Quebec taxi industry seeks injunction against Uber

Quebec's taxi industry went to court Tuesday to seek a permanent injunction against Uber that is also aimed at deactivating the company's app throughout the province.

MONTREAL — Quebec’s taxi industry went to court Tuesday to seek a permanent injunction against Uber that is also aimed at deactivating the company’s app throughout the province.

Uber’s drivers are breaking the law and the company’s services are illegal, lawyer Marc-Antoine Cloutier told a news conference outside the Montreal courthouse.

The drivers don’t need a permit, as required by the law, he argued.

Benoit Jugand, a taxi-industry spokesman, urged the Quebec government to start cracking down on Uber.

“It’s not normal that the industry must take care of what’s supposed to be done by the government,” he said. “It’s simple: taxi is legal and Uber is illegal. The law says it. The law is clear. We simply want the law to be applied.”

Jugand and Cloutier both said Uber’s service has nothing in common with the practice of people giving their neighbours a lift into work free of charge.

“Ride-sharing is well-defined with the transportation law,” Jugand said. “It says you need to share transport but you just share your gas. But giving calls to somebody who’s taking you from point A to point B is clearly taxi business.”

A spokesman for Uber Canada said the “protectionist” suit is without merit and is aimed at preserving the “monopoly of the taxi industry to the detriment of consumers.”

“We believe that Quebecers deserve an alternative transportation option that is safe, reliable and affordable and that taxi and ride-sharing can complement each other to better serve the needs of users,” Jean-Christophe de Le Rue said in a statement.

Uber also argues that developing a mobile app that lets customers hail nearby cars makes it a technology company rather than a transportation firm.

The controversy surrounding Uber has raged across the country, with Edmonton city council approving a bylaw last week that would allow it and similar companies to operate legally.

The bylaw takes effect March 1 and includes two licences: one for firms called private transportation providers and the other for taxis.

In other Uber-related developments Tuesday:

— Ontario’s insurance regulator approved coverage for drivers using ride-hailing services such as Uber, even before the province’s legislature decides whether such services are legal. The Insurance Bureau of Canada says the new insurance offering is the first coverage of its kind in the country.

The Financial Services Commission of Ontario gave Aviva Canada the green light to offer coverage for drivers carrying paying passengers in their own vehicles.

— And about 200 taxi drivers gathered on Parliament Hill to ask Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to shut down Uber operations.

“They’re doing the work they do illegally,” said Ottawa driver Admassu Abebe.

“They’re destroying a legitimate business but also socially they are making all kinds of problems … I am hopeful that maybe the federal government, Justin Trudeau, might be able to advise provinces or municipalities to enforce the law.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Comments are closed

Just Posted

Provincial watchdog probes often don’t lead to charges against police

An analysis of data from civilian police watchdogs in Canada shows that… Continue reading

Germany finalizing plan to phase out coal energy

BERLIN — Germany’s parliament was preparing Friday to pass new legislation finalizing… Continue reading

Le Chateau starts work on producing 500,000 hospital gowns in Canada

MONTREAL — Le Chateau Inc. says it has started the manufacturing of… Continue reading

Brazilian cowboy to finish trek from Alaska to Calgary with Stampede honour

CALGARY — Brazilian long rider Filipe Masetti Leite is almost at the… Continue reading

Red Deer remains at two active COVID-19 cases

Alberta confirms 94 new cases over past two days

‘This year is unlike any other’: Trudeau delivers Canada day address

Sophie Gregoire Trudeau and the Prime Minister release video celebrating the national holiday

Michael Dawe: Canada Day festivities have been interfered with before

Because of the restrictions imposed as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic,… Continue reading

Save-On-Foods stores donate to Red Deer Food Bank

Thanks to some hungry central Albertans, the Red Deer Food Bank is… Continue reading

8-month wait almost over for resumption of Chinese soccer

An eight-month wait for the new Chinese Super League to start is… Continue reading

Eastwood’s ankle forced production shift for ‘The Outpost’

LONDON — An accident requiring two screws in his ankle nearly prevented… Continue reading

Patrick Watson says Indigenous acknowledgment ‘censored’ from Canada Day show

MONTREAL — Singer-songwriter Patrick Watson says Heritage Canada edited out a land… Continue reading

Canadian engineer released from Egypt needs treatment, family says

Canadian engineer released from Egypt needs treatment, family says

Inquiry into mass shooting in Nova Scotia facing delays due to ‘technicalities’

Inquiry into mass shooting in Nova Scotia facing delays due to ‘technicalities’

Quebec tractor driver charged after accident kills three children, injures seven

Quebec tractor driver charged after accident kills three children, injures seven

Most Read