Wind Mobile, federal government appeal court ruling

MONTREAL — Wind Mobile will be at the centre of a legal case on Wednesday that questions how the federal cabinet intervened to allow the mobile phone carrier to operate in Canada, despite a CRTC ruling that decided it was foreign owned.

MONTREAL — Wind Mobile will be at the centre of a legal case on Wednesday that questions how the federal cabinet intervened to allow the mobile phone carrier to operate in Canada, despite a CRTC ruling that decided it was foreign owned.

“Obviously, we will fight in the courts as far as we can,” Wind Mobile chairman Anthony Lacavera said of the case, which will be heard in the Federal Court of Appeal in Ottawa.

Wind Mobile and the federal government are appealing a decision that cabinet overstepped its authority when it let the Toronto telecom company go into business in December 2009 after the national regulator had already ruled it wasn’t Canadian owned.

Lacavera also said it could mean taking the case to the Supreme Court, or going back to the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission to satisfy ownership requirements if he loses the appeal case.

“At the end of the day, there’s no scenario where Wind gets shut down,” Lacavera said.

Wind Mobile has almost 300,000 mobile phone customers and says it’s on track to have 1.5 million subscribers in three years. It’s aiming to be Canada’s fourth major wireless carrier after Rogers, (TSX:RCI.B), Bell (TSX:BCE) and Telus (TSX:T).

Back in October 2009, the CRTC said that Wind’s parent company Globalive didn’t meet Canadian ownership and control requirements to operate as a telecommunications carrier.

Egyptian telecom company Orascom owns 65 per cent of Globalive and holds the majority of its debt, a structure accepted by Industry Canada when Wind Mobile’s licence was originally granted, but the sticking point for the CRTC when ruling it wasn’t Canadian.

Rival wireless company Public Mobile took the issue of telecom ownership rules involving Wind Mobile to the courts. In February, the Federal Court of Canada quashed Industry Minister Tony Clement’s order-in-cabinet to overrule the CRTC.

Lacavera maintains the February court decision ruled the government didn’t follow the “correct legal procedure” when it issued the 2009 order-in-council that allowed Wind Mobile to go into business, and that his company is Canadian owned.

NDP member Brian Masse, who has been following the case, said there needs to be a level playing field for new wireless players.

“The objective was to have new entrants enter the market in a fair way that would increase competition and lower prices for consumers,” said Masse, who represents the Ontario riding of Windsor-West.

“Well that entire thing has been defeated by the way this government has handled the situation,” Masse said. “Instead, that story is trying to be sorted out through the court system.”

Masse said Wind Mobile should have been told by Industry Minister Tony Clement that it had to go back to the CRTC to satisfy ownership requirements.

“That way Wind and its competitors that were entering the market could have felt more comfortable with the competitive process and we could have moved past the speculation of throwing industry progress to the court system.”

It’s going to be tough for the majority Conservative government to move ahead quickly with relaxing foreign ownership rules with this case in the courts, Masse said.

“The problem is if they want to do that now, they have the fly in the ointment that is this case.”

Telecom lawyer Lorne Abugov said the CRTC and Industry Canada along with the federal cabinet reached two “diametrically different” conclusions under essentially the same ownership and control laws.

“Purely from a structural point of view, it seems to be needless double jeopardy,” said Abugov, who’s based in Ottawa.

“I am talking about the larger issue of the inherent weakness in the existing law that would allow a circumstance like this to happen.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Bloc Québécois MP Sebastien Lemire rises during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Friday, March 12, 2021. A Bloc Québécois MP has apologized for taking a screen shot of a Liberal MP who inadvertently appeared nude during virtual proceedings in the House of Commons last week. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Bloc Québécois MP apologizes for taking nude photo of Liberal MP William Amos

‘I have no idea how that photo made its way into the media’

FILE - This Sunday, June 25, 2017, file photo shows TK Holdings Inc. headquarters in Auburn Hills, Mich. A driver in South Carolina is the latest person to be killed by an exploding Takata air bag inflator. Honda says that a faulty driver’s air bag blew apart in a crash involving a 2002 Honda Accord in Lancaster County, South Carolina. The company wouldn’t give details of the Jan. 9, 2021, crash near Charlotte, North Carolina, nor would it identify the person who was killed. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya, File)
South Carolina driver killed by exploding air bag inflator

Drivers can check to see if their vehicles have been recalled

Hospital staff shift the body of a COVID-19 patient on a stretcher to a waiting ambulance at a specialized COVID-19 hospital in Noida, a suburb of New Delhi, India, Wednesday, April 21, 2021. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
Low on beds, oxygen, India adds global high 314K virus cases

Government rushing oxygen tankers to replenish hospital supplies

A traveler wearing a protective mask, due to the COVID-19 outbreak, walks through the nearly empty JetBlue terminal at Logan Airport in Boston, Friday, May 29, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP, Charles Krupa
JetBlue expanding wings with service to Vancouver from New York and Boston

JetBlue will have to compete with Canadian airlines

Green Party MP Elizabeth May arrives on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, Sept. 24, 2020. An emergency parliamentary debate that was supposed to be a forum for cross-party collaboration on better ways to combat the COVID-19 pandemic has devolved into another round of partisan finger-pointing. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Emergency parliamentary debate on pandemic devolves into partisan finger-pointing

‘Let’s work together instead of playing terrible politics in this debate’

Westerner Park’s Exhibition Hall was used as a vaccination clinic on Wednesday. A steady stream of people came to get their COVID-19 shots either by appointment or as walk-ins. Photo by PAUL COWLEY/Advocate staff
No long lineups at walk-in vaccination site in Red Deer

A steady stream of people walked into Westerner Park on Wednesday to… Continue reading

FILE - In this March 19, 2021, file photo, people take pictures of the Olympic rings installed by the Japan Olympic Museum in Tokyo. The vaccine rollout in Japan has been very slow with less than 1% vaccinated. This of course is spilling over to concerns about the postponed Tokyo Olympics that open in just over three months.(AP Photo/Hiro Komae, File)
Olympic bodies launch competitive series in virtual sports

Olympic body hopes to reach more young people

Linda Tomlinson
Gardening: Leave the lawn until the soil is dry

Spring is arriving, Alberta style with warm days, cold days and snow.… Continue reading

Silent protests were held recently in response to Red Deer Public Schools’ decision to reject a Pride Week in favour of a Diversity Week. Some former employees at Red Deer Public are saying the decision is misguided. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Letter: School board silencing Pride Week concern

While it has been our practice to not comment on matters arising… Continue reading

Anderson scores twice as Canadiens down Oilers 4-3

Anderson scores twice as Canadiens down Oilers 4-3

New York Liberty guard Kia Nurse (5) shoots next to Indiana Fever's Kamiah Smalls during the first half of a WNBA basketball game Thursday, Sept. 10, 2020, in Bradenton, Fla. Nurse isn't just one of Canada's finest female basketball players, she's becoming a popular voice of the game as well. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP -Phelan M. Ebenhack
Canadian basketball star Nurse is carving out space in sports broadcasting at just 25

Canadian basketball star Nurse is carving out space in sports broadcasting at just 25

Most Read