Protests are planned in Sweden’s capital on Dec. 10, 2019, as Nobel Literature Prize laureate Peter Handke collects his award. (Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Protests are planned in Sweden’s capital on Dec. 10, 2019, as Nobel Literature Prize laureate Peter Handke collects his award. (Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Canadian prize juries wrestle with tension between politics and literature

With every literature prize comes some contention over which texts are most worthy of celebration. But rather than a war over words, this awards season was dominated by controversy over a writer’s moral character.

Protests are planned in Sweden’s capital on Tuesday as Nobel Literature Prize laureate Peter Handke collects his award in the face of widespread criticism over his stance on the 1990s wars in the former Yugoslavia.

Handke’s Nobel win in October triggered a flood of condemnation accusing the Austrian author of being an apologist for war criminals in the Bosnia-Herzegovina conflict.

The scandal has reverberated across the literary world, prompting Canadian prize juries to wrestle with how to weigh an author’s artistic achievements against their political views.

Bosnian-American author Aleksandar Hemon, who served on the jury for this year’s Scotiabank Giller Prize, has been one of Handke’s most vocal detractors, writing an October op-ed in the New York Times calling the author “The Bob Dylan of Genocide Apologists.”

“(The Nobel Committee) effectively endorsed his genocide denial while pretending that it doesn’t matter,” Hemon said in an interview.

Despite a United Nations court ruling to the contrary, Handke has denied that genocide took place in the Bosnian town of Srebrenica, where about 8,000 Muslims were massacred by Serb soldiers in 1995. He also spoke at the 2006 funeral of Serbian strongman Slobodan Milosevic, who died of a heart attack while facing war crimes charges in The Hague.

Handke refused to address the backlash or his beliefs at a news conference last week, dismissing reporters’ questions as “empty and ignorant.”

The permanent secretary of the Swedish Academy, which chooses the Nobel literature laureate, said the prize body found that none of Handke’s works concerning Yugoslavia represent an “anti-humanitarian attitude,” adding that his comments fall within the bounds of “freedom of opinion” and “freedom of the arts.”

“The prize is always an endorsement of literary merit, never an endorsement of political view,” Mats Malm said in a statement. “The relationship between art and person has constantly been an issue of disagreement, yet the Academy is obliged to appoint laureates based on literary merit within the limits mentioned above.”

In Hemon’s view, this defence rests on a false distinction between esthetics — or an author’s artistic approach — and politics.

Writing is not an autotelic exercise that has no meaning beyond the page, he said. Rather, literature always reaches outwards, engaging readers in a conversation that cannot be removed from the world in which we live.

“(Literature) should not be reduced to politics, obviously, because human experience is more than politics,” he said. “But also, human experience is never without politics.”

This renders every literature prize an “ethical judgment,” Hemon said. But he drew a distinction between lifetime writing awards like the Nobel, which must account for the way a writer exists in the world, and prizes for individual works.

Giller executive director Elana Rabinovitch said an author’s political proclivities shouldn’t factor into their eligibility for the $100,000 honour, emphasizing that each work must stand on its own.

But Canadian writer Randy Boyagoda, who chaired this year’s Giller jury, said it’s not always so easy to separate the writer from what’s on the page.

“I think you can’t help but consider a writer’s larger profile, career, commitments, but they needn’t be the decisive factor, unless they’re decisive to how the writer works things out,” said Boyagoda.

“We have to all maybe accept our historical moment, and be aware of the pressures that are on us … but then not be fully captive to those pressures in what we love and prize.”

Vancouver-based novelist and poet Ian Williams, who won the Giller last month for “Reproduction,” said moral righteousness is not a prerequisite to be a brilliant writer, but the literary community has to uphold certain standards to prevent the abuse of others.

“What we don’t want to do is sort of preserve environments where people can continue to be evil,” said Williams, who is also a Griffin Poetry Prize trustee and judged the 2018 award.

“If it means sort of destroying entire systems in order to protect other people, I think that’s important.”

Dessa Bayrock, a PhD student at Carleton University who studies Canadian literature awards, noted that these systems have material consequences, including prize money, a bump in book sales and increased exposure for the author.

“Granting an award to literature isn’t an action that takes place in a vacuum,” said Bayrock.

“By celebrating authors whose politics are ethically or morally transgressive, prize culture does a disservice to vulnerable populations who are targeted by these politics.”

While it may seem that literature prizes are becoming more polarized, Bayrock said juries have long been influenced by a politics so dominant it can seem invisible — the tastes of the largely white, male and Euro-centric cultural elite.

“That is a sort of politics in and of itself, and one that tends to reproduce itself fairly easily, because those are the figures that have largely run these prizing formulations since their inception.”

The Swedish Academy brought in five external members to help adjudicate the 2018 and 2019 literature laureates on the heels of a sexual-misconduct scandal at the awards body that saw the prize suspended last year.

Two external members have since resigned, one in protest of Handke’s win.

In the wake of Handke’s selection, PEN Canada joined its U.S. and international counterparts in issuing a statement that denounced the decision as “baffling and deeply regrettable,” particularly in light of the academy’s promised reforms.

In an interview, PEN Canada executive director Brendan de Caires said the organization for the most part prefers to stay out of the awards fray. But in this case, the non-profit felt the author’s views fell outside of the realm of writers’ right to freedom of expression and into “extremely dangerous territory.”

Still, he stood up for the prerogative of prize juries to reward politically contentious writing, noting that such decisions have often been used to amplify dissidents speaking out against authoritarian regimes.

Having served on prize juries, de Caires acknowledged that such judgments can be difficult to arbitrate.

“I would say there’s an esthetic question, which juries can decide on. There’s a political question, which is relevant, but not decisive. But beyond that, there’s an ethical question, and I think that’s the one that’s most important here,” said de Caires.

“But who wants to be weighing in on all three levels every time a prize is given?”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Dec. 9, 2019.

— with files from Associated Press

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Andre Lemus, the owner of Las Palmeras in Red Deer, says he hopes in-person dining restrictions are lifted this upcoming Thursday. (Photo courtesy
Red Deer restaurant owner hopes in-person dining restrictions are lifted Thursday

The owner of a Red Deer restaurant says business has “dropped” since… Continue reading

The Town of Ponoka and the Alberta Union of Provincial Employees (AUPE) have ratified a new agreement, averting a strike. (File photo from Facebook)
Alberta gov’t ‘using pandemic as shield to lay off workers,’ says AUPE

The Government of Alberta’s “attacks on workers” is continuing with a new… Continue reading

Rocky Mountain House RCMP, EMS, Search and Rescue, STARS air ambulance and Alstrom Helicopters worked together to rescue a fallen ice climber Friday. (Photo contributed by Rocky Mountain House RCMP)
Rocky Mountain House RCMP help rescue fallen ice climber

Rocky Mountain RCMP helped assist a fallen ice climber Friday afternoon. At… Continue reading

Students Association of Red Deer College president Brittany Lausen says she’s pleased the college is offering students a choice to attend class in-person or remotely. (Red Deer Advocate file photo)
Red Deer College winter term enrolment dips

Enrolment down about six per cent but mix of online and in-person instruction is going over well

Dwayne Buckle, 40 of Red Deer finished a 1,638-kilometre walk, in honour of his family. The 12-week, 82 day-journey wrapped up in Port Hardy, B.C. on Monday. Facebook photo
Red Deer man completes 1,638 km hike for cancer research

Dwayne Buckle, a Red Deer firefighter returned home Friday after his 12-week journey

A cat named Willow is shown in this recent handout photo. Victoria firefighter Capt. Tim Hanley says using a jackhammer and other home repair tools to save a cat stuck in a tiny basement drainpipe ranks as the strangest rescue call he's been on in his 20-year career. Hanley says he and three other firefighters spent more than two hours using sledgehammers and a jackhammer to break through Victoria homeowner Emma Hutchinson's concrete basement floor to free Willow, a nine-month-old kitten. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO - Twitter, City of Victoria
Victoria firefighters use homeowners’ jackhammer to rescue cat trapped in tiny pipe

VICTORIA — A Victoria firefighter says using a jackhammer and other home… Continue reading

Conservative Leader Erin O'Toole holds a press conference on Parliament Hill, in Ottawa on December 10, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
No place for ‘far right’ in Conservative Party: O’Toole

OTTAWA — Federal Conservative Leader Erin O’Toole says there is “no place… Continue reading

Alberta Energy Minister Sonya Savage addresses the attendees while Tom Olsen, Managing Director of the Canadian Energy Centre, looks on at a press conference at SAIT in Calgary on Wednesday, Dec. 11, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Greg Fulmes
‘Morally and ethically wrong:’ Court to hear challenge to Alberta coal policy removal

First Nations, ranchers, municipal officials and environmentalists hope to persuade a judge… Continue reading

Sub-Lt. Jeffrey Delisle arrives at Nova Scotia provincial court for a sentencing hearing in Halifax on Friday, Feb. 1, 2013. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan
Canada’s spy-catching system caused delay, angst in Delisle case: former FBI official

OTTAWA — The U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation’s former head of counter-intelligence… Continue reading

People wait to be screened before entering Little Mountain Place, a long-term care home that has had 41 residents die since a COVID-19 outbreak was declared at the facility in November in Vancouver on Sunday, January 3, 2021. Staff in long-term care homes across Canada are struggling to isolate elderly residents with dementia during COVID-19 outbreaks, accelerating the deadly spread of the virus, experts say. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
Care home staff struggle to isolate dementia patients during outbreaks: experts

VANCOUVER — Staff in long-term care homes across Canada are struggling to… Continue reading

A passer by walks in High Park, in Toronto, Thursday, Jan. 14, 2021. This workweek will kick off with what's fabled to be the most depressing day of the year, during one of the darkest eras in recent history. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young
‘Blue Monday’ getting you down? Exercise may be the cure, say experts

This workweek will kick off with what’s fabled to be the most… Continue reading

Winnipeg Jets' Blake Wheeler (26) just misses the net against goaltender Laurent Brossoit (30) during  scrimmage at their NHL training camp practice in Winnipeg, Wednesday, January 6, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/John Woods
Jets return to practice a day after suspending workouts due to COVID concerns

WINNIPEG — The Winnipeg Jets have returned to practice a day after… Continue reading

Most Read