Charter fight over denial of liver transplants to alcohol abusers can proceed

TORONTO — Relatives of two men who were denied liver transplants because of their alcoholism can press their constitutional fight over the hospital’s refusal to perform the surgery, an Ontario court has ruled.

In his ruling, Superior Court Justice Andras Schreck rejected arguments from Toronto-based University Health Network that the charter does not apply to it as a private rather than governmental entity. The charter, Schreck found, may apply in cases where actions of a private entity are related to a specific governmental program or policy.

“This is especially true of cases involving hospitals,” Schreck said. ”In these circumstances, it is far from ‘plain and obvious’ that the charter does not apply.”

The now-deceased men, Mark Williams and Mark Selkirk, died from liver disease related to their alcohol consumption. Both were denied potentially life-saving transplants based on their drinking habits.

Under Ontario legislation, the Trillium Gift of Life Network is responsible for fairly rationing scarce organs from dead donors based on need. The agency does not generally allow people with livers damaged by alcohol to receive transplants unless they have been dry for at least six months. The criterion does not apply to liver transplants from living donors.

Nevertheless, the University Health Network, the only hospital that does live-donor transplants, refused to do the surgery based on the Trillium rules. Williams died in May. Selkirk died in November 2010.

Their estates challenged the constitutional validity of the policy that denied them transplants as a violation of their constitutional rights to life and equality. Selkirk’s estate also argued he was subject to cruel and unusual treatment.

In its motion before Superior Court, the health network argued the case should be thrown out on the basis that it’s a private institution and the charter has no application. Its adoption of Trillium’s transplant criteria did not involve implementation of government policy but was rather an internal policy decision, the hospital network said.

Schreck disagreed. In one case, he said, the courts ruled a hospital’s refusal to provide sign-language interpretation ran afoul of the charter on the basis that hospitals carry out governmental objectives under the Canada Health Act and provincial legislation to provide medical services to the public.

“It is neither plain nor obvious that the provision of a (live-donor) liver transplant is not as much a part of the delivery of health care services as is the provision of sign language interpreters,” Schreck said.

The transplant refusals, the judge also said, appeared to be the result of hospital policy rather than the result of a clinical decision by a doctor.

In a related decision, Schreck refused a motion from Trillium to transfer the case to Divisional Court. The challenge is part of a wider fight that involves the University Health Network’s policy, he said.

“It would not be ‘practical and pragmatic’ to bifurcate the proceedings, nor would it be in the interests of justice to do so,” Schreck said.

There have been several challenges in Canada in recent years to policies that deny transplants to drinkers. After advocacy from Selkirk’s wife, Trillium began a three-year pilot project in 2017 under which some of those people could still receive a new organ.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

B.C. Liberal leader Andrew Wilkinson, B.C. NDP leader John Horgan and B.C. Greens leader Sonia Furstenau. (Black Press Media)
VIDEO: One day until B.C. voters go to the polls in snap election defined by pandemic

NDP Leader John Horgan’s decision to call an election comes more than a year ahead of schedule and during a pandemic

Alice Kolisnyk, deputy director of the Red Deer Food Bank, says the agency expects an increase in demand as the COVID-19 pandemic continues. Every new subscription to the Red Deer Advocate includes a $50 donation to the food bank. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)
Support the food bank with a subscription to the Red Deer Advocate

The community’s most vulnerable members are always in need of a hand,… Continue reading

Removing Molly Banister extension makes no sense

Re: “Removing road extension would be ‘terrible,’ says former city manager,” Oct.… Continue reading

jj
NDP is certain to tire of propping up Trudeau’s Liberals

To impose his will on the House of Commons, Prime Minister Justin… Continue reading

Mariah Bell of the United States competes during women’s freestyle program in the International Skating Union Grand Prix of Figure Skating Series Saturday, Oct. 24, 2020, in Las Vegas. (AP Photo/David Becker)
Canadian Keegan Messing earns bronze at Skate America in Vegas, Chen wins gold

Messing earns 266.42 points at Skate America in Las Vegas

In this Oct. 7, 2020 photo, chef Sohla El-Waylly prepares Swedish meatballs during a taping of “Stump Sohla,” in New York. El-Waylly became a familiar face on YouTube as a standout on Bon Appetit’s test kitchen channel. But during the nationwide racial reckoning following the police killing of George Floyd, she was among members of the test kitchen who accused the channel’s owner, Conde Nast, of discriminatory practices. She departed Bon Appetit in August after failed negotiations. Her new show is her own, pushing her to deploy her talent, charm and encyclopedic culinary chops to solve challenges. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer)
‘Babish’ expands as pandemic boosts YouTube cooking shows

Daily views of videos with “cook with me” soaring

FILE - Oprah Winfrey arrives for the presentation of Stella McCartney’s ready-to-wear Fall-Winter 2019-2020 fashion collection in Paris on March 4, 2019. Winfrey is setting aside her usual book club recommendations and instead citing seven personal favorites ranging from James Baldwin’s landmark essays in “The Fire Next Time” to Mary Oliver’s poetry collection “Devotions.” She is calling her choices “The Books That See Me Through,” works she values for “their ability to comfort, inspire, and enlighten” her. (AP Photo/Michel Euler, File)
`The books that see her through’: Winfrey suggests seven

Mix of fiction, poetry, non-fiction and spirituality

NDP Leader John Horgan celebrates his election win in the British Columbia provincial election in downtown Vancouver, B.C., Saturday, Oct. 24, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
John Horgan says he will work across party lines to find ideas that work for B.C.

VICTORIA — British Columbia’s election results show a divided province with Liberal… Continue reading

Most Read