A colourized transmission of the MERS coronavirus that emerged in 2012 is pictured.

A colourized transmission of the MERS coronavirus that emerged in 2012 is pictured.

MERS mystery persists

A year after SARS hit the world’s radar, scads had been learned about the virus that set off outbreaks in China, Hong Kong, Toronto and other spots, and ignited panic far beyond the affected centres.

TORONTO — A year after SARS hit the world’s radar, scads had been learned about the virus that set off outbreaks in China, Hong Kong, Toronto and other spots, and ignited panic far beyond the affected centres.

The coronavirus was rapidly discovered, it genome sequenced within weeks of the World Health Organization warning on March 15, 2003, of its existence and spread. The animals that transmitted it to people had been identified. Doctors knew when SARS patients were infectious and what steps needed to be taken to stop its spread. With that knowledge, the virus was quickly contained. SARS is medical history.

Later this week — Friday — will mark a year since the world learned that a cousin of the SARS virus had burst out of some hiding spot in nature to infect and kill a man in Saudi Arabia. Since then, the world has learned of roughly 130 MERS cases, 57 of them fatal.

But in contrast to the SARS outbreak, at this point relatively little is known about MERS. With several million Muslim pilgrims descending on Saudi Arabia — the hottest of MERS hot spots — in coming weeks for the annual Hajj, there is a real sense of worry among scientists watching the outbreak.

Many scientists are at a loss to diplomatically explain the lack of progress.

“We knew more in two to three weeks with SARS than we probably even know now. Maybe it’s three to four weeks,” says Dr. Larry Anderson, the scientist who led the U.S. Centers for Disease Control’s SARS response a decade ago.

Anderson, who now teaches in the medical school at Emory University in Atlanta, says he finds the state of the scientific world’s MERS knowledge “concerning and sad.”

“I think some opportunities clearly have been missed, and it’s surprising to me that we don’t know more than we do,” he says.

“It has put the world at some risk — I don’t know if it’s a large risk or small risk — that we’re not as prepared as we could be if we had some of this information. And if it (the virus) … took off, it would look really bad, I think.”

The director of the Center for Infectious Diseases Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota says he cannot understand why global health bodies like the World Health Organization and governments like his own aren’t publicly complaining about the lack of information.

“This is not just a curiosity exercise. This is a global obligation that the public health officials in the Middle East have in terms of preparing the world for a potential global event,” Michael Osterholm says.

“We all as a global public health community have a right to know what’s being done to stop these ongoing transmissions because this could be in our lap tomorrow.”

A year after the WHO’s first SARS alert, more than 1,000 journal papers had been written about severe acute respiratory syndrome.

At this point, a search for MERS in the PubMed, an online index of scientific papers maintained by the U.S. National Library of Medicine, draws up about 200 hits. Important papers, the ones that flesh out detail of this new disease, are a portion of that total.

Last week, one of the biggest annual infectious diseases conferences in the world took place in Denver, Colo. There wasn’t a single presentation on MERS made at the meeting.

“I think that is a reflection of what studies are actually being done, particularly in the U.S.,” says Dr. Mark Pallansch, who heads the CDC’S MERS response effort.

To the confusion and frustration of a number of scientists watching the outbreak from a distance, it appears Saudi Arabia — the only country to have diagnosed substantial numbers of cases — has not conducted what is known as a case control study on MERS patients.

A case control study is epidemiology 101. This type of research compares people who contract the disease to those who don’t.

It is an invaluable way to start generating ideas about how people are becoming infected and what behaviours, exposures or biological traits put people at greatest risk.

Pallansch admits that when CDC disease detectives are sent to investigate an outbreak, setting up a case control study is high on the list of priority tasks.

Staff of the World Health Organization went so far as to design a template for such a study that Saudi Arabia or any other country with MERS cases could use, posting it on the agency’s website in early July.

Still, the WHO’s point person for MERS, Dr. Tony Mounts, doesn’t know where things stand on the issue — and his lack of knowledge is not from lack of interest.

“I don’t know what has or hasn’t (been done). I just don’t have the information,” Mounts says.

“I know they are talking to patients, I know they are gathering data. Whether they’ve done a formal study yet or not, that’s the question.”

Dr. Ziad Memish, Saudi Arabia’s deputy minister of health, did not reply to a request for an interview for this article.

Dr. Alimuddin Zumla, an infectious diseases researcher at University College London who has been tapped by Memish to help on several Saudi MERS studies, says he does not know of any case control studies on MERS that have been done, though there have been discussions about the idea.

Case reports from Saudi Arabia are bare-bones, leaving the WHO to scramble to gather relevant information.

This far into an outbreak, scientists would expect to see a consistent set of facts about each case, but that hasn’t been forthcoming.

“I think that right now, it is at the stage of ‘Does this data eventually become public through (scientific) publication or presentation, or is it data that does not exist?”’ Pallansch says.

Dr. John Spika, director general of the public health agency’s centre for immunization and respiratory infectious diseases, says Saudi Arabia has been reporting cases more rapidly of late, and he believes there has been a better information flow.

“It obviously could be better. They haven’t done what China did with H7,” he says, referring to H7N9, the new bird flu virus that infected roughly the same number of people as MERS has, but over four months in the late spring and winter.

Chinese scientists shared information rapidly and have pumped out a steady stream of scientific papers on the new virus. “China, what they’ve done with H7 is to me just phenomenal,” says Spika. “But then China also didn’t do so well with SARS.”

Some of the MERS knowledge gaps are the result of cultural factors. To date there hasn’t been a single reported autopsy done on a patient who has died of MERS. Autopsies are rarely if ever done in the Muslim culture.

Matt Frieman, a coronavirus expert at the University of Maryland who is looking for drugs that might work against MERS, says the lack of a single image of the damage the disease does to lungs hinders his work.

There are educated guesses on the incubation period of the disease — the time from exposure to onset of symptoms, which typically falls within a range. With SARS, some people got sick as late as 14 days after exposure; Memish said at a WHO meeting in May that with MERS it can be as long as 14.5 days.

But it’s not yet known when people who are sick are contagious, key information for trying to stop spread of a disease. With SARS, patients were only infectious after they developed symptoms, which meant isolating them and quarantining their contacts stopped the spread. It’s hoped this is true for MERS as well, but the data to prove it either don’t exist or haven’t been shared.

“Ideally we need a prospective study of all new cases where MERS-CoV” — short for coronavirus — “viral load levels are measured in all clinical samples,” says Zumla, referring to sputum, urine and stool and other specimens.

“This is the only way to say how long the infectious period lasts and what infection control measures should be in place.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Alberta reported an additional 1,980 cases of COVID-19 Friday. (NIAID-RML via AP)
Red Deer adds 37th death from COVID-19, active cases drop

Alberta Health identified an additional 1,980 cases of the virus province-wide

A rodeo south of Bowden drew a huge crowd on May 1 and 2, 2021. (Photo courtesy Mom’s Diner’s Facebook page)
Kris Sturgess with Calgary Ghostbusters. (Photo from GoFundMe)
GoFundMe account salutes Red Deer prop builder

Kris Sturgess died unexpectedly April 28

The City of Red Deer says it has not implemented a curfew and will continue to explore options and do what is necessary based on provincial direction. (Advocate file photo).
COVID curfew not on Red Deer city council’s agenda

Red Deer creeping up to 1,000 COVID-19 cases

FILE - A firefighter wears a mask as he drives his truck. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward, File
VIDEO: Flames rip through Edmonton-area seniors complex, but no fatalities

ST. ALBERT, Alta. — Fire has destroyed part of a retirement complex… Continue reading

A man watches the financial numbers on the digital ticker tape at the TMX Group in Toronto's financial district on Friday, May 9, 2014. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darren Calabrese
TSX up for 10th week with gain as weak jobs reports support continued easy money

TSX up for 10th week with gain as weak jobs reports support continued easy money

The Enbridge logo is shown at the company's annual meeting in Calgary on May 9, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Enbridge CEO warns of ‘bad things’ for shippers, consumers if Line 5 shut down

Enbridge CEO warns of ‘bad things’ for shippers, consumers if Line 5 shut down

Cenovus logo seen at the company's headquarters in Calgary, Alta., November 15, 2017. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Cenovus Energy reports $220M first-quarter profit compared with a loss a year ago

Cenovus Energy reports $220M first-quarter profit compared with a loss a year ago

The retail sector has been hit hardest by job-shedding in the COVID-19 pandemic, with stricter restrictions on the operation of non-essential stores implemented in April in Ontario, Alberta and several regions of Quebec, according to the national statistics gathering agency. Included in those losses is Joyce Garant, a beauty adviser for Clinique makeup and skin care at Hudson's Bay department store in Windsor, Ont., seen in an undated handout self-portrait. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Joyce Garant, *MANDATORY CREDIT*
‘Will I ever have the money to pay bills?’ Retail worker faces third layoff in April

‘Will I ever have the money to pay bills?’ Retail worker faces third layoff in April

A Telus sign is seen on a storefront in Halifax on Thursday, Feb. 11, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan
Telus CEO says it’s on track to lower capital spending sharply in 2023

Telus CEO says it’s on track to lower capital spending sharply in 2023

The Keystone Steele City pumping station, into which the planned Keystone XL pipeline was to connect into, in Steele City, Neb., Nov. 3, 2015. TC Energy Corp. is reporting a first-quarter net loss of $1.1 billion after taking a $2.2-billion after-tax asset impairment charge on its cancelled Keystone XL export oil pipeline. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Nati Harnik
TC Energy reports $1.1-billion net loss after $2.2-billion writedown on Keystone XL

TC Energy reports $1.1-billion net loss after $2.2-billion writedown on Keystone XL

FILE - In this Wednesday, Nov. 4, 2020, file photo, the Rev. Jacqui Lewis, senior pastor at Middle Collegiate Church, speaks during an interfaith gathering outside of the Judson Memorial Church near Washington Square Park in New York. Muslims, Jews, Christians and Buddhists came together to show solidarity among faith communities as the country awaited the final result of the U.S. presidential election. (AP Photo/Emily Leshner, File)
National Day of Prayer inspires pleas for unity and justice

National Day of Prayer inspires pleas for unity and justice

Most Read