Spy agency heard allegations of prisoner abuse: CSIS report

The Canadian Security Intelligence Service was aware of allegations that prisoners in Afghanistan were abused, but had no “first-hand knowledge” of torture, says an internal report on the spy agency’s involvement with detainees.

OTTAWA — The Canadian Security Intelligence Service was aware of allegations that prisoners in Afghanistan were abused, but had no “first-hand knowledge” of torture, says an internal report on the spy agency’s involvement with detainees.

The newly declassified review also says while CSIS “appeared to be tardy in issuing directions and guidelines” on interviewing Afghan detainees, the selection of appropriate personnel and a “common sense approach” to the task ensured the spy service’s “credibility and professional reputation was maintained.”

“The service has since formalized appropriate direction to its officers in dealing with issues of detainees in Afghanistan.”

Last March The Canadian Press revealed CSIS’s involvement in interviewing suspected Taliban fighters alongside military intelligence officers.

In response, CSIS director Dick Fadden commissioned the “comprehensive review” of the service’s activities given the “controversial and high-profile nature” of the issue with the Canadian government, the 13-page report says.

A draft version of the secret April report, with several deletions, was obtained this week under the Access to Information Act.

The Canadian army is thought to have captured hundreds of suspected Taliban fighters over the last nine years. Reports indicate that since 2006 almost 500 have been handed over to Afghan authorities.

CSIS questioned Afghan detainees from 2002 through late 2007, when the military began to conduct interrogations without assistance. The report says the shift occurred “as there was a concern with respect to the legalities and procedures in allowing outside agencies to be involved.”

For the review, CSIS examined files dating as far back as 2002 and interviewed service employees directly involved in the detainee file.

“CSIS policies/directional statements specific to employees’ involvement in matters of Afghan detainees were not in place at the beginning of the service deployment to Afghanistan,” the report says.

“This has only recently been rectified.”

The review identified two outstanding issues, including an incorrectly worded draft Canadian Forces standing order that indicated “CSIS had the lead” on interrogating detainees.

CSIS spokeswoman Isabelle Scott said the correction has been made. The second, undisclosed issue was also addressed, she said, declining to elaborate.

The review findings are consistent with past CSIS insistence that the Canadian Forces were responsible for deciding whether to transfer prisoners to Afghan custody.

However, the report discloses that CSIS played an occasional “facilitation” role as a “liaison conduit” in transfers between Canadian military and Foreign Affairs officials and the infamous Afghan National Directorate of Security.

CSIS officers posted to Afghanistan had “no first-hand knowledge of the abuse, mistreatment or torture of detainees by either (Canadian Forces) or Afghan authorities,” the report says.

However, allegations of “possible abuse by Afghan authorities did exist,” says the report.

Subsequent details have been redacted.

Early on in Afghanistan, the military hoped to “capitalize on the cultural knowledge and experience” of CSIS in the interview process. While the Forces had “well documented” procedures, CSIS involvement was less structured, the review says.

“The Review Team found no indication that direction from (CSIS national headquarters) was sought or provided on the issue of service involvement in the interview of detainees in the custody of the (Canadian Forces).”

Over time, the military became wary of CSIS involvement.

“Even though the CF turned to the service for assistance in conducting interviews of detainees, there was a growing recognition among the CF Intelligence cadre that this process was neither sustainable nor preferred, from a CF professional point of view.”

The review says the precise number of interviews the service participated in is unknown.

However, CSIS has previously put the number at 40 to 50.

The interviews focused on the identities of captives, basic biographical information and “critical intelligence” related to Forces security, the report says.

It says mistreatment of prisoners was not NDS policy but quite the opposite in that “the NDS wanted to prosecute those accused of being terrorists with regard to due diligence to the rules of (Afghan) law.”

“Absent of evidence which could be used in a judicial proceeding, the NDS would release the prisoners from custody.”

Nevertheless, the report acknowledges there continues to be a predominating belief that prisoners “were/are abused at the hands of their Afghan custodians.”

“The service remains cognizant of these allegations and strives to confirm or refute them.”

Some in the Canadian military have publicly defended the notorious Afghan intelligence service.

Maj.-Gen. Mike Ward, in testimony before the Military Police Complaints Commission last fall, called the NDS “a highly thought of organization” and complained the Afghans had been unjustly tarred in human rights reports, including those by the U.S. State Department and Foreign Affairs in Ottawa.

“I’ve read a lot of those reports and just spent a year reading more and more of those reports,” he testified on Sept. 9, 2010.

“They don’t help very much because you create an expectation of a climate of torture or terror in Afghan prisons that is actually not accurate.

“Just as everything is not hunky-dory, these are not torture chambers per se and as I think we’ve found out subsequently.”

Yet Canadian diplomats received reports of potential abuse as late as January 2010, according to documents uncovered by The Canadian Press.

During an unannounced inspection of the Kandahar NDS detention facility, a diplomat and correctional officer were flagged down by a prisoner who’d been captured by Canadian troops.

The date of the actual visit was censored, but the document was written on Jan. 10, 2010.

The suspect alleged his captors threatened to kill him and slapped him around, says a report obtained under the Access to Information law.

“The detainee stated the slaps were delivered with a back and forth motion of the open hand,” says the significant incident report.

The diplomat “observed no visible marks on the inside of the mouth of the detainee.”

When the Foreign Affairs officer went back to verify the allegation on Jan. 3, 2010, the NDS said it had released the suspect.

The Canadian case was closed.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Ice shifted to the shoreline at Sylvan Lake on April 21. (Photo contributed by Andrea Swainson)
Icy shores of Sylvan Lake

A local photographer has captured how the ice has shifted to the… Continue reading

Curtis Labelle (second from left) and his band are planning a cross-Canada tour in 2022. Meanwhile, Labelle is continuing to host his weekly livestreamed talk show, Chattin 88. (Contributed photo).
Red Deer rock pianist takes on a talk show role

Curtis Labelle’s Chattin 88 gets views from around the globe

A boat sits idle on the banks of Villa Victoria Dam, the main water supply for Mexico City residents, on the outskirts of Toluca, Mexico, Thursday, April 22, 2021. The mayor of Mexico City said the drought was the worst in 30 years, and that problem can be seen at the series of reservoirs that bring in water from other states to supply the capital. (AP Photo/Fernando Llano)
FILE - In this Jan. 18, 2020, file photo Caitlyn Jenner speaks at the 4th Women’s March in Los Angeles. Jenner has been an Olympic hero, a reality TV personality and a transgender rights activist. Jenner has been consulting privately with Republican advisers as she considers joining the field of candidates seeking to replace Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom in a likely recall election later this year. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes, File)
Jenner adds celebrity, questions to California governor race

Celebrity activist immediately stands out in a growing field

FILE - In this Thursday, Feb. 14, 2019 file photo, Jeremy Fleming, head of the British Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ), in London. Western countries risk losing control of technologies that are key to internet security and economic prosperity to nations with competing values like China and Russia if they don’t act to deal with the threat, one of the U.K.’s top spy chiefs warned on Friday, April 23, 2021. “Significant technology leadership is moving East” and causing a conflict of interests and values, Jeremy Fleming, director of government electronic surveillance agency GCHQ, said in a speech. (AP Photo/Frank Augstein, file)
UK spy chief says West faces ‘moment of reckoning’ on tech

China’s Foreign Ministry condemn the remarks

Brooke Henderson, of Canada, watches her tee shot on the 17th hole during the final round of the Tournament of Champions LPGA golf tournament, Sunday, Jan. 24, 2021, in Lake Buena Vista, Fla. (AP Photo/Phelan M. Ebenhack)
Canadian Brooke Henderson vaults into tie for fourth at LPGA Tour event

Henderson is sixth in the world women’s golf rankings

Switzerland’s skip Silvana Tirinzoni makes a call during a women’s curling match against Canada at the 2018 Winter Olympics in Gangneung, South Korea, Sunday, Feb. 18, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Natacha Pisarenko
Previously unbeaten women’s teams suffer setbacks at Grand Slam curling event

Top six women’s and men’s teams qualify for the playoffs.

FILE - Gal Gadot arrives at the Vanity Fair Oscar Party on Sunday, Feb. 9, 2020, in Beverly Hills, Calif. Gadot is using her Hollywood star power to spotlight remarkable women from around the world. The “Wonder Woman” actor is host and executive producer of a new documentary series “National Geographic Presents IMPACT with Gal Gadot,” premiering Monday, April 26. (Photo by Evan Agostini/Invision/AP, File)
Gal Gadot spotlights women’s stories in new docuseries

First episode follows a young Black figure skating coach in Detroit

Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Minister Marco Mendicino listens to speakers during a news conference in Ottawa, Friday October 2, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Retaking language test unfair during COVID-19: applicants to new residency pathway

New program aims to grant 90,000 essential workers and international graduates permanent status

LtE bug
Letter: Questions around city funding for Westerner

The Advocate article on April 21 on page 3 “Council to discuss… Continue reading

Most Read