Saskatchewan’s Court of Appeal is to make the first ruling on federally imposed carbon tax. (Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Appeal Court to rule on Saskatchewan’s court challenge of federal carbon tax

REGINA — Saskatchewan’s Court of Appeal is to make the first ruling in Canada on whether a federally imposed carbon tax is constitutional.

The Saskatchewan Party government filed a legal challenge of Ottawa’s levy that came into effect April 1 in provinces without a carbon price of their own.

Over a two-day hearing in February, Saskatchewan argued that the question isn’t one of climate change, but rather the division of power.

It argued a carbon tax is unconstitutional because it’s not applied evenly across the country and erodes the sovereignty of provincial jurisdiction.

The federal government said it has the power to put a price on pollution, because greenhouse gas emissions are a national concern.

Premier Scott Moe believes a carbon tax hurts his province economically and has said he plans to appeal if the court upholds the validity of the tax.

“It’s the first word, it’s not necessarily the last word,” Dwight Newman, a University of Saskatchewan law professor, said of Friday’s ruling.

He said the decision will serve as ”persuasive authority” that will be closely examined by other provinces waging their own legal battles against the federal tax.

Manitoba, New Brunswick and Ontario all became subject to a carbon price last month.

Manitoba recently filed papers in Federal Court for its challenge, while Ontario was in court last month to argue its case and is waiting for the outcome.

“If they (Saskatchewan Appeal Court justices) write a persuasive judgment it could impact on how other courts decide the matter,” suggested Newman.

“Of course, both sides could learn from the arguments made in this one — and how they fared — and even make adjustments in the other cases.”

New Alberta Premier Jason Kenney has promised he will scrap the carbon tax the former NDP government brought in and also fight in court if Ottawa tries to impose a national tax on his province.

Newman notes that given the complexity of the case, Saskatchewan’s Appeal Court arrived at a decision “surprisingly quick.”

Sixteen groups — including the attorney generals of British Columbia, Ontario and New Brunswick — intervened in the court case on both sides of the debate.

The federal government’s carbon price starts at a minimum of $20 a tonne and is to rise $10 each year until 2022.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Comments are closed

Just Posted

Frontline rural police will benefit from new support positions say municipal representatives

Province says of 43 new RCMP officers on the job, 18 will provide support and specialized services

Man and woman accused of breaking into rural lease site arrested

Pair arrested after vehicle got stuck in field near Huxley

More camping means more lost dogs, says dog tracker

Lure them back with the scent of food

WE group to stop running federal volunteer program, return funds already paid

OTTAWA — The WE organization won’t manage the federal government’s $900-million program… Continue reading

Provincial watchdog probes often don’t lead to charges against police

An analysis of data from civilian police watchdogs in Canada shows that… Continue reading

‘This year is unlike any other’: Trudeau delivers Canada day address

Sophie Gregoire Trudeau and the Prime Minister release video celebrating the national holiday

It’s play ball for Red Deer Legends and Twilight Baseball League

In a normal year, Blair Hanna and the Red Deer Legends would… Continue reading

Leduc RCMP on scene at plane crash

A float plane crashed in a field near Range Road 232 and Highway 623.

POLL: Should Canada Day be celebrated on the first Monday in July rather than July 1?

Should Canada Day be celebrated on the first Monday in July rather… Continue reading

Three people arrested after failed escape ends in farmer’s field

Cole Joseph Obdam facing numerous charges for incident with police

New city program brings family fun to neighbourhood near you

The City of Red Deer is starting a new program that will… Continue reading

Toronto FC leaves for Florida with concerns over COVID-19 situation that awaits

Toronto FC heads to Florida with some unease given recent positive tests… Continue reading

Michael Dawe: Canada Day festivities have been interfered with before

Because of the restrictions imposed as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic,… Continue reading

8-month wait almost over for resumption of Chinese soccer

An eight-month wait for the new Chinese Super League to start is… Continue reading

Most Read