Citizenship oath to the Queen ’repugnant,’ Ontario Court of Appeal hears

Allowing would-be citizens to opt out of a “repugnant” oath to the Queen would cause no harm to anyone and allow them to retain their sense of integrity, Ontario’s top court heard Tuesday.

TORONTO — Allowing would-be citizens to opt out of a “repugnant” oath to the Queen would cause no harm to anyone and allow them to retain their sense of integrity, Ontario’s top court heard Tuesday.

In calling for the citizenship oath to be struck down, a trio of longtime permanent residents argued the requirement is discriminatory and violates their religious and conscientious beliefs.

“Someone who wants to be a citizen is being forced to say, ’I support the constitutional monarchy,’ their lawyer Peter Rosenthal told the Court of Appeal.

“How repugnant must that be to someone who’s a staunch anti-monarchist?”

At issue is part of the citizenship oath in which newcomers must promise to be “faithful and bear true allegiance to Queen Elizabeth the Second, Queen of Canada, her heirs and successors.”

The trio — Israeli, Irish and Jamaican citizens — say they would be happy to take an oath to Canada, but not the Queen, who they call a relic that represents privilege and lack of equality.

The three justices frequently challenged Rosenthal, who pointed to polls showing most Canadians oppose the monarchy.

The judges noted Canada is a constitutional monarchy in which freedom to express dissenting views is guaranteed.

Rosenthal insisted that forcing newcomers opposed to the monarchy to pledge allegiance to the Queen makes them hypocrites and would constrain them from pursuing anti-monarchist causes.

Justice Peter Lauwers said the appellants seemed to have an “unsophisticated” view of the citizenship oath in maintaining it speaks to their integrity.

“We have different notions of integrity,” Rosenthal said.

“That’s not appropriate,” Lauwers responded.

Native-born Canadians do not have to take any oath, hence the argument that permanent residents are discriminated against on the basis of nationality or origin.

Dror Bar-Natan, 48, a Jew, and Simoney Topey, 47, a Rastafarian, maintain their religion forbids taking an oath to any person.

“Some people might object to taking any oaths at all on religious grounds,” Lauwers said. “Do we do away with all oaths?”

Rosenthal said it would depend on the circumstances.

Michael McAteer, 80, a staunch republican from Ireland, said the oath is unnecessary and would violate his conscience.

Australia, also a constitutional monarchy like Canada, did away with its pledge to the Queen 20 years ago, the court heard.

Speaking for the government, lawyer Kristina Dragaitis argued the Queen is at the apex of the Constitution and symbolizes the rule of law.

“The Queen and the Constitution protects their rights to dissent,” Dragaitis said.

The appellants, she said, are taking a “literal approach” to the oath.

Dragaitis said the government was not conceding the oath infringes on religious beliefs.

Last September, a lower court judge ruled that any charter violation the oath requirement causes can be justified in a democratic society, prompting the appeal.

The government has already made it clear it will take the case to the Supreme Court of Canada if it loses before the Ontario Court of Appeal.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Dentists are skills at injections and can help get more Albertans vaccinated, says the Alberta Dental Association and College. (Pxhere)
Use dentists’ injection skills to get more Albertans vaccinated sooner, says association

Dentists can safely give patient injections and want to support the immunization effort

An aggressive arrest by Red Deer RCMP is facing online scrutiny. No charges have been laid and the incident is still under investigation. (Screenshot of YouTube video)
Second video shows moments leading up to violent arrest in Red Deer

Warning: Story and video contain disturbing details. Charges are pending against two… Continue reading

Rocky Mountain House RCMP are investigating a fatal collision involving a pedestrian on Feb. 27. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Rocky Mountain House RCMP investigate fatal pedestrian collision

Collision occured west of Rocky on Highway 11A

A cross-country skier glides along the banks of the Ottawa River in Ottawa on Thursday, Feb. 25, 2021. Canadians across the country can look forward to a mild spring peppered with the odd winter flashback throughout the first part of the season, according to predictions from one prominent national forecaster. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Mild spring with some wintry blasts predicted for most of Canada: Weather Network

March will be dramatically warmer through the prairies

Bharat Masrani, CEO, TD Bank Group speaks at the Economic Club of Canada in Toronto on Wednesday, November 1, 2017. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Five things to watch for in the Canadian business world in the coming week

Shares in metals and mining companies have rebounded sharply

Red Deer dogs Bunsen and Beaker helped save a missing pet recently. The two dogs have more than 80,000 followers on Twitter. (Contributed photo)
WATCH: Red Deer science dogs help save lost pet

Red Deer science-communicating dogs Bunsen and Beaker helped rescue a missing pet… Continue reading

A ” Justice for Jeff” T-shirt. (Photo submitted)
Rally to be held outside Red Deer courthouse for slain Ponoka man

Sentencing for accused charged with manslaughter with a firearm set for March 4

Team Canada skip Kerri Einarson makes a shot against Team Alberta as second Shannon Birchard, right, and lead Briane Meilleur sweep in the semi-final at the Scotties Tournament of Hearts in Calgary, Alta., Sunday, Feb. 28, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Kerri Einarson wins second straight Canadian women’s curling championship

Einarson and her teammates celebrated Sunday in the silence in an empty arena

Amy Poehler and Tina Fey hosted the Golden Globes on Feb. 28, 2021. (Photo by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS)
With loved ones and pets, Globes winners embrace cozier show

Nicole Kidman and musician-husband Keith Urban got glammed up to sit on their couch

The cast of “Schitt’s Creek” pose for a photo after winning the Award for Best Comedy Series at the Canadian Screen Awards in Toronto on March 31, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young
Schitt’s Creek nabs two Golden Globes for its final season

Catherine O’Hara named best television actress in a musical or comedy

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney speaks during a news conference in Edmonton on Feb. 24, 2020. It’s budget day in the province, and Kenney’s United Conservative government is promising more help in the fight against COVID, but more red ink on the bottom line. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Alberta Premier slams vandalism after slur painted on MLA’s office window

EDMONTON — Alberta Premier Jason Kenney is condemning alleged vandalism at the… Continue reading

Canada Pension Plan Investment Board President and Chief Executive Officer Mark Machin waits to appear at the Standing Committee on Finance on Parliament Hill, in Ottawa on Tuesday, November 1, 2016. Executives who engage in so-called "vaccine tourism" show both an ethical disregard for those less fortunate and a surprising lack of business acumen, experts argue. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Vaccine tourism is both unethical and bad for business, experts say

Executives who engage in so-called “vaccine tourism” show both an ethical disregard… Continue reading

Edmonton Oilers' Jesse Puljujarvi (13) and Toronto Maple Leafs' Justin Holl (3) battle in front as goalie Jack Campbell (36) makes the save during second period NHL action in Edmonton on Saturday, February 27, 2021.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
No Matthews, no problem: Minus NHL goal leader, Maple Leafs blank Oilers 4-0

Leafs 4 Oilers 0 EDMONTON — The Maple Leafs knew even with… Continue reading

Leader of the Government in the House of Commons Pablo Rodriguez rises during Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Friday, Nov. 20, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
Gummed-up bills in House of Commons: harbinger of a federal election?

OTTAWA — All federal party leaders maintain they don’t want an election… Continue reading

Most Read