Quebec’s food allergy policies questioned

MONTREAL — Quebec should consider a province-wide framework on how schools manage food allergies rather than leaving it up to individual school boards, allergy experts said Wednesday.

The government was forced to defend its lack of provincial protocol this week after a Montreal school board announced it wouldn’t tell parents what to pack in their kids’ lunches.

In a memo to parents, the Commission scolaire de Montreal said school staff will not confiscate any food brought to school as it is up to parents to decide what their children eat.

The memo said students will be required to wash their hands before and after meals and are prohibited from sharing food.

“School staff are present during lunch hour and know the children who have allergies,” the memo stated. “They have at their disposal many strategies to intervene in order to protect children with severe allergies while respecting everyone’s lunches.”

The memo made headlines across the province and highlighted how Quebec is one of the only provinces without legislation or clear policy on how schools manage students’ food allergies.

David Fischer, president of the Canadian Society of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, said school food policy is a “thorny and controversial topic.”

But he added a province-wide approach is useful.

“Anything that is mandatory and regimented can help,” Fischer said.

There is a consensus among academics and other experts on how schools can reduce and treat serious allergic reactions, called anaphylaxis, but it doesn’t include “banning” foods, he explained.

Fischer said there is no data indicating food bans reduce risks of anaphylaxis and there is even a “slight trend” of increases of reactions in places where food bans have been tried.

His organization’s guidelines include adult supervision when children are eating; no sharing food; washing hands with soap before and after eating; and properly cleaning surfaces such as tables.

Ontario introduced legislation in 2006 forcing schools in the province to have an allergy policy that includes individual safety plans for at-risk students, emergency procedures, and training for school staff.

The Ontario government said the law was the first of its kind in the world.

Fischer said Ontario’s law “isn’t necessarily as good as people think it is” because while it stipulates that every school should have a plan, the legislation doesn’t say what that plan should be.

Gwen Smith, editor of Allergic Living magazine, said the Montreal school board’s memo places too much emphasis on parents making lunches, “but pays only lip service to the very real needs of children with severe food allergies.”

“I suspect you’ll see backlash to this from parents of young allergic children,” she said. ”They will, quite rightly, be wanting more details of how their children are protected if they are to be in a milieu in which many other young children are eating a major allergen or allergens.”

Quebec Education Minister Sebastien Proulx said Tuesday he has “confidence” that individual school boards can properly manage their own policies regarding reducing the risks of allergic reactions in schools.

Health Minister Gaetan Barrette added there are an “infinite” number of foods that can cause allergic reactions.

“There is a public perception that when it comes to allergies, we’re talking about peanut butter or shellfish,” he said. “But there are people allergic to things like carrots. There are so many different kinds of allergies that if we drew up a list, we would end up banning all food.”

Just Posted

Red Deer College waiting for feds to finalize marijuana legalization

Like businesses, Alberta and municipal governments, Red Deer College is waiting for… Continue reading

Class size only part of the problem say Central Alberta teachers

Though the Alberta auditor general’s report points out that classroom sizes continue… Continue reading

Lacombe County promoting crime prevention measures

County pushing Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design principles

Red Deer doctor concerned about patient transfers to rural hospitals

Family physician says the move creates less incentive for expansion at Red Deer hospital

Fire permit season begins in March

Earlier springs in last few years prompted Alberta government to move up fire permit season

WATCH: Red Deer’s River Bend upgrades officially open

River Bend Golf and Recreation Area is the latest venue to be… Continue reading

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

As Olympics wrap up, still no coverage in North Korea

PYEONGCHANG, Korea, Republic Of — While hundreds of millions of the world’s… Continue reading

Supplier to NHL’s Calgary Flames breathes again as B.C. wine ban suspended

VICTORIA — The operators of a small British Columbia winery that landed… Continue reading

Canada’s men’s hockey team beats Czechs to win Olympic bronze

GANGNEUNG, Korea, Republic Of — Canada’s men’s hockey team has won the… Continue reading

Duncan apologizes for behaviour after drunken joyride in Pyeongchang

PYEONGCHANG, Korea, Republic Of — Canadian ski cross racer Dave Duncan is… Continue reading

In Pyeongchang, maintaining Olympic venues relies on a poor, aging workforce

GANGNEUNG, South Korea - Hockey players from Finland were circling with the… Continue reading

Trudeau’s fashion missteps highlight what not to wear on vacation

TORONTO — The traditional garb that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his… Continue reading

Stores make push in scan and go tech, hope shoppers adopt it

NEW YORK — Shoppers at self-checkout lanes scanning all their groceries after… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month