Lawyers clash in top court

Robert Pickton was the “head honcho” in the murders of six Vancouver prostitutes and any mistakes at his trial should not undo his lawful conviction, the Supreme Court of Canada heard Thursday.

Legal counsel for Robert Pickton Gil McKinnon (left) leaves Supreme Court of Canada in Ottawa

Legal counsel for Robert Pickton Gil McKinnon (left) leaves Supreme Court of Canada in Ottawa

OTTAWA — Robert Pickton was the “head honcho” in the murders of six Vancouver prostitutes and any mistakes at his trial should not undo his lawful conviction, the Supreme Court of Canada heard Thursday.

British Columbia prosecutor John Gordon told the high court no errors were made by the judge at Pickton’s 2007 trial — and even if there were errors, they were so minor they do not warrant a new trial.

Gordon was rebutting earlier arguments by Pickton’s lawyer, Gil McKinnon, that the former pig farmer did not receive a fair trial when he was convicted of six second-degree murder charges in the deaths of sex-trade workers in Vancouver’s squalid Downtown Eastside.

The Crown contends its case against Pickton was so overwhelming that he couldn’t possibly avoid conviction at another trial, so justice would not be served by ordering a new one.

Pickton’s appeal hinges on instructions the trial judge gave to jurors after they returned with a question on the sixth day of deliberations.

They wanted to know whether they could still convict Pickton if he was aided by an accomplice.

The Supreme Court reserved judgment Thursday but not before a full panel of justices grilled prosecution and defence lawyers during the two-hour hearing.

Debate centred on whether the initial instruction by the trial judge was adequate.

They also wanted to know whether his subsequent answer to the jury muddied the waters further, possibly undermining Pickton’s constitutional right to fully answer the charges against him.

“There was a failure, a procedural error, in failing to qualify the question,” said McKinnon.

Justice Louise Charron raised the issue of whether an ideal set of instructions would have made a difference to the trial’s outcome.

“How could a full aiding-and-abetting instruction from the word get-go possibly have benefited Mr. Pickton?” she asked.

“I don’t say it could have,” replied McKinnon.

“So we would send him back for a new trial for something that could not possibility benefit him?” Charron answered.

Justice Louis Lebel noted the “root cause” of the jury’s uncertainty was the failure of the trial judge to give proper instructions in his original charge.

Gordon said the trial prosecutors made a mistake by relying on the too-narrow theory that Pickton acted alone.

Yet evidence emerged at trial of the involvement of others in the killings, and none of it diminished Pickton’s guilt.

“He was, as he admitted, the head honcho,” Gordon argued.

The jury that convicted him realized that Pickton was “the one constant at each and every stage of the scheme, at each and every instance of its execution,” Gordon told the justices.

Pickton is serving a life sentence with no possibility of parole for 25 years.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney updates media on measures taken to help with COVID-19, in Edmonton on Friday, March 20, 2020. Alberta is set to join three other provinces in exploring the feasibility of small modular reactors as a clean energy option. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Four provinces to sign memorandum of understanding to explore small nuclear reactors

Alberta, Ontario, Saskatchewan and New Brunswick sign memorandum of understanding

Demonstrators take cover from crowd-dispersal munitions from police outside the Brooklyn Center Police Department while protesting the shooting death of Daunte Wright, late Tuesday, April 13, 2021, in Brooklyn Center, Minn. (AP Photo/John Minchillo)
Minnesota shooting charging decision awaited, protests go on

Police and protesters faced off once again after nightfall Tuesday

Storage tanks are shown at the Marathon Petroleum Corp. refinery in Detroit on April 21, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP, Paul Sancya
U.S. oil comprised 77 per cent of Canada’s foreign oil imports last year: regulator

U.S. absorbed 96 per cent of Canadian oil exports last year

House prices in Alberta are going up in many communities, reports the ATB. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graeme Roy)
Alberta’s house prices are on the rise: ATB

Supply has been low, relative to demand

The interchange at Highway 2 and McKenzie Road at the south end of Gasoline Alley is being redesigned with two roundabouts. Construction is expected to begin this month and finish in October. (Graphic from Red Deer County)
Roudabouts coming to McKenzie Road overpass at Gasoline Alley

Project expected to improve traffic flow at busy intersections

A prairie fire in the Burnt Lake district. (Photo by Bert Fors via Red Deer Archives)
Michael Dawe: Fires of spring 1931 in central Alberta

Central Alberta has just come through a relatively warm and dry winter… Continue reading

Gwynne Dyer
Opinion: Boris Johnson is to blame for what’s happening in Ireland

Twenty-three years of peace in Northern Ireland, after a sectarian war that… Continue reading

Canada's Sarah Pavan and Melissa Humana-Paredes, fom left, celebrate after winning women's gold medal match against Brazil's team at the Beach Volley Worldtour Major Series, in Vienna, Austria on August 4, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP, Ronald Zak
Canada’s world champion beach volleyball duo finally getting games before Tokyo

Canada’s world champion beach volleyball duo finally getting games before Tokyo

Toronto Raptors center Khem Birch (24) gets fouled by Atlanta Hawks guard Bogdan Bogdanovic (13) during the first half of an NBA basketball game Tuesday, April 13, 2021, in Tampa, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara)
Bogdanovic, Capela lead Hawks past Raptors 107-103

Bogdanovic, Capela lead Hawks past Raptors 107-103

Titanic was the largest and most luxurious ship in the world. Photo provided and colourized by Jiri Ferdinand.
QUIZ: How much do you know about the world’s most famous shipwreck?

Titanic sank 109 years ago today, after hitting an iceberg

Toronto Blue Jays starting pitcher Hyun Jin Ryu throws to a New York Yankees batter during the first inning of a baseball game Tuesday, April 13, 2021, in Dunedin, Fla. (AP Photo/Mike Carlson)
Ryu sharp into 7th, Semien homers as Blue Jays top Yanks 7-3

Ryu sharp into 7th, Semien homers as Blue Jays top Yanks 7-3

Calgary Flames' Johnny Gaudreau (13) scores the game winning goal on Toronto Maple Leafs goaltender David Rittich (33) in overtime NHL action in Toronto on Tuesday, April 13, 2021.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Frank Gunn
Gaudreau scores in overtime, Flames beat Maple Leafs 3-2

Gaudreau scores in overtime, Flames beat Maple Leafs 3-2

Jim Bullock, Vicki Pappas and Randy Waples off to Canadian Horse Racing Hall of Fame

Jim Bullock, Vicki Pappas and Randy Waples off to Canadian Horse Racing Hall of Fame

Most Read