Vancouver park board tells smokers to butt out at parks and beaches

VANCOUVER — Vancouver’s park board will vote on a plan Monday that would prohibit smoking in all public parks and beaches, a move critics allege tramples on smokers’ rights and is simply political grandstanding.

VANCOUVER — Vancouver’s park board will vote on a plan Monday that would prohibit smoking in all public parks and beaches, a move critics allege tramples on smokers’ rights and is simply political grandstanding.

The board will review a report prepared by park staff that recommends the ban on medical and environmental grounds.

“I have letters of support from the Heart and Stroke Foundation, I have emails from the Vancouver Coastal Health Authority, I also have emails from leading no-smoking experts from the University of British Columbia,” said Raj Hundal, a park board commissioner.

“There is obviously scientific support toward bringing a ban.”

But Robert Holmes, president of the B.C. Civil Liberties Association, said the ban is virtually unenforceable and violates an individual’s freedom.

“From a civil libertarian perspective, we start off with the basic principle that if what you’re doing is your own free choice, and the only person it can cause harm to is yourself, then what business do other people or the state have to tell you not to do so?”

Smoking is the leading cause of death in B.C., while exposure to second-hand smoke is third.

The report, which was posted on the park board’s website last week, said cigarette butts are also a danger environmentally.

“We use machinery to collect the garbage that we have, the pop cans, the chip bags, but unfortunately the machinery that we utilize can’t pick up those cigarette butts that are embedded in the sand,” Hundal said in an interview.

“What quite often happens is those cigarette butts then wash up on our shores.”

Hundal said the smoking ban has been discussed since last year and an online survey was conducted on the park board’s website in the fall.

Those who clicked onto the website were presented with a pop-up window that asked if they wanted to take part.

Of the 608 responses recorded, 75 per cent favoured the smoking ban at beaches.

Ninety per cent of the survey’s respondents categorized themselves as non-smokers. The report said about 87 per cent of British Columbians don’t smoke.

When asked if an online poll on the park board’s website was the most scientific way to debate policy, Hundal said the response he’s personally received has only supported the findings.

“I’ve received hundreds and hundreds of emails on the issue, and phone calls. It’s safe to say eight out of 10 of the emails I’m getting are in favour of an outright ban,” he said.

But Holmes said while second-hand smoke is clearly a concern in enclosed spaces — Vancouver smokers are banned from lighting up inside public buildings or within six metres of their entrance — it’s more difficult to justify the prohibition in relation to open-air places, such as parks and beaches.

“There’s no evidence that that does create a health risk,” he said.

“I think (the ban is) far more motivated by politicians wanting to engage in some grandstanding and get some attention.”

Dan Romano, a member of Montreal-based Citizens Against Government Encroachment, or C.A.G.E., agreed.

Romano said stopping smokers from lighting up on Vancouver beaches might force them to drive elsewhere, which would have a different environmental effect than the park board’s envisioned.

“Contrary to tobacco smoke, car exhaust is a real health hazard outdoors,” he said in an email.

Hundal said Vancouver is only following in the footsteps of municipalities throughout Canada and the United States that have enacted similar bans in recent years.

One of those is White Rock, located about 40 minutes southeast of Vancouver.

Paul Stanton, the city’s director of planning and development services, said the impact has been mostly positive but there have been some unexpected problems.

“I know some of the restaurants and pubs down on the waterfront will say it’s pushed people out into the street from the patios and that’s created more litter on the sidewalks or more of a nuisance to pedestrians on the sidewalk,” he said.

“But for the most part, my understanding is that it has reduced smoking along the promenade and the pier, and places like that.”

The White Rock bylaw stipulates that any person convicted of smoking in a banned area can be fined between $100 and $2,000.

Hundal wouldn’t disclose how steep a fine Vancouver smokers might face if they ignore the ban, saying only that fines haven’t been ruled out.

“I think it’s safe to say that we believe there will be compliance,” he said when asked why smokers would pay any attention to the ban.

“People adhere to health bylaws.”

But Holmes said he’s skeptical smokers will simply fall in line, which would only further dilute the rule of law.

“If they’re going to put out something that they’re not serious about enforcing, then they really shouldn’t call it a law and make it something that is going to take away from the respect that people generally should have for the law,” he said.

Holmes said it’s ironic the park board will vote on the smoking ban just 18 hours before thousands of marijuana enthusiasts descend on downtown Vancouver to openly toke up to mark April 20.

The park board report says Vancouver Coastal Health and other agencies have offered to cover any initial costs that come with implementing the smoking ban.

The plan calls for an education phase that would commence this summer.

Vancouver’s park board oversees more than 200 parks and nearly 18 kilometres of beaches throughout the city.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Bloc Québécois MP Sebastien Lemire rises during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Friday, March 12, 2021. A Bloc Québécois MP has apologized for taking a screen shot of a Liberal MP who inadvertently appeared nude during virtual proceedings in the House of Commons last week. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Bloc Québécois MP apologizes for taking nude photo of Liberal MP William Amos

‘I have no idea how that photo made its way into the media’

FILE - This Sunday, June 25, 2017, file photo shows TK Holdings Inc. headquarters in Auburn Hills, Mich. A driver in South Carolina is the latest person to be killed by an exploding Takata air bag inflator. Honda says that a faulty driver’s air bag blew apart in a crash involving a 2002 Honda Accord in Lancaster County, South Carolina. The company wouldn’t give details of the Jan. 9, 2021, crash near Charlotte, North Carolina, nor would it identify the person who was killed. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya, File)
South Carolina driver killed by exploding air bag inflator

Drivers can check to see if their vehicles have been recalled

Hospital staff shift the body of a COVID-19 patient on a stretcher to a waiting ambulance at a specialized COVID-19 hospital in Noida, a suburb of New Delhi, India, Wednesday, April 21, 2021. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
Low on beds, oxygen, India adds global high 314K virus cases

Government rushing oxygen tankers to replenish hospital supplies

A traveler wearing a protective mask, due to the COVID-19 outbreak, walks through the nearly empty JetBlue terminal at Logan Airport in Boston, Friday, May 29, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP, Charles Krupa
JetBlue expanding wings with service to Vancouver from New York and Boston

JetBlue will have to compete with Canadian airlines

Green Party MP Elizabeth May arrives on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, Sept. 24, 2020. An emergency parliamentary debate that was supposed to be a forum for cross-party collaboration on better ways to combat the COVID-19 pandemic has devolved into another round of partisan finger-pointing. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Emergency parliamentary debate on pandemic devolves into partisan finger-pointing

‘Let’s work together instead of playing terrible politics in this debate’

Westerner Park’s Exhibition Hall was used as a vaccination clinic on Wednesday. A steady stream of people came to get their COVID-19 shots either by appointment or as walk-ins. Photo by PAUL COWLEY/Advocate staff
No long lineups at walk-in vaccination site in Red Deer

A steady stream of people walked into Westerner Park on Wednesday to… Continue reading

Linda Tomlinson
Gardening: Leave the lawn until the soil is dry

Spring is arriving, Alberta style with warm days, cold days and snow.… Continue reading

Silent protests were held recently in response to Red Deer Public Schools’ decision to reject a Pride Week in favour of a Diversity Week. Some former employees at Red Deer Public are saying the decision is misguided. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Letter: School board silencing Pride Week concern

While it has been our practice to not comment on matters arising… Continue reading

Anderson scores twice as Canadiens down Oilers 4-3

Anderson scores twice as Canadiens down Oilers 4-3

New York Liberty guard Kia Nurse (5) shoots next to Indiana Fever's Kamiah Smalls during the first half of a WNBA basketball game Thursday, Sept. 10, 2020, in Bradenton, Fla. Nurse isn't just one of Canada's finest female basketball players, she's becoming a popular voice of the game as well. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP -Phelan M. Ebenhack
Canadian basketball star Nurse is carving out space in sports broadcasting at just 25

Canadian basketball star Nurse is carving out space in sports broadcasting at just 25

The D.C. Defenders, right, line up against the Seattle Dragons for the opening kickoff of the opening football game of the XFL season, in Washington, Saturday, Feb. 8, 2020. Despite heated social media discussion in Canada, talks between the CFL and XFL haven't addressed what rules could be implemented in a potential partnership. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Stephen Whyno
CFL commissioner Ambrosie says talks with XFL have centred around business, not rules

CFL commissioner Ambrosie says talks with XFL have centred around business, not rules

Most Read