Permissive parenting leads to kids’ destructive behaviours

You have been very critical of behavioral scientists and other writers who recommend a more permissive approach to child-rearing.

Question: You have been very critical of behavioral scientists and other writers who recommend a more permissive approach to child-rearing.

Explain why this concerns you. Why is it ever wrong to be kind and merciful to a boy or girl?

Answer: The issue is not one of kindness and mercy. It is one of loving authority and leadership at home, which is in the child’s best interest. The majority of books and seminars since 1950 on child raising have effectively stripped parents of the ability to deal with willful defiance when it occurs.

First, they haven’t admitted that such behavior happens, and second, they have given parents no tools with which to confront it. This bad advice has led to a type of paralysis in dealing with kids. In the absence of “permission” to step in and lead, parents were left with only their anger and frustration in response to defiant behavior.

Let me give an example from a parenting text entitled Your Child from Two to Five, published during the permissive 1950s. In it was a bit of characteristic advice from that era, paraphrased from the writings of a Dr. Luther Woodward, as follows:

“What do you do when your preschooler calls you a ‘big stinker’ or threatens to flush you down the toilet? Do you scold — punish — or sensibly take it in your stride? Dr. Woodward recommends a positive policy of understanding as the best and fastest way to help a child outgrow this verbal violence.

When parents fully realize that all little tots feel angry and destructive at times, they are better able to minimize these outbursts.

Once the preschooler gets rid of his hostility, the desire to destroy is gone and instinctive feelings of love and affection have a chance to sprout and grow. Once the child is six or seven, parents can rightly let the child know that he is expected to be outgrowing sassing his parents.”

Having recommended that passive approach, with which I disagree strongly, Dr. Woodward then told parents to brace themselves for unjust criticism. He wrote, “But this policy (of letting children engage in defiance) takes a broad perspective and a lot of composure, especially when friends and relatives voice disapproval and warn that you are bringing up a brat.”

According to the optimistic Dr. Woodward, the tot who has been calling his mother a “big stinker” for six or seven years can be expected to transform, like a butterfly emerging from a cocoon, into a sweet and loving seven-year-old. That outcome is most improbable. Dr. Woodward’s “policy of understanding” (which means “policy of permissiveness”) leads directly to adolescent rebellion in strong-willed children.

Question: My wife has been severely depressed for nearly three months. What kind of treatment or therapy would you recommend for her?

Answer: Get her to a physician, perhaps a psychiatrist or internist, as soon as possible.

This kind of prolonged depression can have serious medical and psychological consequences, yet it is usually very responsive to treatment.

Antidepressant drugs are effective in controlling most cases of depression.

She could also be entering menopause and may need estrogen replacement therapy or some other hormone treatment.

Of course, medication will not correct an emotional problem, if that is what underlies her depression. She may need to talk to a psychologist or a counselor after you have approached the problem from a medical perspective. The important thing is to get going. Depression should not be permitted to continue unchecked.

James Dobson is founder and Chairman Emeritus of the nonprofit organization Focus on the Family, Colorado Springs, Colo. 80995 (www.family.org).

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Rainbow flag raised at Red Deer College to kick off Pride Week

Central Alberta Pride Week runs next week

Alberta to explore small nuclear technology

EDMONTON — The Alberta government says it plans to join three other… Continue reading

From masks to cohorting, a guide to back-to-school rules across the country

Plans are being made across the country for how to safely send… Continue reading

Red Deer asking for feedback on new transit routes

The new routes will begin Aug. 23

Updated: Red Deer region unemployment hits 14%

Unemployment in Red Deer region nearly double July 2019 rate of 7.4%

Protestors for Indigenous Lives Matter gather in Wetaskiwin

Protestors gathered along 56 St Wetaskiwin, Alta. August 4, 2020 for Indigenous Lives Matter.

Cast your votes for Best of Red Deer

The Red Deer Advocate’s Best of Red Deer Reader’s Choice Awards are… Continue reading

‘Caught up in the frenzy:’ Oilers 50/50 draw breaking ticket sale records

EDMONTON — Frenzy over the Edmonton Oilers online 50/50 draw continued Friday,… Continue reading

POLL: Do you plan on leaving the province on holiday this summer?

Do you plan on leaving the province on holiday this summer?… Continue reading

Flower show open to the public

The Alberta Dahlia and Gladiolus Society will host its annual flower display… Continue reading

Innisfail Eagles to play in Ranchlands Hockey League in 2020-21

Eagles have still declared as a senior AAA team for next season

Red Deer Rebels lend helping hand to Vancouver Canucks

The hockey community is a tight-knit one and it was the Red… Continue reading

Labyrinth is a gift to neighbours

Lacombe resident encourages others to use their imagination

You have nothing to fear from central EMS dispatching

My name is Brad Higgins. I am reaching out with respect to… Continue reading

Most Read