Minister attempts to clarify letter attacking environmentalists

Natural Resources Minister Joe Oliver says he isn’t opposed to all environmentalists — just the foreigner ones who are trying to damage Canada’s interest.

Natural Resources Minister Joe Oliver says he isn’t opposed to all environmentalists — just the foreigner ones who are trying to damage Canada’s interest.

“We are not demonizing,” Oliver said Monday after releasing a letter that referred to “environmental and other radical groups” trying to “hijack” with foreign money hearings on a pipeline that would bring Alberta oilsands bitumen to port at Kitimat, B.C.

“I have not called everybody radicals, nor do I think they are, nor do I think they’re trying to stop every kind of development. But there are some that do.

“I thought we’d just get the facts out without being politically correct about it.”

Environmentalists — who called Oliver’s letter everything from appalling to a hyperbolic rant — pointed out the vast majority of the people and money behind their campaign against the proposed Northern Gateway project is Canadian.

They released a poll taken last spring that suggests British Columbians are much more concerned about foreign money funding the oilpatch.

Policy experts criticized the letter for singling out Canadians who have concerns and wondered if the government is setting the stage for further attacks on environmentalists and the regulatory process.

“I’m appalled that the minister responsible for the National Energy Board would so brazenly demonize and discredit legitimate Canadian voices in this process,” said George Hoberg, a University of British Columbia political scientist who’s studied such issues for years. “It’s remarkable that they’re saying these things.”

Oliver said in the letter that foreign-funded environmentalists and jet-setting celebrities are trying to further a “radical ideological agenda” during hearings into Enbridge Inc.’s proposed (TSX:ENB) $5.5-billion proposed pipeline, which are to begin Tuesday.

“Their goal is to stop any major project — no matter what the cost to Canadian families in lost jobs and economic growth. No forestry. No mining. No oil. No gas. No more hydro-electric dams,” Oliver wrote.

In an interview, Oliver said he didn’t mean to describe all opponents that way.

“There are people with legitimate concerns and interests, including people in British Columbia on the coast. They have every right to express their legitimate concerns on environmental impact.”

Oliver’s targets shot back Monday, saying one man’s red tape is another man’s hard look.

“Although minister Oliver and Prime Minister Harper may think this is a dictatorship and whatever they say goes, it’s actually a democracy,” said Will Horter of the Dogwood Initiative, a Victoria-based group that opposes the pipeline.

“This aggressive language that they use with anybody who disagrees with them is indicative of their approach to governing.”

Environmentalists released an online poll of 830 adults taken last April that found about 15 per cent of respondents were concerned about U.S. funding of Canadian non-governmental organizations. The same poll found nearly 75 per cent of respondents were worried about Americans investing in Canadian natural resources.

The conservationists pointed to a series of polls over the last few years that consistently suggest about three-quarters of respondents oppose tanker traffic along B.C. coastlines. They say the great majority of their funding is Canadian — 80 per cent in the case of West Coast Environmental Law and 86 per cent for the Dogwood Initiative.

Oliver said he isn’t bothered by the hundreds of millions that flow into the Canadian oilpatch from everywhere from France to China.

“There is not enough capital in this country to finance (oilsands development), so we welcome capital from other countries. These are countries that are supplying billions of dollars of capital to help build critical infrastructure to help us in our overarching objective, which is to move our resources from where they are to the new markets.”

Jessica Clogg of West Coast Environmental Law said that if anyone is importing U.S. influences, it’s the pipeline advocates.

“In recent days, we’ve seen the petroleum industry advocates use misleading U.S.-style attack ads in an attempt to discredit the fierce local and First Nations opposition,” she said.

Green party Leader Elizabeth May wrote her own letter in which she suggested Oliver has been taken over by the “spin machine” in the prime minister’s office, which has in turn been hijacked by lobbyists from foreign oil companies.

“You should not have signed such a hyperbolic rant,” she wrote.

Just Posted

Update: Hundreds pay respects to Stettler homicide victim

Gofundme account created to help the Heritage House in Stettler

Victim Services information event planned

Information on becoming a Victim Service volunteer available at April 26 meeting

Much left to fight for beyond legalization, pot activists say as they mark 4-20

TORONTO — Cannabis activists say although this year’s 4-20 celebrations across the… Continue reading

Canadian Pacific starting operations shutdown ahead of possible strike

CALGARY — Canadian Pacific Railway says it has begun shutting down train… Continue reading

Nicholas Butcher says he fatally stabbed Kristin Johnston by accident

HALIFAX — Nicholas Butcher has told his second-degree murder trial that he… Continue reading

WATCH: Fine wine and food at Red Deer College

The Red Deer College Alumni Association hosted its 14th annual Fine Wine… Continue reading

Sarah Jessica Parker calls Cynthia Nixon’s run ‘exciting’

NEW YORK — Cynthia Nixon’s quest for the governorship of New York… Continue reading

Lawyers for Russian player say FIFA ends anti-doping case

By Graham Dunbar THE ASSOCIATED PRESS GENEVA — Lawyers for Russia defender… Continue reading

Woman who lost pink house, court case seeks box office win

WASHINGTON — Susette Kelo’s Supreme Court case now has a Hollywood ending,… Continue reading

Recent retail sales far weaker than initial estimates, revisions suggest

OTTAWA — Canadian retail sales during the crucial holiday shopping season were… Continue reading

U.S. woman sentenced to life in Valentine’s Day shooting plot at mall

HALIFAX — An American woman who plotted to go on a Valentine’s… Continue reading

Alabama mail-bomber the oldest executed in US modern times

ATMORE, Ala. — An Alabama man convicted of sending mail bombs during… Continue reading

The Latest: It was Putin call that had Trump fuming at Flynn

WASHINGTON — The Latest on former FBI Director James Comey’s memos (all… Continue reading

Boston’s Tuukka Rask, Riley Nash step up in Game 4 win over Leafs

Bruins 3 Maple Leafs 1 TORONTO — The Boston Bruins didn’t need… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month