Book review: The Other Twin’s plot all too familiar

The Other Twin by L.V. Hay


Published: November 15, 2017. Orenda Books

Poppy has not returned to her hometown, Brighton, in years. She spends her nights in a drunken haze, bringing strange men to her home only to wake up with the guys long gone and mere flash backs to remind her of what happened. On one particular day she wakes up, Poppy realizes she has a ton of missed calls and texts from her mother. She and her mother are not exactly best friends, so Poppy knows that something terrible must have happened – maybe her step dad passed away? No, the news is worse than she could’ve thought – her younger sister, India, has fallen to her death from a bridge. The police are saying it was suicide.

So of course, Poppy returns home to be with her family and attend her sisters funeral but then stays so she can play detective. She doubts that India committed suicide – even though she finds a referral to a psychiatrist with a prescription of anti-depressants (that India had not been taking). Okay, so India was suffering from depression – that doesn’t mean she jumped to her death. What really grabs Poppy’s attention is the ‘suicide note’ left by India that is addressed to someone both Poppy and her parents have never heard of – Jenny.

This Jenny, from what readers will discover, is an egotistical woman who loves being in charge and literally saviors that feeling when those who are beneath her follows her command in fear. Okay so what does this Jenny have to do with what happened to India? What kind of show is Jenny running if she has this much power over people? And an even better question is how Matthew Temple, Poppy’s ex boyfriend that she abandoned, involved?

I really wanted to enjoy this book – but this whole plot of a character having to return to their long lost home and become their own investigator to discover the truth of what happened to their loved ones is just so over used. The book is character driven by characters that I personally couldn’t relate too, let alone really like – which also placed this book below average for me.

Kirsten Lowe attends Athabasca University

Just Posted

Red Deer RCMP investigate reports of a weapon

Collicutt Centre and high schools reopen

Energy regulator says crude-by-rail shipments fell to 310,000 bpd in August

CALGARY — The Canada Energy Regulator says exports of crude oil by… Continue reading

Red Deer ICU included in leading-edge study

Looking at standard versus accelerated dialysis in critically ill patients

UN report highlights ‘abhorrent’ housing conditions for Indigenous people

A United Nations report is highlighting the role “abhorrent” housing conditions play… Continue reading

Lane closures on 49th Avenue in Red Deer on Tuesday

City crews start working near Baymont Inn and Suites

WATCH: Red Deer Citizens on Patrol monitoring downtown with new program

Volunteers will patrol downtown Red Deer to help keep the city safe.… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Tuesday The Small Business Centre at Burman University’s School of Business invites… Continue reading

Health: What should I mix with my rum?

Have I been leading readers astray? For years this column has stressed… Continue reading

Family: Reflections on Thanksgiving and other holidays

With Thanksgiving over and done with its time to get on with… Continue reading

Blondin adds to medal tally at Canadian speedskating championships

CALGARY — Ottawa’s Ivanie Blondin won a pair of gold medals on… Continue reading

Hofbauer, Pidhoresky qualify for marathon event at Tokyo 2020 Games

TORONTO — Calgary’s Trevor Hofbauer and Vancouver’s Dayna Pidhoresky are Tokyo bound.… Continue reading

Mike Downie says Secret Path Live was ‘powerful’ and he’d ‘love to do it again’

TORONTO — A brother of the late Tragically Hip frontman Gord Downie… Continue reading

Taika Waititi says ‘Jojo Rabbit’ isn’t a ‘challenging’ take on the Holocaust

TORONTO — “Jojo Rabbit” director Taika Waititi is laying flat on the… Continue reading

RDC Queens honour graduating players, fall in season finale

Rattlers 6 Queens 0 It’s been a rough tumble to the end… Continue reading

Most Read