Plains Midstream charged for 2011 pipeline spill

The Canadian arm of a U.S.-based pipeline company is facing environmental charges related to a massive leak that spilled millions of litres of oil into wetlands and shut down a school in northwestern Alberta.

EDMONTON — The Canadian arm of a U.S.-based pipeline company is facing environmental charges related to a massive leak that spilled millions of litres of oil into wetlands and shut down a school in northwestern Alberta.

Plains Midstream Canada faces three counts under the provincial Environmental Protection and Enhancement Act, which allows for maximum fines of $500,000.

The April 2011 breach, about 95 kilometres northeast of Peace River, released 4.5 million litres of oil and was blamed for powerful smells in the community of Little Buffalo that residents said caused headaches and stomach problems and kept schoolchildren at home for days.

It was Alberta’s largest leak in 36 years.

The charges Friday came days before Greenpeace had planned to release results of its extensive examination of hundreds of pages of documents into how the provincial energy regulator and the government handled the Plains leak.

Greenpeace spokesman Keith Stewart said the main conclusions — that the Alberta government and the Energy Resources Conservation Board have grown too cosy with industry — remain valid.

Plains Midstream Canada was harshly criticized in an investigation report released last February by the energy conservation board that said Plains did a poor job assessing the risks associated with the pipeline, failed to maintain it properly and didn’t have an sufficient response plan in case of problems. The board added that earlier repairs probably contributed to the leak and it faulted the company for having inadequately trained staff and ineffective supervision.

“Plains Midstream Canada has received and is now evaluating the charges arising out of this matter,” the company said in a release Friday. “We will be reviewing them with our counsel and the Crown, and will respond formally with our position in due course.”

The Greenpeace report outlines examples which it says demonstrates how officials were more concerned with protecting the image of a besieged industry than protecting the public.

It points out the board’s own reviewers recommended on Sept. 13, 2011, that a public inquiry into the spill be held — a recommendation that was squelched by the board’s chief operating officer three weeks later.

The environmental group also suggests that the board misrepresented air-quality data from the Little Buffalo school, quoting a board statement that “based on the current data, there is no evidence that the air quality poses risk of long-term health impact at this time.”

In fact, the air quality report said the monitoring station was upwind of the spill at the time it took its readings.

“Thus, we are unable at this time using the data collected … May 5 to infer the impact of the oil spill on air quality at the school,” says the report.

Greenpeace also pointed out contradictions between the board’s report and what Energy Minister Ken Hughes was told privately. While the board concluded “contaminated water was not migrating off site,” a May 6, 2011, briefing note to Hughes said “there are some exceedances of hydrocarbons downstream from the wetlands.”

Finally, Greenpeace quotes a May 31, 2011, briefing note to then-premier Ed Stelmach that the group says contradicts assurances given to the public: “Full restoration of the localized area is unlikely,” the briefing note says.

Board spokesman Bob Curran responded that administration decided that an investigation was a better way to handle the situation than an inquiry. He said the board’s report and supporting documentation is available online.

Accusations the board has been “captured” by industry aren’t new, Curran said.

He pointed out that in addition to the board’s strongly worded investigation report, the Plains Midstream line was shut down for the better part of four months — an action the board estimates cost the company and its customers about $850 million.

“I don’t think a captive regulator would do that,” Curran said. “Enforcement is a serious thing in Alberta and companies take it seriously.”

Energy Minister Ken Hughes likewise rejected the Greenpeace charges.

“The expectation from the government of Alberta has been and continues to be that the province’s regulator works on behalf of all Albertans to ensure responsible energy development and a clean and healthy environment,” he said in an email. “I have every confidence that this will continue under the leadership of Alberta’s new single regulator.”

Stewart said there are enough red flags about how the Plains Midstream leak was handled to raise concerns about that new regulator, which comes into effect this summer and will be headed by Gerry Protti, a former energy executive and lobbyist who was the industry’s representative in designing the new approach.

The energy board is investigating a second pipeline spill involving Plains Midstream. Last June’s breach leaked up to 475,000 litres of oil into the Red Deer River near Sundre in central Alberta.

A review of pipeline safety called by Hughes last summer has not been publicly released. Nor have plans for public consultation that Hughes promised in November.

Previous charges against energy companies have typically been settled through a guilty plea and a corporate donation to an environmental project.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

An Air Canada Boeing 737 MAX 8 jet arrives at Halifax Stanfield International Airport on Friday, April 9, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan
Air Canada agrees to $5.9-billion aid package, giving Ottawa equity stake in airline

$1.4 billion earmarked to help reimburse thousands of customers

Innisfail RCMP say Brandon Pitts is missing. (Photo contributed)
Missing central Alberta man

Innisfail RCMP request public’s help

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau shakes hands with Yukon Premier Sandy Silver as Liberal on Wednesday February 8, 2017 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Yukon headed for minority government as two main parties in a tie

Liberals came into the election looking to build on their surprise 2016 majority win

Minister of National Defence Harjit Sajjan takes part in a year-end interview with The Canadian Press at National Defence headquarters in Ottawa on Thursday, Dec. 17, 2020. Sajjan took aim at recent Chinese military expansions into the South China Sea this evening even as he faced questions about the Liberal government’s ties to Beijing. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Sajjan targets Chinese claims in South China Sea, battles Tories over Beijing ties

HMCS Calgary shadowed for at least part of the voyage as it passed near the disputed Spratly Islands

Transport trucks approach the Canada/USA border crossing in Windsor, Ont. on Saturday, March 21, 2020. North American trade is facing a “critical moment” in the ongoing aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, say Canadian business leaders as they embark on a concerted campaign to fortify ties with the United States. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Rob Gurdebeke
Canada-U.S. trade faces ‘critical moment’ that demands urgent action, businesses warn

Will fall to Canada to ensure its best interests are represented

FILE-Team Canada’s Meaghan Mikkelson fights for control of the puck with U.S.A.’s Hayley Scamurra during third period of Women’s Rivalry Series hockey action in Vancouver, Wednesday, February 5, 2020. Gina Kingsbury, Hockey Canada’s director of women’s national teams, hopes a Rivalry Series against the United States can happen this winter.THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP/Michael Dwyer
Canadian women’s hockey team to open selection camp in Nova Scotia

Six goaltenders, 15 defenders and 26 forwards will vie for spots on Canada’s 23-player roster

FILE - Rhian Wilkinson, left, and Melissa Tancredi of Canada’s women’s soccer team attend a news conference in Vancouver, Friday, Jan. 13, 2017 to announce their retirement from the team. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
Former Canadian international Rhian Wilkinson now part of England coaching setup

Wilkinson left Canada Soccer in January to join interim England head coach Hege Riise as an assistant

Canadian actor/producer/director Jay Baruchel is photographed at the 5 Drive-In Theatre in Oakville, Ont., ahead of the premier of Baruchel’s movie Random Acts of Violence, Wednesday, July 29, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Cole Burston
Jay Baruchel to host Amazon Prime Video’s ‘LOL: Last One Laughing Canada’

Final comedian left standing wins a grand prize for a charity of their choice

Letters
Letter: Leaders like MLA Jason Stephan should work towards greater good

Red Deer South MLA Jason Stephan talks about the devastating social and… Continue reading

Opinion
Opinion: Women, hit hardest by pandemic, key to economic recovery

Events of the past year have laid bare the many disparities and… Continue reading

Children at the Port Angeles Boys & Girls Club practice social distancing throughout the day to minimize the spreading of germs and potentially the coronavirus. Photo courtesy of the Boys & Girls Clubs of the Olympic Peninsula
Opinion: Teach young people these five principles

At all ages, young people may be the subject of mean behaviours… Continue reading

LtE bug
Letter: MLAs need to think about all Albertans

I was surprised to find more than a dozen UCP MLAs were… Continue reading

Most Read