Without constitutional change, we’re better off with Senate as is

By not attaching a Senate vote to this year’s municipal ballot, Premier Ed Stelmach rightly took a step back from seeking to elect the Senate without changing the constitution.

By not attaching a Senate vote to this year’s municipal ballot, Premier Ed Stelmach rightly took a step back from seeking to elect the Senate without changing the constitution.

The previous vote was a farce boycotted by two parties and set a record for spoiled ballots. Increasingly, Albertans understand Senate selection votes, added to the constitutional status quo, are worse than the status quo.

Less seen is that an elected Senate, even if preceded by constitutional change, would be no prize. An intergovernmental Senate would be better and may be more feasible.

First, election of the current Senate would weaken Alberta by making more prominent the House where our voice is weakest. Alberta has more population than all Atlantic provinces combined: they have 30 senators to our six. Alberta and B.C. have more population than Quebec but 12 senators to their 24. Seat shares can only be revised by constitutional change, requiring support of Parliament and six provinces. There is no appetite in either region for reducing their shares.

Most Quebec MPs are separatists but we keep separatists out of the Senate. Election would admit them and they could stay until 75.

Senate reform requires plain language. ‘Elected appointee’ is nonsense, a contradiction in terms like ‘dry water’ or ‘sour sugar.’ With or without prior votes, no one becomes senator unless appointed. And ‘one person, one vote’ doesn’t make anyone accountable for what they do after they get there. The current appointed Senate delays for reflection but usually defers to the elected House.

Selection votes, if other provinces follow, may spur constitutional change. More likely, divisions over how to change the Senate will provoke other results based on the logic of political systems.

Continuing to elect appointed senators, without prior agreement on a deadlock breaking process, imperils our form of government. In parliamentary systems, government continuance depends on confidence of the Commons. That leads to strongly party-based voting. Parliament would become paralyzed when a pseudo-elected Senate, unaccountable to voters, does what our appointed one doesn’t: blocks a budget.

Deep integration with the U.S. would be facilitated by making the parliamentary system unworkable, so we abandon the confidence vote and adopt the U.S. system. Or some may hope for annexation after our form of government breaks down.

If we managed to create a deadlock breaking mechanism out of constitutional crisis, it might look like Australia’s, which has an elected Senate in a parliamentary system. Their dispute resolution system doesn’t work well, and includes joint session where the smaller Senate is swamped and outvoted by the other House. Single-chamber decisions would swamp Alberta’s unique interests, and Quebec’s. Proposed in the Charlottetown Accord, that was defeated in a Canada-wide referendum.

Countries with elected senators centralize power. Election would reduce provinces as the voice of regional interests, Alberta’s best line of defence, and reduce the only place where French is a majority.

Former premier Peter Lougheed argued that elected senates don’t work well in parliaments. That’s also why they are so few. In 1982, he proposed an intergovernmental Senate, somewhat resembling the U.S. pre-1913 and modern Germany. Quebec supported that. After Lougheed, Alberta sought an ‘elected appointed’ Senate.

What it seeks would diminish Alberta, threaten Quebec while permitting separatist senators, and imperil our system of government. More likely, Alberta dooms Prime Minister Stephen Harper to minority governments or loss of power.

Lougheed’s ideas deserve a second look. We can start toward them before agreement on details, without re-opening the Constitution prematurely, by working on improved co-operation between the levels of government.

David Baugh, PhD, is an instructor and head of the Political Science Department at Red Deer College.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

The QEII was closed Sunday morning due to a pole fire. (Photo courtesy City of Red Deer)
UPDATE: QEII near Red Deer reopens

The QEII has been reopened after being closed due to a pole… Continue reading

Innisfail RCMP are investigating a single-vehicle crash that happened west of Bowden on March 21, 2021. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Bashaw RCMP investigate fatal collision in central Alberta

Bashaw RCMP are investigating after a fatal collision Saturday afternoon. Police were… Continue reading

A damaged unicorn statue is shown in a field outside of Delia, Alta. in this undated handout photo. It's not often police can report that a unicorn has been found, but it was the truth Saturday when RCMP said a stolen, stainless-steel statue of the mythical beast had been located in a field not far from where he'd been taken. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO, RCMP *MANDATORY CREDIT*
Mounties get their unicorn; stolen statue of mythical beast found in Alberta field

DELIA, Alta. — It’s not often police can report that a unicorn… Continue reading

Red Deer Rebels forward Ethan Rowland battles with Medicine Hat Tigers forward Brett Kemp during WHL action at the Centrium Saturday night. (Photo by ROB WALLATOR/Red Deer Rebels)
Tigers claw back, hand Rebels 11th straight loss

Tigers 5 Rebels 2 The same old issues continue to plague the… Continue reading

There were six additional deaths across Alberta reported over the past 24 hours, bringing the death toll to 1,926 since the beginning of the pandemic. (File photo)
Investigators from the Vancouver Police Department were in Chilliwack Saturday, collecting evidence connected to a double homicide. (file photo)
Police investigate shooting death of man outside downtown Vancouver restaurant

Vancouver police say one man was killed in what they believe was… Continue reading

Dr. E. Kwok administers a COVID-19 vaccine to a recipient at a vaccination clinic run by Vancouver Coastal Health, in Richmond, B.C., Saturday, April 10, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
B.C. to start registering people 18 years and older for COVID-19 vaccines

VICTORIA — The British Columbia government says it’s inviting people 18 years… Continue reading

San Jose's Tomas Hertl, center, celebrates with teammates Patrick Marleau, left, and Rudolfs Blacers, right, after Hertl scored a goal during the first period of an NHL hockey game against the Minnesota Wild, Friday, April 16, 2021, in St. Paul, Minn. (AP Photo/Stacy Bengs)
Patrick Marleau set to break Gordie Howe’s games record

For Patrick Marleau, the best part about Monday night when he is… Continue reading

Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, speaks during a press briefing at the White House, Tuesday, April 13, 2021, in Washington. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)
Half of U.S. adults have received at least one COVID-19 shot

WASHINGTON — Half of all adults in the U.S. have received at… Continue reading

People are shown at a COVID-19 vaccination site in Montreal, Sunday, April 18, 2021, as the COVID-19 pandemic continues in Canada and around the world. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes
Federal government to send health-care workers to Ontario, Trudeau says

MONTREAL — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says federal departments and some Canadian… Continue reading

People cross a busy street in the shopping district of Flushing on Tuesday, March 30, 2021, in the Queens borough of New York. Access to the COVID-19 vaccine in the United States is growing by the day. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Kathy Willens
Despite COVID-19 vaccines, Americans in D.C. not feeling celebratory — or charitable

WASHINGTON — This might make Canadians jealous of their American cousins for… Continue reading

A man pays his respects at a roadside memorial in Portapique, N.S. on Thursday, April 23, 2021. RCMP say at least 22 people are dead after a man who at one point wore a police uniform and drove a mock-up cruiser, went on a murder rampage in Portapique and several other Nova Scotia communities. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan
Memorial service in Nova Scotia marks one year since mass shooting started

TRURO, N.S. — A memorial service is planned for today in central… Continue reading

In this April 23, 2016, photo, David Goethel sorts cod and haddock while fishing off the coast of New Hampshire. To Goethel, cod represents his identity, his ticket to middle class life, and his link to one the country's most historic industries, a fisherman who has caught New England's most recognized fish for more than 30 years. (AP Photo/Robert F. Bukaty)
‘It’s more than just a fish:’ Scientists worry cod will never come back in N.L.

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — The latest assessment of Atlantic cod stocks, whose… Continue reading

Most Read