Achievement tests are not the answer

Provincial achievement tests are inherently flawed in many ways. These tests measure only a small portion of what teachers are required to teach and what students are expected to learn.

Re. Michael Zwaagstra’s Nov. 17 article, headlined Achievement tests are worth keeping:

Provincial achievement tests are inherently flawed in many ways.

These tests measure only a small portion of what teachers are required to teach and what students are expected to learn.

For example, did you know that out of the 200 learner outcomes in Grade 9 science, only 63 (32 per cent) can be assessed by the provincial achievement test?

Because these exams are almost exclusively multiple-choice, their scope is severely limited. There is a big difference between someone who values what they measure and those who measure what they value.

Alberta has come to believe that a good education system can be made better by simply testing more. The budget of the Learner Assessment Branch that administers provincial achievement tests has tripled from $4 million to $12 million since the mid-1980s.

Over the same period, the budget of the Curriculum Branch, which designs and implements the entire Alberta K-12 curriculum, has remained static at $4 million.

Alberta leads all other Canadian provinces in the frequency and intensity of government testing programs. Yet despite the millions of dollars pumped into its data collection, there is no evidence that these efforts actually help students.

The millions of dollars used to develop, mark and report the tests is money that would be better spent on student learning in classrooms.

Using provincial achievement Test scores to judge a school’s quality equates to a kind of educational malpractice. Research has shown that up to 70 per cent of the variation in student learning is not attributable to school factors but to student, family and community characteristics. This means that too many tests are reporting on what children bring to school and not necessarily what they learn at school.

Research has shown that there is a statistical association between high scores on standardized tests and shallow thinking on behalf of the students. And just as the student’s thinking can be “dumbed down,” a teacher’s instruction can be harmed from the overbearing pressures to achieve high scores.

This kind of pressure can lead to poor teaching, such as the use of lecturing on behalf of the teacher and memorization on behalf of the student.

This kind of shallow learning and superficial teaching have led some educators to believe that “measurable outcomes may be the least significant results of learning.”

Albert Einstein may have summarized this all really well when he said, “Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts.”

Many people are not aware how standardized test questions are chosen. If every teacher could get every student to answer a question correctly, that question would be removed from next year’s exam. It would be replaced with a question that test-makers would hope roughly half would get right and half would get wrong.

The better job teachers do to teach their students those important skills and knowledge, the less likely there will be a question on the exam to measure that skill or knowledge.

It is important to have diagnostic tools to assess our schools; however, using provincial achievement tests to diagnose the learning in our schools is like using a tablespoon to measure someone’s temperature.

Joe Bower

Red Deer County

Just Posted

Random Acts of Green Canadian tour comes to Red Deer

Red Deerians are being encouraged to lessen their impact on the environment.… Continue reading

Red Deer economy bouncing back but slowly: report

While Red Deer’s economy has been in recovery mode for the past… Continue reading

Red Deer cyclist dead after being hit by vehicle

A Red Deer man was killed after being hit by a vehicle… Continue reading

Support for retaining ‘public’ in Alberta school titles could snowball, says local trustee

Even districts that never had the word in their titles are now discussing adding it

Multiple Oktoberfest events coming up in Red Deer

Red Deerians will have several chances to take part in one of… Continue reading

WATCH: 2019 Canada Winter Games will leave a lasting legacy, say organizers

It leaves Red Deer with the infrastructure and confidence to host future such events

Your community calendar

Wednesday Central Alberta Historical Society annual general meeting is 6 p.m. at… Continue reading

Couche-Tard wants to be a player in the sale of cannabis

LAVAL, Que. — Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. wants to be one of the… Continue reading

Michael Dawe: A safe supply of water has long been a priority for Red Deer

The oldest part of the Red Deer water treatment plant on 54th… Continue reading

New parent charged in admissions scam, linked to $400K bribe

BOSTON — A woman accused of paying $400,000 to get her son… Continue reading

Canadian stars Virtue, Moir say in video they’re “stepping away” from ice dancing

Canadian ice dancing stars Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir say they are… Continue reading

Bruce Cockburn avoids impulse to get political with lyric-less new album

TORONTO — If anyone is looking for activist folk singer Bruce Cockburn… Continue reading

13 seasons in, stars reflect on success of ‘Heartland,’ Canada’s ‘comfort food’

HIGH RIVER, Alta. — Alberta-born actor Shaun Johnston had already had a… Continue reading

N.S. senior whose birthday card request drew international response dies

SYDNEY, N.S. — A Nova Scotia widower who received thousands of birthday… Continue reading

Most Read