Series of mistakes plagues trial

Everything that could possibly go wrong in a robbery trial did on Thursday.

Everything that could possibly go wrong in a robbery trial did on Thursday.

Two Red Deer accused of the armed robbery of a city liquor store last year had their trial adjourned in provincial court because of a series of mistakes by the court, Crown and RCMP.

John Louis Umperville, 50, and Leebert Ernest Jellifo, 44, are both charged with armed robbery and being masked while committing an offence in connection with the Nov. 10, 2008, robbery of the North Liquor Barn.

The first glitch occurred when Umperville’s lawyer John MacNaughton raised objection to the presence of Judge David Plosz, who was set to hear the case.

Plosz was supposed to have been disqualified from hearing the case because he denied Umperville his release on bail shortly after his arrest.

Judges are disqualified from hearing anything further on a case if they hear the bail review because of the perception of bias.

At the bail review, MacNaughton said Plosz asked the clerk to flag the case noting his disqualification.

Secondly, and more importantly, Plosz said, was that both MacNaughton and Jellifo’s lawyer Paul Morigeau hadn’t been presented copies of video surveillance taken by a store camera of the robbery.

Two copies of the tape were in the Crown’s file but hadn’t been turned over to the defence.

The third glitch was the failure of the RCMP and Crown to provide the defence lawyers with copies of a statement of one of three civilian witnesses. That was done only moments before court opened a second time.

A day had been set aside for the trial but it was clear to the lawyers and the court that two days are needed. The Crown planned to call six RCMP officers and the three civilians.

This was the second adjournment of the trial. The first occurred on Jan. 2 because MacNaughton was ill and some witnesses weren’t present.

Morigeau said he was anxious to have the trial start immediately since Jellifo remains in custody after having his federal parole revoked because of the charges.

Umperville spent about two months in custody until he was granted bail in Court of Queen’s Bench in January.

At the time of the robbery, it was disclosed that a man wearing a mask and armed with a knife robbed the store of $110 in cash.

Two suspects were arrested shortly after.

The trial has been adjourned until Nov. 12 and 13.

jwilson@bprda.wpengine.com

Just Posted

Everything from coffee makers to coats in latest Canada Games sale

Sale runs 1 to 7 p.m. at Games office at Bower Place mall

Town of Sylvan Lake has big ideas for lakeshore

Day mooring docks wanted but first water licence needed from province

Red Deer business moves away from overdose prevention site

At least one Red Deer business has moved away from the temporary… Continue reading

Canada Revenue Agency tax services back online after ‘hardware’ problems

OTTAWA — The websites Canadians use to file their taxes online were… Continue reading

Roof structures failed before Radiohead stage came down, inquest hears

TORONTO — Metal structures meant to hold a roof over a stage… Continue reading

Opinion: Business tax relief is a sound idea

NDP leader should avoid picking winners and losers

Svechnikov scores in overtime, Carolina beats Montreal 2-1

RALEIGH, N.C. — The Carolina Hurricanes struggled to beat Montreal goaltender Carey… Continue reading

Canadian men’s soccer squad off to Gold Cup with 4-1 win over French Guiana

VANCOUER, B.C. — Canada’s men’s soccer team is looking to the future… Continue reading

Inquest into fatal Radiohead stage collapse set to get underway in Toronto

TORONTO — An inquest is set to get underway today into the… Continue reading

The Latest: Streisand apologizes for Jackson comments

NEW YORK — The Latest on Barbra Streisand’s comments about the sexual… Continue reading

Pricey Titanic wreck tours hope to bring new life to a century-old story

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — Adventure tourists with money in the bank have… Continue reading

Most Read