A Court of Queen’s Bench justice has found parts of the province’s Mental Health Act unconstitutional. (File photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Alta Mental Health Act found unconstitutional after man held for nine months

CALGARY — An Alberta judge has found parts of the province’s Mental Health Act unconstitutional after it was used to hold a man against his will for nine months and treat him with psychiatric drugs.

“(The man) suffered multiple breaches of his fundamental rights to life, liberty and security,” wrote Queen’s Bench Justice Kristine Eidsvik in a ruling released Wednesday.

Eidsvik was addressing issues left over from a 2015 ruling, which originally allowed the man, a member of a B-C First Nation, to leave the Calgary hospital in which he had been detained. The issues she ruled on this week involved constitutional matters.

According to Eidsvik’s written decision, the man was originally brought to Calgary Foothills hospital in 2014 with injuries suffered in a hit-and-run. He was treated and released, but during his stay the then-49-year-old lost his apartment and was homeless upon his release.

He wound up living in a home for substance abusers and was subsequently re-admitted to hospital for further treatment for his previous injuries, as well as other ailments. After 20 days, the man improved and asked to be released.

Instead, he was detained under the Mental Health Act. Doctors wrote he was “disoriented, lacks insight into seriousness of his medical condition … (has) unsteady gait.”

“There is no evidence about whether (the man’s) competency was evaluated at this time,” Eidsvik wrote.

Eidsvik was scathing in her description of the man’s treatment.

“There is no evidence that verbal, let alone written notice was given to (the man) or his ‘nearest relative’,” she wrote.

“There is no evidence that (the man) was advised by anyone of his right to obtain legal counsel who could help him challenge his certificates, nor that he was aware one way or another at this time that he could seek help from a Patient Advocate.”

She noted that the man filed affidavits stating that during the time he was held, the hospital had evidence to suggest he was mentally fit.

“The hospital has consistently indicated that I have been able to communicate my needs, my speech has been clear and I have been alert,” she quoted in her ruling.

“They have consistently reported that I am independent and there was ‘no neurological sensory deficit’ observed or reported.”

Meanwhile, treatment was imposed.

“(The man) was treated with psychiatric medications which were not medically required without his consent,” Eidsvik wrote. “(He) failed to have a procedurally fair hearing because he did not know the case he had to meet as a result of the lack of information provided to him, including his reasons for detention and his medical records.”

Eidsvik found six breaches of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms in the Mental Health Act.

She has given the provincial government a year to fix them, or they will be struck down.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Alberta-registered truck elicits a note of kindness in British Columbia

There have been multiple reports online of vandalism to vehicles with Alberta licence plates

Every Albertan eligible for COVID-19 testing

22 new cases confirmed on Friday

Red Deer’s small fitness facilities limbering up for reopening

Al Parada has done everything in his power to stay busy. But… Continue reading

Post-pandemic offices could see some changes

Office designs encouraging more physical distancing could become the norm

WATCH: Central Albertans applaud efforts of Golden Circle staff, volunteers

Central Albertans thanked the Golden Circle Senior Resource Centre’s staff and volunteers… Continue reading

Laurentian Bank Financial Group reports Q2 profit down, cuts quarterly dividend

Laurentian Bank Financial Group reports Q2 profit down, cuts quarterly dividend

POLL: Have you gone out to eat since restaurants were allowed to reopen?

Have you gone out to eat since restaurants were allowed to reopen?… Continue reading

COVID cancelled their wedding plans, so they married on a BC mountaintop

Ceremony was live streamed to friends and family around the world

Red Deer RCMP looking for missing woman

Red Deer RCMP is asking the public to help locate a woman… Continue reading

Crude has best month on record in May as prices surge 88 per cent

Crude has best month on record in May as prices surge 88 per cent

‘It is dire:’ Study finds B.C. logging continues on critical caribou habitat

‘It is dire:’ Study finds B.C. logging continues on critical caribou habitat

Hitching a ride: How risky is carpooling during COVID-19 pandemic?

Hitching a ride: How risky is carpooling during COVID-19 pandemic?

Condition in kids with possible COVID-19 link being studied in Canada

Condition in kids with possible COVID-19 link being studied in Canada

Most Read