Top court clears Crown in satanic sex-abuse case

The Crown attorney who pressed a controversial satanic sex-abuse case against two foster parent families in Saskatchewan did not act maliciously, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled.

OTTAWA — The Crown attorney who pressed a controversial satanic sex-abuse case against two foster parent families in Saskatchewan did not act maliciously, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled.

In a 7-0 decision, the court erased a malicious prosecution finding against Matthew Miazga.

Miazga, police officer Brian Dueck, and child therapist Carol Bunko-Ruys were all accused of malice in the 1991 case against the Klassen and Kvelo families based on complaints from three children.

The children told police that they had been sexually abused and forced into satanic rituals including the mutilation and killing of animals, dismemberment of babies and drinking of human blood.

The charges were all stayed after the children admitted to making up the accusations.

The families sued for malicious prosecution and won.

The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal later threw out the case against Bunko-Ruys, but found Miazga and Dueck liable.

Dueck didn’t appeal; Miazga did.

Justice Louise Charron, writing for the Supreme Court, said a finding of malice must meet a four-point test and the case against Miazga fell short.

She sympathized with the accused foster parents, but ruled for the prosecutor.

In 2004, the Saskatchewan government paid the plaintiffs in the malicious prosecution suit $2.46 million in a settlement while withholding some additional money pending the outcome of the legal process.

Justice Charron said the sex abuse accusations had to be put in the context of the early 1990s.

At the time, the rules of evidence had changed, eliminating the requirement for corroboration of unsworn evidence of children.

“There was also a prevailing and pervasive doctrine, now debunked but popular among child psychologists at the time, that ‘children don’t lie’ about abuse.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

UPDATED: Donations pour in for family of doctor killed in Red Deer attack

More than $100k raised as of Tuesday at 3:40 p.m.

Colleague says Red Deer physician who died was family man, good doctor

Monday’s attack is a shock to Red Deer health community

Doctor who died Monday in Red Deer knew the attacker: RCMP

Red Deer doctor was attacked in his walk-in clinic Monday

IN-DEPTH: Physicians often face aggressive patients

Almost all say they have been abused by patients or their families at some point

Central Alberta man charged with killing Red Deer doctor to appear in court

RED DEER, Alta. — A man accused of killing a family doctor… Continue reading

Alberta reports 257 new cases of COVID-19

The Alberta government reported 257 new cases of COVID-19 in its latest… Continue reading

Cast your votes for Best of Red Deer

The Advocate’s Best of Red Deer Readers’ Choice Awards are back. Community… Continue reading

Hank Williams Jr., Marty Stuart to join Country Hall of Fame

NASHVILLE — Hank Williams Jr., Marty Stuart and songwriter Dean Dillon are… Continue reading

Broadway musical ‘Diana’ to bypass closed stage for Netflix

NEW YORK — The Broadway musical “Diana” isn’t waiting for theatres to… Continue reading

Stocks open higher, pushing S&P 500 closer to record high

Stocks are opening higher on Wall Street Wednesday, bouncing back from a… Continue reading

Belarusian women rally in solidarity with injured protesters

MINSK, Belarus — Nearly 200 women gathered in Belarus’ capital on Wednesday… Continue reading

Biden, Harris to make unusual campaign debut in virus era

WILMINGTON, Del. — Joe Biden is making his first appearance with newly… Continue reading

PM’s ethical conduct in spotlight as Commons sits but Trudeau won’t be there

OTTAWA — Justin Trudeau’s ethical conduct will be put under an opposition… Continue reading

The latest numbers on COVID-19 in Canada for Aug. 12

The latest numbers of confirmed COVID-19 cases in Canada as of 4… Continue reading

Most Read