B.C. court rules American Indigenous man has right to hunt in Canada

NELSON, B.C. — An American Indigenous man’s right to hunt in Canada has been upheld by a B.C. Supreme Court judge because his ancestors traditionally hunted in this country.

Richard Desautel was charged under the Wildlife Act with hunting without a licence and hunting big game while not a resident of B.C. after he shot and killed an elk near Castlegar in 2010.

Desautel, a member of the Lakes Tribe in Washington state, argued in provincial court that he was exercising his constitutional right to hunt for ceremonial purposes.

The Lakes Tribe was described in court as a “successor group” to the Sinixt people, who lived, hunted and gathered in B.C.’s Kootenay region prior to first contact with European settlers.

The provincial court acquitted the man in March, but the Crown appealed to the higher court, arguing that Desautel is not an Aboriginal person of Canada and not entitled to rights under the constitution.

Desautel’s lawyer, Mark Underhill, said the argument goes back to a 1956 declaration by the federal government that said the people of the small First Nation in the Kootenays were extinct.

For the Sinixt, that declaration has “weighed on the collective psyche for generations,” Underhill said.

“What this case has been about from the outset is whether the Sinixt still legally exist and can possess constitutionally protected rights. And that means everything for these folks,” he said in an interview.

In a written decision released Friday, Justice Robert Sewell dismissed the Crown’s appeal saying Desautel’s tribe traditionally lived on both sides of the border and has deep connections to its territory in Canada.

Desautel is an Aboriginal person of Canada and denying his Aboriginal rights would go against the idea of reconciliation, Sewell says in the decision.

“In my view, it would be inconsistent with that objective to deny a right to a group that occupied the land in question in pre-contact times and continued to actively use the territory for some years after the imposition of the international boundary on them,” he says.

Sewell noted the term Aboriginal Peoples of Canada refers to people who occupied an area of what became Canada prior to first contact with Europeans.

Underhill said the decision is a clear statement that where First Nations come from is what counts, not citizenship or international borders.

Sinixt members may have moved to other places, but they remain deeply connected to their traditional territory in southeastern B.C., Underhill said.

“Their identity is so tied to their connection to the land … You can’t be Sinixt if you can’t be on that territory and be connected to it,” he said.

Desautel said in a statement that he is “extremely pleased” with the decision, which he said upholds Indigenous traditions and natural laws.

Underhill said the Sinixt want to pursue reconciliation and that includes further recognition of their existence.

He said that recognition could include a welcome centre in Nelson, B.C., where visitors would learn about Sinixt history.

“What we’re not talking about is thousands of people moving up en masse to shoot every animal in sight or otherwise take over,” he said. “What the Sinixt people want is to enjoy their territory in whatever way that’s possible, but together with the many folks that now reside in the territory.”

Underhill said the province could appeal the decision, and if that happens, the Sinixt are prepared to continue their legal battle all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada, if necessary.

Just Posted

Wildfire that threatened Alberta communities was arson: RCMP, province

EDMONTON — A wildfire that threatened remote communities in north-central Alberta and… Continue reading

Fatal vehicle crash reported near Rimbey

Multiple vehicles involved

Ukraine’s president urges lawmakers to take polygraph test

KYIV, Ukraine — Ukraine’s president on Wednesday urged a group of lawmakers… Continue reading

Rogers Communications reports $593M third-quarter profit, cuts revenue guidance

TORONTO — Rogers Communications Inc. cut its financial guidance as it reported… Continue reading

Mock federal election for students also ends in Liberal minority

If Canada’s elementary and high school students were the ones responsible for… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Tuesday The Small Business Centre at Burman University’s School of Business invites… Continue reading

Opinion: Alberta government salaries are higher than in other provinces

Albertans are paying for inflated government salaries and benefits. With Alberta taxpayers… Continue reading

Military balls were once a highlight of Halloween

Another Halloween is rapidly approaching. It is one of the most popular… Continue reading

Very complex: Nats, Astros share spring site, meet in Series

WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. — Asked how his Washington Nationals figured out… Continue reading

Canada’s Milos Raonic loses to Korea’s Hyeon Chung in return from injury

VIENNA — Milos Raonic’s first tour match in more than two months… Continue reading

Loughlin, 10 other parents charged anew in college scandal

BOSTON — “Full House” actress Lori Loughlin, her fashion designer husband, Mossimo… Continue reading

Louvre exhibit acclaims Da Vinci, 500 years after his death

PARIS — Much about Leonardo Da Vinci remains an enigma: the smile… Continue reading

Trudeau must keep promise to support the West, Kenney and Moe say

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s promise to support the West should be more… Continue reading

Most Read