy free concert at Red Deer mall, ahead of ACMA awards

Fans like to get up close and personal and that’s exactly what… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Feb. 1 A Jump Rope Competition will be held at the Abbey… Continue reading

Virus in China affects sports events, Olympic qualifiers

GENEVA — Amid growing concern at the spread of a new virus… Continue reading

Ottawa 67’s boss Andre Tourigny gets call to coach Canada’s junior team

CALGARY — After serving as an assistant coach this year for Canada’s… Continue reading

Juno Awards nominees to be unveiled for music’s big night in Saskatoon

TORONTO — The 2020 Juno Awards nominees are set to be revealed… Continue reading

Harvey Weinstein NYC sex assault trial picks up pace

NEW YORK — The closely watched #Metoo era rape trial of Harvey… Continue reading

Calgary sport school that grooms Olympic champions threatened with shutdown

CALGARY — The National Sport School in Calgary that produces Olympic and… Continue reading

Quebec to seek consensus on offering medical aid in dying to mentally ill

MONTREAL — Quebec on Monday walked back a plan to offer medical… Continue reading

GOP defends Trump as Bolton book adds pressure for witnesses

WASHINGTON — Senators faced mounting pressure Monday to summon John Bolton to… Continue reading

Most Read