Second Cup franchisees file lawsuit against coffee chain over debt, ad fund

A group of Second Cup Ltd. franchisees is each suing the struggling Canadian coffee chain for $300,000, alleging the company’s actions have been detrimental to them.

The current and past franchisees outline a long list of complaints against their franchisor in a lawsuit filed earlier this month in the Superior Court of Quebec.

None of the allegations has been proven in court, and the company as well as its lawyer declined to comment.

“It is not Second Cup’s practice to comment on matters that are actively before the court, particularly when, as in this instance, they are at a very early stage of the proceedings,” wrote spokeswoman Ali Azzopardi in an email.

While the company has seen positive change over the past three years as it’s attempted to win back customers, franchisees continue to suffer, according to the lawsuit.

“On the contrary, during these three years franchise revenues have continued to decline,” documents read.

The company allegedly misused a franchisee-funded advertising reserve, it said. Franchisees must pay the equivalent of two to three per cent of their sales to the ad fund.

“Second Cup does not use this money in an adequate manner to advertise and fails to fulfil its contractual obligations to that end,” read the court documents.

The coffee chain also forced franchisees to acquire debt to pay for equipment that failed to boost sales, according to the suit, such as equipment needed to sell Pinkberry brand frozen yogurt treats.

Second Cup signed an exclusive licensing agreement with Pinkberry in September 2017 to roll out the brand at its cafes after testing the concept at four locations that summer. It is now served at 84 Canadian stores, as of Nov. 5, and the company has said the yogurt is an important contributor to overall sales and transactions.

Franchises “swimming in debt suddenly went further in debt,” according to the claim.

“Not only was the increase in franchise sales disappointing, it turned out that Second Cup customers were either having coffee or a Pinkberry smoothie, but not both.”

The plaintiffs also alleged product problems, including being required to purchase products at a “far higher” price than what it is worth on the market, stock shortages thanks to supplier changes, and “problematic” food quality.

They asked for $300,000 in damages per plaintiff. That includes $75,000 per year for three years’ of lost revenues, and another $75,000 in advertising costs, according to documents.

The suit stems from an original claim by one Second Cup franchisee against the company that eight other franchisees later asked to join.

It is not currently clear how many plaintiffs are involved in the suit.

Second Cup filed a document last week arguing the additional plaintiffs should be treated separately from the first claim.

“… Each claim is extremely fact-specific in connection with a given franchisee location and a given plaintiff-franchisee relationship and would not be able to be tried at the same time and determined on the same evidence,” according to documents.

Second Cup has been struggling amid increased competition from both high-end coffee purveyors and fast-food chains offering caffeine jolts.

It recently launched a strategic review of the company and announced plans to sell recreational cannabis. It is in the process of converting two Alberta stores to recreational cannabis dispensaries as part of a joint venture with a cannabis firm. It has identified many more Ontario locations as attractive candidates for such conversions.

The coffee chain is not alone in facing disgruntled franchisees. Restaurant Brands International, the parent company of Tim Hortons, has grappled with an unsanctioned, outspoken franchisee group for more than a year.

The Great White North Franchisee Association claims to represent more than half of Canada’s Tim Hortons franchisees. It formed in an effort to remedy alleged mismanagement of the brand and since its inception launched multiple lawsuits against the parent company, its subsidiaries and several executives. Among other things, it has also alleged mismanagement of the chain’s advertising fund — a claim the company has denied. RBI has also filed lawsuits against the group and some of its members.

Just Posted

Red Deer woman lives 102 years with humour, ‘gentle strength’ — and porridge

Minnie Deibert was surrounded by family and friends at her birthday party Sunday

Boy escapes serious injury after falling from third-storey window

SURREY, B.C. — A little boy is very lucky to have escaped… Continue reading

Harmonic singing for young women will be taught at a fall workshop in Red Deer

The Hearts of Harmony Chorus is presenting the Nov. 16 session

‘Crying out for help:’ Calgary radicalization program evolves to help others

CALGARY — The soft-spoken young man wasn’t being recruited by neo-Nazis or… Continue reading

Victoria pledges to plant 5,000 trees as part of United Nations challenge

Victoria is promising to plant 5,000 trees on public and private land… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Tuesday Bower Place Community Association Seniors Card and Coffee party at 1:30… Continue reading

Liberals pitch middle-class savings as second full week of campaign beckons

OTTAWA — The Liberals tried to turn the page on Justin Trudeau’s… Continue reading

Democrats blast latest Trump crisis. But what will they do?

WASHINGTON — A whistleblower’s complaint over President Donald Trump’s interactions with a… Continue reading

Face transplant recipient’s donor face now failing

MANCHESTER, N.H. — A woman who was severely burned in a domestic… Continue reading

Charity boat with 182 migrants waits to dock in Europe

A non-profit-run ship carrying 182 migrants rescued on the Mediterranean Sea sailed… Continue reading

Singh-Trudeau meeting will be private, say Liberals, but no time set yet

OTTAWA — The Liberal Party pledged Saturday to keep private the details… Continue reading

Glen Assoun calls for reform in how Ottawa considers cases of wrongful conviction

HALIFAX — Tethered to an ankle monitor and alone in a British… Continue reading

No winning ticket for Saturday nights $9 million Lotto 649 jackpot

TORONTO — There was no winning ticket for the $9 million jackpot… Continue reading

Most Read