Ghomeshi trial judge has a history of finding reasonable doubt in cases:Lawyer

The man tasked with deciding the fate of former CBC star Jian Ghomeshi has a history of finding reasonable doubt in cases with more conclusive evidence than what was presented at his sexual assault trial.

TORONTO — The man tasked with deciding the fate of former CBC star Jian Ghomeshi has a history of finding reasonable doubt in cases with more conclusive evidence than what was presented at his sexual assault trial.

Justice William Horkins presided over the courtroom where defence lawyers hammered away at the three women who accused Ghomeshi of sexual assault. Defence lawyer Marie Henein and her team delivered devastating cross-examination, highlighting gaps in their memories and presenting photos or letters that cast doubt on their credibility.

Horkins’ past rulings suggest a rigid adherence to the concept of reasonable doubt. He dismissed charges against a sexual assault suspect in 2008 despite DNA evidence suggesting contact took place and an account that the judge himself described as resembling a “schoolboy’s fantasy.”

Even in cases where he has shown support for prosecution arguments, Horkins has been known to be strict in his interpretation of the law.

A 2013 decision saw him lambaste the Toronto Police Service for their practice of conducting arbitrary street checks against citizens and rule that the practice — known as carding — violated the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, but still find that a gun procured during one of those checks was admissible in a criminal trial. That gun was later used to convict the defendant.

Lawyers who have argued cases before Horkins say that degree of fine detail is typical of a judge with a reputation for being both meticulous and fair.

“He’s very detached, very business-oriented in the sense that he comes to work prepared and expects you to be prepared,” said criminal defence lawyer Corben Cawkell with Hicks Adams in Toronto. “The phrase ‘doesn’t suffer fools lightly” is often used. You should be prepared when you go in front of Horkins because he’s going to be the first to comment on it.”

Horkins has divided his 36-year career evenly between the two sides of the bench.

After being called to the bar in 1980, he worked as both a Crown and defence lawyer for 18 years before being named to the Ontario Court of Justice in 1998.

Since then, Cawkell said Horkins has become known for examining not just the individual cases before him, but the broader systems in which they play out.

In 2007, for instance, the Crown attempted to place Cawkell’s client under community supervision after he had served his complete sentence for a violent offence. Horkins dismissed that application, but also issued pointed remarks about the ways in which people are evaluated for the risk they may pose to society.

He concluded that police officers are not best equipped to make such assessments, saying that task should be left to forensic psychologists and psychiatrists instead. Cawkell said that standard has been widely applied ever since.

He also criticized the slow pace at which cases moved through the system, according to Cawkell.

“He was unimpressed with the idea that an application could be brought without any criminal allegations, that it could take years to be heard, and throughout that time effectively the individual was under conditions that mirrored what they wanted without having to actually get a ruling on it,” Cawkell said. “He would look at the broader picture and look at the implications of the overall process.”

Horkins’ discontentment with the system was revealed more sharply in January 2010 when he dismissed charges against a nursing home employee accused of assaulting a patient on the ground that the wheels of justice were turning too slowly.

“Undue delay erodes public confidence in the criminal justice system. The charter recognizes the truth in the old adage ‘justice delayed is justice denied,”‘ he wrote in the ruling.

Fairness lies at the heart of his general reputation in legal circles, according to both Cawkell and another lawyer who has argued in front of him who wished not to be named.

That fairness, Cawkell argued, has already been displayed at the Ghomeshi trial when Horkins denied the media’s request to view a provocative photo of one of the Crown’s witnesses clad in a bikini. In doing so, Horkins referenced the court’s role as a “gatekeeper” and the “societal interest” in protecting the privacy of sexual assault complainants.

At the heart of the Ghomeshi trial, however, lies the issue of witness credibility.

It’s a subject Horkins tackled directly in the 2008 sex assault case, in which two women accused a man of forcing himself upon them while they were sedated and while the man’s wife and sister slept upstairs.

Horkins delivered a scathing assessment of the defendant’s account of events while praising aspects of the complainants’ testimony for being articulate and forthright.

“The version of events given by the accused and his supporting witnesses quite frankly, and very bluntly, strike me as somewhat incredible,” Horkins wrote in his judgement. “It reads like a schoolboy’s fantasy and seems to conveniently contain just sufficient admissions against interest to answer the undeniable forensic evidence of sexual contact, and no more.”

Yet in the end Horkins dismissed the charges, citing instances in which the evidence was not conclusive enough to eliminate all possible doubt as to the man’s innocence.

He laid out his mode of evaluating such cases in that same 2008 judgment, offering a prospective clue as to his approach in deciding Ghomeshi’s fate.

“This is not simply a credibility contest as between the complainants and the accused,” he wrote. “The measuring stick of a criminal prosecution is proof beyond a reasonable doubt.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

File photo
Gov’t of Alberta identifies estimated 300 new COVID-19 cases Sunday

Online COVID-19 dashboard unavailable as upgrades being completed

The Central Alberta Freestyle Ski Club is hoping to win $50,000 through the Mackenzie Investments Top Peak contest. (Contributed photo)
Central Alberta ski club trying to win $50K in online contest

A central Alberta ski club has entered a contest where it can… Continue reading

A health-care worker prepares a dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine at a UHN COVID-19 vaccine clinic in Toronto on Thursday, January 7, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Red Deer dips below 300 active COVID-19 cases

The number of active COVID-19 cases in Red Deer continued to drop… Continue reading

Ben King scores for the Red Deer Rebels during the third period of a Western Hockey League game against the Calgary Hitmen at the Westerner Park Centrium Saturday. (Photo by Rob Wallator/Red Deer Rebels)
Rebels complete comeback to pick up first win of season

Rebels 3 Hitmen 2 (OT) The Red Deer Rebels were able to… Continue reading

Minister of National Defence Harjit Sajjan takes part in a year-end interview with The Canadian Press at National Defence Headquarters in Ottawa on December 17, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Conservatives to call top Sajjan, Trudeau aides to testify on Vance allegations

OTTAWA — The federal Conservatives plan to summon two senior Liberal aides… Continue reading

Elvira D'Angelo, 92, waits to receive her COVID-19 vaccination shot at a clinic in Montreal, Sunday, March 7, 2021, as the COVID-19 pandemic continues in Canada and around the world. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes
‘It’s been a good week’: Tam hopeful on vaccines as pandemic anniversary nears

Several provinces were preparing to loosen COVID-19 restrictions on Sunday, as Canada’s… Continue reading

Mount Pearl Senior High in Mount Pearl, N.L., remains closed on Wednesday, March 3, 2021. The provincial health authority says there were 185 cases at 22 schools, including 145 infections among staff and students of one high school in Mount Pearl that was an early epicentre of the outbreak. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Daly
In Newfoundland and Labrador, three ingredients made for explosive COVID-19 outbreak

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — With her classes, three part-time jobs and a… Continue reading

A passenger places a tag on luggage at the departure terminal at Toronto Pearson Airport, in Mississauga, Ont., Friday, May 24, 2019. The economic and life disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic has prompted many recent immigrants to leave Canada and return to their countries of origin, where they have more social and familial connections. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young
COVID-19 pandemic prompts recent newcomers to leave Canada for their home countries

OTTAWA — The economic and life disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic… Continue reading

Rail cars wait for pickup in Winnipeg, Sunday, March 23, 2014. The fierce debate over cross-border pipelines is putting more Canadian oil and gas on trains destined for the United States — a country experts fear is ill-equipped for the potential consequences. THE CANADIAN PRESS/John Woods
As debate rages over cross-border pipelines, U.S. analysts brace for more oil by rail

WASHINGTON — The fierce debate over cross-border pipelines is putting more Canadian… Continue reading

Pictures and notes in from friends and classmates make up a memorial in support and memory of Aubrey Berry, 4, and her sister Chloe, 6, during a vigil held at Willows Beach in Oak Bay, B.C., on December 30, 2017. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito
Mother of slain daughters supports recent changes to Canada’s Divorce Act

VICTORIA — Legal experts and a mother whose ex-partner was convicted of… Continue reading

Radio and television personality Dick Smyth is shown in an undated handout photo. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO
Dick Smyth, Canadian maestro of news radio commentary, dies at 86

TORONTO — Radio and television personality Dick Smyth, whose booming commentary filled… Continue reading

Walter Gretzky father of hockey hall-of-famer Wayne Gretzky waves to fans as the Buffalo Sabres play against the Toronto Maple Leafs during third period NHL hockey action in Toronto on Tuesday, January 17, 2017. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Funeral for Walter Gretzky to be held Saturday in home town of Brantford, Ont.

The funeral for hockey legend Wayne Gretzky’s father Walter will take place… Continue reading

Most Read