City lawyers say killing two-for-one jail credit makes for a bad bargain

Proposed legislation to abolish two-for-one credit often given convicted criminals for time spent in pre-trial custody is “draconian” and won’t help solve crime, Red Deer lawyers say.

Patty MacNaughton

Proposed legislation to abolish two-for-one credit often given convicted criminals for time spent in pre-trial custody is “draconian” and won’t help solve crime, Red Deer lawyers say.

The Conservative government hoped to introduce the legislation today in Parliament and has support from the Opposition Liberals and guarded support from the NDP.

“I think the (Prime Minister Stephen) Harper government’s criminal justice reforms are draconian and is setting it back instead of forward,” lawyer Patty MacNaughton said on Thursday.

Michael Scrase, another local lawyer, said the Conservatives are just being “punitive and not coming up with ways to help solve crime.”

Jim Dixon, a veteran Lacombe lawyer, said the government should formulate ideas to help rehabilitate criminals instead of finding ways to further punish them.

The main justification for giving double credit for pre-trial detention has been that it compensates inmates for so-called “dead time” spent in overcrowded detention centres that lack proper rehabilitation programs.

MacNaughton said everyone should remember that people charged with a crime are innocent until proven guilty.

She is currently defending people accused in two high-profile Central Alberta crimes, which include charges of kidnapping, sexual assault and first-degree murder.

Those suspects face a year or more in remand before their cases come to trial.

She said some people spend months in pre-trial custody because they can’t get or afford bail and must wait for trials in a crowded system.

In Red Deer, wait times for trials that will take a day or more have ballooned to eight or nine months, Scrase said. Just a few years ago, the wait was half that.

The Alberta system is chronically short of provincial court judges and sees trials in Calgary and Edmonton set more than a year down the road.

MacNaughton fears some people may plead guilty to avoid long delays in waiting for a trial.

“Often some people will have a legitimate defence to argue at trial,” she added.

Scrase said the Tory proposal is “outrageous.”

He said people should receive credit for time served when they are housed with one or two other people in cells built for one.

MacNaughton said there’s virtually nothing for people in remand centres to do. “There’s no programs to take like in a federal jail, where there’s numerous programs and services.”

Dixon said the government needs to spend more time thinking of ways to rehabilitate inmates and turn them out as productive members of society.

He said the flexibility aspect of parole and the granting of incentives to accused or convicted people is diminished by removing credits.

Critics argue the concept of two-for-one has been abused by some prisoners who try to prolong pre-trial custody to reduce their overall period behind bars.

The Criminal Code doesn’t spell out the ratio but the vast majority of judges accept it as a rule of thumb.

jwilson@bprda.wpengine.com

Just Posted

PHOTO: Rainbow Block Party at Red Deer’s West Park

The Trans and Non-Binary Aid Society hosted a Rainbow Block Party at… Continue reading

Blood donations needed in Central Alberta: Canadian Blood Services

357 donors are needed before Aug. 26 at the Red Deer clinic

WATCH: Annual Family Picnic at Central Spray and Play

Blue Grass Sod Farms Ltd. held the Annual Family Picnic at the… Continue reading

Photos: Smoky conditions in Red Deer

Red Deer and area is experiencing high risk air quality.See related: Red… Continue reading

Committee to decide how millions in Humboldt Broncos donations are split

SASKATOON — Lawyers for the families of some of those who died… Continue reading

Boy, 11, dies after being struck by payloader on southern Alberta ranch

BOW ISLAND, Alta. — A boy has died after an accident on… Continue reading

Liberals look at creating federal holiday to mark legacy of residential schools

OTTAWA — The federal Liberal government wants to establish a holiday to… Continue reading

Thousands of police officers expected at regimental funeral in Fredericton

FREDERICTON — Thousands of police officers and first responders from across the… Continue reading

B.C. declares state of emergency over wildfires

VICTORIA — The British Columbia government has declared a provincial state of… Continue reading

As service refusals make headlines, experts say businesses usually in the wrong

Two Canadian businesses that recently made headlines for refusing customers have learned… Continue reading

Irregular asylum claims increased in July after two months of decline

OTTAWA — The number of irregular border crossers in Canada went up… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month