Oilsands emissions not so bad: reports

CALGARY — Two new government-funded reports suggest that oilsands oil doesn’t create that many more greenhouse gas emissions than other conventional crude sources when everything is taken into consideration.

CALGARY — Two new government-funded reports suggest that oilsands oil doesn’t create that many more greenhouse gas emissions than other conventional crude sources when everything is taken into consideration.

The reports, released Thursday, say that oil from oilsands creates from 10 per cent to 45 per cent more greenhouse gas than other oil imported into the U.S. when everything from exploration to burning in a car engine is taken into account.

But environmentalists counter the studies only confirm that the oilsands generate the most carbon-intensive fuel around.

They add the reports downplay how much more greenhouse gas is emitted as oilsands oil is produced.

“When you look on the full cycle like that, it diminishes the apparent differences that are caused by the source of the oil,” said Dan Woynillowicz of the environmental think-tank Pembina Institute.

The reports examined a wide variety of crude oils that are commonly imported into the U.S. and some from American sources.

It found, when all direct emissions from well to tailpipe are considered, oilsands oil creates at best 10 per cent more greenhouse gas than conventional crude. Depending on the source of the crude, that figure could go as high as 45 per cent higher.

The reports also point out that carbon emissions from conventional oil are rising, as resource pools get harder and harder to exploit.

On the other hand, oilsands emissions are declining on a per-barrel basis as the industry improves and becomes more efficient.

The reports were an attempt to put some hard, specific numbers around the climate change impact of various fuel sources as the U.S. country works toward policies on greenhouse gas emissions.

“Numbers were being assumed for conventional crudes and we decided to do this study to ensure we understood the comparison,” said Eddy Isaacs of the Alberta Energy Research Institute, the government body that funded the studies.

“We were hoping we would put the facts on the table so that (as) policy-makers are considering how they set up the low-carbon fuel standards, at least they know that this is a complex business to measure them.”

At least one American wasn’t convinced.

“I think they’re underestimating the U.S. audience,” said Susan Casey-Lefkowitz of the Washington-based Natural Resources Defence Council.

“(Americans) are going to see (the reports) indeed confirm that tarsands oil has very high greenhouse gas emissions. It’s still the dirtiest.”

Woynillowicz pointed out that a gallon of gas has the same carbon footprint whether it was refined from sweet Saudi Arabian crude or oilsands bitumen. Including those emissions in the overall figure, from well to tailpipe, dilutes the fact that so much more carbon is emitted during oilsands production.

Comparing well-to-tank emissions is much clearer way of comparing fuel sources, Woynillowicz said.

Just Posted

Cannabis legalization won’t impact one Red Deer pot dispensary

Nothing changes for Compass Cannabis Clinic in Red Deer despite legalization

Cannabis retail store will open later in October in Red Deer

Two cannabis stores coming to downtown Red Deer

Neighbours drop opposition to Red Deer County communications tower

Communication tower to be located in Balmoral Heights

Legal cannabis comes with many unknowns: Red Deer County councillors

Councillors question how rural municipalities will be able to enforce cannabis regulations

Kitten season puts pressure on Red Deer shelter

More public education needed to control cat population

WATCH: Two weeks away from Canadian Finals Rodeo in Red Deer

In just two weeks, Ponoka’s Shayna Weir will compete with the best… Continue reading

‘Start low, go slow’: Experts walk bud beginners through cannabis 101

With the countdown to cannabis legalization Wednesday ticking towards 4-20, some novice… Continue reading

NHL stays with status quo as Canada pot legalization looms

As Riley Cote took and delivered countless punches over more than a… Continue reading

Paul Stanley: Kiss farewell tour could include ex-members

ATLANTIC CITY, N.J. — It won’t be all night, but former members… Continue reading

Judge tosses Stormy Daniels’ defamation suit against Trump

WASHINGTON — A federal judge dismissed Stormy Daniels’ defamation lawsuit against President… Continue reading

Canada open to growing trade with China now that USMCA is a done deal: PM

TORONTO — Canada is open to doing more business with China now… Continue reading

Pot shop raids “highly unlikely” on Wednesday: head of police chiefs

VANCOUVER — Police departments across Canada are fully prepared for marijuana legalization… Continue reading

Campers will be able to smoke cannabis at campsites in Canada’s national parks

Parks Canada says visitors should do their research on cannabis before going… Continue reading

U.S. pot firms urge Trump to deny Canadian producers’ ‘competitive advantage’

WASHINGTON — An American cannabis producer is warning President Donald Trump that… Continue reading

Most Read