Ontario shipyard withdraws complaint alleging federal favouritism toward Davie

OTTAWA — An Ontario shipyard has dropped a request for an investigation into whether the federal government tried to rig its plan to add a third yard to its multibillion-dollar shipbuilding strategy in favour of Quebec rival Chantier Davie.

The move by Hamilton-based Heddle Marine comes only a few weeks after the government invoked a controversial national-security exception that prevents such investigations by the Canadian International Trade Tribunal.

The tribunal’s role is to ensure the government follows proper procurement rules, including adhering to Canada’s obligations under international trade law and free-trade agreements.

In an interview, Heddle Marine president Shaun Padulo said his company decided to drop its complaint after lawyers determined there was no point in continuing after the exception was invoked.

The tribunal was still formulating an official response to the government’s use of the exception, which the Liberal government quietly expanded over the summer without any consultation with industry or experts.

“What we were advised is that based on the law, that national-security exception, there’s nothing that we could really do to fight it,” Padulo told The Canadian Press.

“They said that this would not be a fight that we could win and it would not accomplish anything to protest the national-security exception. So our best bet is to wait to see what the government’s next steps are.”

The federal government launched its high-stakes search for a third yard to join Halifax’s Irving Shipbuilding and Seaspan Marine in Vancouver in Canada’s so-called national shipbuilding strategy in August.

The winning yard could be awarded billions of dollars in work associated with building at least six new icebreakers for the Canadian Coast Guard and stands to gain much more in future work as well.

Heddle alleged in its complaint that many of the requirements the government said shipyards must meet to qualify for consideration were not legitimate or reasonable — and would disqualify virtually every yard but Davie, which is across the St. Lawrence River from Quebec City.

The federal procurement department subsequently amended some of the requirements, but Heddle asked the tribunal to press ahead with its probe.

It was at that point that the government invoked the national-security exception. In June, the government had rewritten regulations so it could invoke the exception without having to give a justification.

That change came without warning or consultation with industry — and despite previous concerns from the tribunal about an excessive use of such exemptions as well as requests the government limit their use.

While the government did not lay out to the tribunal why the exception was invoked in this case, Fisheries and Oceans Canada spokeswoman Ashley Jackson said it was to ensure the protection of Canada’s “national-security interests.”

“The ships will be used for a wide variety of security-related work such as supporting law-enforcement activities, national and international fisheries patrols, Arctic sovereignty, and maritime-domain awareness,” Jackson said.

“In the past, the coast guard has applied the national-security exception to the projects acquiring the polar icebreaker, medium icebreakers and helicopters.”

Heddle’s complaint aside, the changes to the exception should be a concern to all Canadians given how much the government spends on goods and services each year, said Christopher McLeod, the head of commercial litigation at Mann Lawyers in Ottawa.

“Having an open, fair and transparent system for the government to procure those goods and services is fundamentally important,” said McLeod, who successfully challenged the exception in a previous case in 2016.

That challenge prompted the trade tribunal to begin more closely scrutinizing the government’s reasons for invoking the exception — until the new rules came in saying the government doesn’t have to give any.

“The regulations introduced this summer are a giant step backwards when it comes to fairness, openness and transparency,” McLeod said.

“It’s not like the federal government is simply ignoring a loophole that allows unfairness, they have actually gone back and re-opened a loophole that the (trade tribunal) has previously tried to close.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

RCMP investigate possible drowning at Pigeon Lake: Man and woman found dead on shore

Bodies recovered from Pigeon Lake’s northeastern shores.

Red Deer Region Highland Dancing Association to participate in national dance-a-thon

Central Albertan dancers have missed performing during the COVID-19 pandemic, says the… Continue reading

Maskwacis teen charged in 10-year-old boy’s death

The RCMP Major Crimes Unit have laid a manslaughter charge against a 13-year-old boy from Maskwacis.

Still no mandatory masks in Red Deer

While a growing number of Alberta communities have made masks mandatory, the… Continue reading

Cast your votes for Best of Red Deer

The Advocate’s Best of Red Deer Readers’ Choice Awards are back. Community… Continue reading

69 salmonella cases in B.C. linked to red onions, province’s CDC says

VANCOUVER — The BC Centre for Disease Control is warning people in… Continue reading

Puncher’s chance: Fighting is up during unique NHL playoffs

The Toronto Maple Leafs’ season was hanging by a thread from one… Continue reading

Quebec festivals organizers look to innovate as restrictions loosened

Montreal has been having its quietest summer in recent memory, as COVID-19… Continue reading

COVID-19 outbreaks over in federal prisons, staff preparing for ‘new normal’

COVID-19 outbreaks in Canada’s federal prisons have been declared over, and staff… Continue reading

Canada to match donations to Lebanon relief

OTTAWA — The federal government will match all individual donations from Canadians… Continue reading

Protests in Beirut amid public fury over massive blast

BEIRUT — Police fired tear gas and clashed with demonstrators in Lebanon’s… Continue reading

Most Read