Opinion: Cancellation of Bighorn Country meetings is a big mistake

The reported nastiness of a few Albertans shouldn’t prevent ordinary people from having their say.

The provincial government’s decision to cancel a series of town hall meetings to discuss the protection and management of Bighorn Country is a mistake.

The idea of a town hall meeting is for government officials to meet face to face with the public, and to some extent, to be held accountable for the proposals they bring forward for discussion.

In this case, the NDP government was to host meetings in Drayton Valley, Red Deer, Sundre and Edmonton to explain its proposal to create Bighorn Wildland Provincial Park and three others adjacent to Banff and Jasper national parks­.

This is a classic example of what politics, at its heart, is all about: the distribution of scarce resources. The intention to set aside lands for parks has run up against the concerns of outdoor recreationists and industry.

Whether one supports their concerns or not, it’s obvious the proposal to restrict the use of Alberta’s public lands would meet with some opposition.

Instead of acknowledging that reality, and welcoming the discussion, the NDP has decided to cancel the town hall meetings, replacing them with two phone-in exercises.

The government cites concern for public safety for its decision to quash the opportunity for proper public input, saying comments on social media have become worrisome.

“This has led to significant misinformation on the status and substance of the proposal for Bighorn Country and, more recently, allegations of bullying, abuse and concerns over personal safety,” Environment Minister Shannon Phillips said.

“I have heard stories of Albertans afraid to attend community events, Albertans berated in public, Albertans followed home, and Albertans feeling intimidated to not speak their mind or participate in this important discussion.

“These reports are not only deeply concerning, this behaviour is not reflective of the values we all share.”

The minister is correct in her observations, of course. Albertans have always bristled when they’ve been denied a voice, as they should now.

Those who support the government’s vision for nurturing a tremendously important part of Alberta’s natural areas should be able to speak up, free of intimidation.

And those who have concerns about limits on their ability to enjoy the wild space for their own enjoyment should have free and public access to the decision-makers too.

That’s not only how sound public decisions are sometimes arrived at, it’s how government builds confidence in the policy it makes in the public interest.

Confidence doesn’t come from skirting the obligation to consult with the public because of unnamed troublemakers. If the government and others have information about people who have made threats, or engaged in illegal actions, they should contact the police.

It’s interesting, after all, that when individuals who oppose infrastructure projects, such as pipelines, engage with the consultative process, they’re widely considered important voices in the public debate.

When they illegally hang banners from buildings such as the Calgary Tower, they’re seen as adding to the public conversation.

There’s never any talk of short circuiting the public review because of their irresponsible and selfish actions, ones that put their own safety and the safety of others at risk.

The same is true of the public discussion of the NDP’s plan for the Bighorn region: deal harshly with a few troublemakers who would stifle debate and let the people have their say.

Important public decisions such as the NDP’s plans for a wide swath of the province deserve no less. When fear mongering and veiled threats cut short important public conversations, all Albertans should be concerned.

David Marsden is managing editor of the Red Deer Advocate.

Just Posted

Lacombe council seeking answers about policing cost overruns

Council surprised to find out about $240,000 policing budget shortfall

Red Deer fundraiser to help educate Somali orphans on May 11

The Mother’s Day event is for all ages

Lacombe to join municipal coalition spreading the word about importance of resource industry

Resources Communities of Canada Coalition to represent municipalities connected to resource industry

These blues will get you dancing: The Overdue Blues Band performs in Red Deer Saturday

Calgary’s Brother Ray Lemelin Band is also on Elks Lodge bill

Gardening: Time and effort key to buying garden plants

Greenhouses, garden centers and box stores are set to start selling bedding… Continue reading

Montreal native Nicholas Latifi off to solid start on Formula 2 race circuit

Practice makes perfect for Canadian Nicholas Latifi. The 23-year-old Montreal auto racer… Continue reading

Bruins victory over Leafs ensures an American team will hoist the Stanley Cup

TORONTO — Many NHL players were either not yet born or too… Continue reading

Swole, buzzy, among new words in Merriam-Webster dictionary

BOSTON — Get swole, prepare a bug-out bag, grab a go-cup and… Continue reading

Garner graces cover of People’s annual ‘Beautiful Issue’

NEW YORK — Jennifer Garner graces the front of this year’s “Beautiful… Continue reading

Updated: Joshua Arthur Sanford has been found, says RCMP

37-year-old Ponoka man last seen on Tuesday morning

Inspired by a galaxy far, far away, these ‘Star Wars’ mementos could be yours forever

CHICAGO —The stuff of “Star Wars” —and there is unfortunately no better… Continue reading

Shoppers Drug Mart launches second online medical pot portal in Alberta

TORONTO — Medical cannabis users in Alberta can now get their therapeutic… Continue reading

Most Read