Cheating for that bonus

When it comes to encouraging extra effort on the job, offering a bonus would seem like just the ticket to help ramp up productivity.

When it comes to encouraging extra effort on the job, offering a bonus would seem like just the ticket to help ramp up productivity.

But could dangling the carrot of a cash incentive lead to people telling white lies in a bid to reach their target — and net a little more dough? New research suggests individuals may be encouraged to cheat to help assure they’ll land a bonus.

A trio of researchers from the University of Guelph and Ryerson University conducted the study published in the B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy. It’s part of a broader project looking at the effects of different forms of compensation not just on cheating and misrepresentation of behaviour but also on productivity.

Researchers aimed to compare levels of cheating by using three different compensation systems: bonus, piece-rate or tournament.

In the bonus system, employees are compensated if they reach a target. With piece-rate, workers are rewarded for each completed task — the more productive the employee, the more they earn. With a tournament system, only those with the highest productivity receive the extra cash.

“All three of those situations give people incentives to cheat because if they do cheat, they’re going to make more money,” said University of Guelph economics professor Bram Cadsby, who co-authored the study with Guelph colleague Francis Tapon and Ryerson professor Fei Song.

“The idea was to look at these three different types of pay-per-performance and see whether one of them seemed to encourage people to cheat more than the others.”

Canadian university undergrads were given the task of taking seven letters and making as many words as possible in one minute.

Participants completed seven rounds of the word-scramble task. They then had another participant mark their work, and were responsible for reporting their final scores to researchers.

“People could have made a decision prior to that if they were going to cheat, but that’s kind of the crunch time where they have to make a final decision,” Cadsby said.

All participants were paid $3 for word-checking, but compensated in different ways.

In the target system, they received an additional $3.60 for each of the seven rounds where they created nine or more words. Under piece-rate, they earned 40 cents for each word created. In the tournament system, they pocketed $3.60 for each of the seven rounds they were above the 85 percentile relative to other participants.

Researchers found that those rewarded in the bonus system were more likely to cheat. What’s more, the closer they were to reaching the nine-word target, the greater the chance they would exaggerate the scores.

“Most people seemed to be much more tempted if they could tell a small lie,” Cadsby said.

“That is, if they could say, ‘I made one more word than I did, or I made two more words than I did’ and then get a lump sum bonus, than telling a big lie, which is what you have to do to make a substantial amount of money under the piece rate system.”

In looking at the implications of the research in the real world, Cadsby said he thinks firms should look carefully at their incentive programs and consider the possible impact on productivity.

“The research suggests rewarding people in proportion to their productivity doesn’t lead to excessive amounts of cheating,” Cadsby said. “It’s when you can be close to a target and by cheating, you can convince your employer that you made that target and get a large bonus as a result that you tend to see a great deal of cheating.”

“If I had that kind of incentive program in place, I’d want to reconsider it.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

City of Red Deer says its roundabouts have sharply reduced the number of injury collisions at a pair of busy intersections. Alberta Transportation wants to incorporate five roundabouts into plans to twin Highway 11 from Sylvan Lake to Rocky Mountain House. Photo by PAUL COWLEY/Advocate staff
Highway 11 roundabouts will increase safety based on Red Deer’s experience

Injury collisions sharply reduced at roundabout intersections in city

As of Friday, Alberta has under 10,000 active COVID-19 cases. (Image courtesy CDC)
One new COVID-19 death in Red Deer, Alberta under 10,000 active cases

Alberta reported an additional 643 COVID-19 cases Friday. The province now has… Continue reading

About 110 students from Red Deer Catholic Regional Schools participated in March for Life rally in Edmonton May 9. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Red Deer high school has COVID-19 case

St. Joseph High School in Red Deer confirmed a positive COVID-19 case… Continue reading

Lacombe High School logo.
Two more COVID-19 cases at Lacombe Composite High School

Lacombe Composite High School confirmed two more positive COVID-19 cases at the… Continue reading

World Juniors’ referee Mike Langin makes a called during the Canada vs. Slovakia at the 2021 World Junior Championship at Rogers Place in Edmonton, Dec. 27, 2020. (Photo by Matthew Murnaghan/Hockey Canada)
Former Sylvan Lake man lives his dream at World Junior Championships

Mike Langin was one the 25 Canadian officials who worked during the tournament

Former Alberta Premier Rachel Notley shakes hands with Joel Ward, former Red Deer College President and CEO, as Notley announces that the college is on the path to grant degrees. Red Deer-South MLA Jason Stephan says university status is not a necessary condition for offering degrees. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Future of Red Deer University increasingly uncertain

MLA’s college update says RDC more like SAIT and NAIT than a university

There are two confirmed COVID-19 cases at Red Deer College. Photo by Mamta Lulla/Advocate staff
Central Albertans were promised a university

Central Albertans were promised a university

FILE - Baseball Hall of Famer Hank Aaron sits for a portrait after receiving his COVID-19 vaccination at the Morehouse School of Medicine in Atlanta, in this Tuesday, Jan. 5, 2021, file photo. Hank Aaron, who endured racist threats with stoic dignity during his pursuit of Babe Ruth but went on to break the career home run record in the pre-steroids era, died early Friday, Jan. 22, 2021. He was 86. The Atlanta Braves said Aaron died peacefully in his sleep. No cause of death was given. (AP Photo/Ron Harris, File)
Hank Aaron, baseball’s one-time home run king, dies at 86

Hank Aaron, baseball’s one-time home run king, dies at 86

Miami Heat guard Duncan Robinson (55) passes the ball around Toronto Raptors guard Fred VanVleet (23) during the second half of an NBA basketball game Friday, Jan. 22, 2021, in Tampa, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara)
Powell, Raptors regroup after blowing lead, beat Heat 101-81

Powell, Raptors regroup after blowing lead, beat Heat 101-81

Tavares scores winner on power play, Leafs beat Oilers 4-2

Tavares scores winner on power play, Leafs beat Oilers 4-2

David Shoemaker, chief executive officer of the Canadian Olympic Committee, speaks during the Olympic Partnership kick off event at the Sobey's office in Mississauga, Ont. on Monday, October 7, 2019. Shoemaker says the IOC remains committed to staging the Summer Games in Tokyo this summer.THE CANADIAN PRESS/ Tijana Martin
Canada’s Olympic athletes try to tune out reports six months from Games

Canada’s Olympic athletes try to tune out reports six months from Games

Toronto FC captain Michael Bradley lifts the Voyageurs Cup after beating Vancouver Whitecaps 5-2 to win the Canadian Championship Final in Toronto on Wednesday, August 15, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young
Forge FC-Toronto FC Canadian Championship final to be played before April 6

Forge FC-Toronto FC Canadian Championship final to be played before April 6

Canada's Penny Oleksiak reacts after her heat of the women's 50m butterfly at the World Swimming Championships in Gwangju, South Korea, Friday, July 26, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Lee Jin-man
Penny Oleksiak, Kylie Masse among six swimmers named early to Canadian Olympic team

Penny Oleksiak, Kylie Masse among six swimmers named early to Canadian Olympic team

Ontario skip Glenn Howard watches a rock as they play Newfoundland and Labrador in draw 15 action at the Tim Hortons Brier curling championship at Mile One Centre in St. John's on Thursday, March 9, 2017. Curling Canada has decided to use the national ranking system as its selection criteria for the final wild-card berths at the Scotties Tournament of Hearts and Tim Hortons Brier.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan
Canadian rankings to be used to determine final wild-card spots at Scotties and Brier

Canadian rankings to be used to determine final wild-card spots at Scotties and Brier

Most Read