Appeal Court says Alberta judge relied on stereotypes in sex assault case

EDMONTON — The Alberta Court of Appeal has overturned the acquittal of a man convicted of sexually assaulting his stepdaughter after finding the trial judge relied on myths and stereotypes around the behaviour of victims.

In a split decision released this week, the three-judge panel ordered a new trial for the 55-year-old man on three counts of sexual assault.

He can’t be named under a publication ban.

During the man’s trial in February 2016, the stepdaughter told Court of Queen’s Bench Justice Terry Clackson that her stepfather regularly assaulted her over six years, starting when she was in Grade 4.

The stepfather testified he was never alone with the child long enough for the offences to take place.

Clackson told court he was left with doubts about the allegations because the girl, now an adult, had an “otherwise normal parent/child relationship” with the accused.

“I would have expected some evidence of avoidance either conscious or unconscious. There was no such evidence,” Clackson ruled. ”As a matter of logic and common sense, one would expect that a victim of sexual abuse would demonstrate behaviours consistent with that abuse or at least some change of behaviour such as avoiding the perpetrator.”

Two of the three appeal judges said that reasoning was wrong.

“The trial judge’s acquittals were directly tied to a legal error of applying an impermissible stereotype or myth that avoidant behaviour was ‘expected,’ and concluding the absence of such behaviour negatively impacted the complainant’s credibility,” wrote justices Marina Paperny and Frederica Schutz.

“It was the trial judge’s assessment that a victim would avoid her perpetrator or otherwise exhibit a change of behaviour; he thus engaged in a prohibited, stereotypical-based assessment of credibility that cannot stand.”

The third appeal judge, Justice Frans Slatter, disagreed. He cited a section of Clackson’s decision in which Clackson noted that he was not relying on ”myths of appropriate behaviour” to judge the girl’s credibility.

“Since the trial judge had just instructed himself not to rely on any stereotypes about the conduct of sexual assault victims, it is not appropriate to assume that he did so anyway,” Slatter wrote.

“The reasons for judgment must be read as a whole and in context. Determining if there is a reasonable doubt based on the evidence or absence of evidence is the particular mandate of the trial judge.”

Just Posted

Blackfalds firefighter battling cancer

A volunteer firefighter in Blackfalds for 15 years, Dave Sutherland now battling… Continue reading

Red Deer transit users are concerned about the future

But recreation centre users are glad facility hours were maintained

Community cardiac awareness dinner and show to be held

Continued focus to bring cardiac catheterization lab to Red Deer

Red Deer businesses react to 2.02 per cent tax increase for 2018

Chamber would prefer zero increase, while DBA thinks it’s reasonable

Bring on the rodeo says Red Deer County mayor

Canadian Finals Rodeo’s move to Red Deer good for whole region, says Red Deer County Mayor Jim Wood

WATCH news on the go: Replay Red Deer Jan. 21

Watch news highlights from Red Deer and Central Alberta

RDC chosen to host 2019 men’s volleyball national championship

Sports enthusiasts in Red Deer will have more to look forward to… Continue reading

Police is still looking for Second World War army passport owner

No one has claimed a rare Second World War German army passport… Continue reading

DJ Sabatoge and TR3 Band kick off Sylvan Lake’s Winterfest 2018

Central Alberta’s youngest DJ will open for TR3 Band kicking off Town… Continue reading

Two Canadians, two Americans abducted in Nigeria are freed

Kidnapping for ransom is common in Nigeria, especially on the Kaduna to Abuja highway

WATCH news on the go: Replay Red Deer Jan. 21

Watch news highlights from Red Deer and Central Alberta

Liberals quietly tap experts to write new paternity leave rules

Ideas include creating an entirely new leave benefit similar to one that exists in Quebec

Insurers say Canadian weather getting hotter, wetter and weirder

Average number of days with heavy rain or snow across Canada has been outside norm since spring 2013

Are you ready for some wrestling? WWE’s ‘Raw’ marks 25 years

WWE flagship show is set to mark its 25th anniversary on Monday

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month