Notion of ‘mature minors’ in assisted death legislation raises thorny questions

A special parliamentary committee has recommended that legislation governing doctor-assisted death for competent adults be expanded within three years to include "mature minors" under the age of 18.

TORONTO — A special parliamentary committee has recommended that legislation governing doctor-assisted death for competent adults be expanded within three years to include “mature minors” under the age of 18.

The notion of a young person seeking help to terminate their lives raises a number of thorny questions, not the least of which is how does one define a mature minor?

The Canadian Paediatric Society opposes mature minors being included in legislation, which the federal government must draft and pass before June 6, when assisted suicide becomes legal in Canada.

However, Dr. Dawn Davies, chairwoman of CPS’s bioethics committee, said the organization will not have a full position statement on the issue until it completes a survey of its members.

“What we suspect is that most pediatricians and pediatric health practitioners would not think that mature minors should be included, at least in the first iteration of the legislation, just because of the weight of the decision being made,” Davies said Thursday from Edmonton.

As to how to define when a minor is considered mature enough to make a decision about ending his or her life, Davies said there is no specific age “and that’s where it becomes very related to the individual child.”

“Really, we’re just looking at can they comprehend the information that’s being presented to them? Do they understand all the options and the outcomes of those options? And is there a durability about their wish.”

Dr. Derryck Smith, who made a submission to the committee during its hearings, said qualifying for assisted death should not be dependent on age, but on whether a person is competent to agree to a medical treatment, including aid in dying.

“Children and teenagers do die and they suffer just as much as adults who are dying,” Smith, the former head of child psychiatry at B.C. Children’s Hospital, said from Vancouver.

“The basic principle is why do we want people of any age to suffer unnecessarily if ultimately they are going to die?”

There are standard measurements for determining competency, which are blind to the age of the individual. So it’s up to the practitioners assessing a patient to decide, based on those standards, if a young person is capable of understanding and consenting to the terminal nature of their request, he said.

“Is a seven-year-old likely to be competent? Probably not. But that’s not because they happen to be seven, it’s because they wouldn’t understand the issues” needed to determine if they have capacity, he said.

Even so, Smith agrees with the committee’s recommendation that Parliament should wait three years before extending the right to die to mature minors.

“I think we need to proceed cautiously with this because it’s controversial.”

To date, Belgium and the Netherlands are the only two jurisdictions that allow minors access to physician-assisted death.

Just Posted

Red Deer songwriter draws on winter, childhood to write Games closing ceremonies song

Kayla Williams is excited to perform ‘Something Right’ March 2 at the Centrium.

House in Calgary destroyed in fire following apparent explosion, officials say

CALGARY — A house was destroyed when a fire broke out following… Continue reading

Historic win for Team Nunavut at Canada Winter Games

Four years in the making boiled down to a collection of firsts… Continue reading

Alberta missionaries among the Canadians heading home from riot-stricken Haiti

MONTREAL — A group of Canadian missionaries who were trapped in Haiti… Continue reading

Historic win for Team Nunavut at Canada Winter Games

Four years in the making boiled down to a collection of firsts… Continue reading

South African activists try to protect endangered pangolins

JOHANNESBURG — As World Pangolin Day is marked around the globe, Saturday,… Continue reading

Fourteen ‘dream’ homes ordered evacuated as sinkholes open in Sechelt, B.C.

Greg and Gerry Latham spent Friday morning scrambling to pack up family… Continue reading

Former B.C. premier Gordon Campbell accused of sexual assault: British newspaper

LONDON — A British newspaper says police in London are investigating an… Continue reading

Graham: U.S. should be stronger on Canadians detained in China

MUNICH — U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham said Friday the response by the… Continue reading

Conservative leaders to attend pro-pipeline rally in Saskatchewan

By Stephanie Taylor THE CANADIAN PRESS MOOSOMIN, Sask. — Federal Tory leader… Continue reading

Games athletes making themselves at home at RDC

Red Deer College’s campus will be home for the athletes during the 2019 Canada Winter Games

Alix resident captures beams of light near Lacombe

Lacombe, Blackfalds, Red Deer photos have since gone viral around the world

Welcome message from the mayor

On behalf of Red Deer city council, the City of Red Deer… Continue reading

Most Read