Conservatives overrule Speaker, force final vote on controversial labour bill

The Senate is wrapping up a reputation-shredding parliamentary session on yet another controversial note —with Conservatives using their majority to overrule their own Speaker and force a final vote on a widely denounced anti-union bill.

OTTAWA — The Senate is wrapping up a reputation-shredding parliamentary session on yet another controversial note —with Conservatives using their majority to overrule their own Speaker and force a final vote on a widely denounced anti-union bill.

The machinations Friday left even some senators acknowledging that the upper chamber seems to have a death wish.

“Every time we break our own rules in order to achieve the wishes of the government of the day, every time we rubber-stamp a bad bill … it feeds directly into the hands of people who criticize the Senate and say that we don’t need a Senate,” said James Cowan, the Liberal Senate leader.

“If we start changing the rules because we can’t win within the rules, then we have chaos, and that’s not good.”

Hugh Segal, a former Conservative senator who led a Senate rebellion against the bill two years ago, said Friday’s “deeply disappointing” move undermines the argument that a second parliamentary chamber is necessary to provide sober second thought to legislation.

“That defence — that on occasion the Senate will stand up and do the right thing by opposing something which is clearly impractical, not workable, unconstitutional and negative in terms of its impact on important things like the role of collective bargaining in a free and open, competitive economy — that defence is now gone,” Segal said in an interview.

“So, whatever the defences were for the continuing existence of the institution and its relevance … those who voted against the Speaker have just cut a huge hole in that flag.”

The Senate has been under siege for the better part of three years, engulfed by an expenses scandal that has resulted in criminal charges against three senators and police investigations into as many as 31 more, including Pamela Wallin and 30 others cited in an explosive audit of expense reports released earlier this month.

The upper chamber has also been rocked by revelations that several senators are facing embarrassing allegations of sexual impropriety.

That the session is coming to an end amid yet more controversy is, at least, consistent.

The latest furor revolves around Bill C-377, a private member’s bill sponsored by Conservative backbencher Russ Hiebert and strongly backed by the Prime Minister’s Office. The bill would require labour unions to publicly disclose details of their spending, including salaries and how much they spend on political activities.

Its detractors include police associations, the privacy commissioner, the Canadian Bar Association and seven provinces who consider it an unconstitutional intrusion into their jurisdiction.

Liberal senators had been filibustering the bill in hopes of outlasting Parliament, but the Conservatives moved Friday to shut down debate and force a vote.

Speaker Leo Housakos — appointed just last month by Harper to be the chamber’s referee — ruled the move out of order. “This would be inconsistent with the basic principles of our rules and practices,” he said.

Seconds later, government Senate leader Claude Carignan appealed to the Senate as a whole to overrule the Speaker’s decision. Carignan won by a vote of 32-17.

Housakos and Sen. Diane Bellemare, who’s been waging a lonely battle against C-377 in the Conservative caucus, were the only Tories to vote in favour of the ruling. Five others abstained: Raynell Andreychuk, deputy Speaker Nicole Eaton, John Wallace, Linda Frum and Vern White.

As a result, the bill will be put to a final vote early next week.

Carignan disputed suggestions that the government side was throwing the procedural rule book out the window.

“This type of motion exists since a long time and it’s not something very exceptional,” he argued. Cowan himself led a successful challenge by Liberals, then in the majority, of a Speaker’s ruling in 2009, Carignan noted.

Cowan said his challenge was on a point of personal privilege, not a case of upending decades-old procedural rules.

Segal said he doesn’t see how Housakos can continue as Speaker when the government Senate leader has demonstrated such a lack of confidence in him. Carignan denied it was a show of non-confidence and Housakos himself seemed to shrug it off.

“I wish they would’ve supported the ruling but it’s their choice,” the Speaker said outside the chamber. “We live in a democracy.”

Segal predicted that the bill will eventually be struck down by the courts as unconstitutional. But in the meantime, he said it could do real political damage to the Conservatives in this fall’s election.

By his estimate, he said, passage of the bill puts the Conservatives at risk of losing 54 ridings in which labour unions wield “huge” influence.

“Why somebody would decide that kind of suicidal, ideologically narrow excess is in the national or the party’s interests or the prime minister’s interests is completely beyond me,” he said.

Just Posted

Patrons practice on a putting green as the Whitestone Bridge looms in the distance at Trump Golf Links at Ferry Point in the Bronx borough of New York on Tuesday, May 4, 2021. Former President Donald Trump has a rich history of fighting back when he’s down and making others pay, and that’s exactly how he intends to deal with New York City over its plans to fire his company from running the city golf course. (AP Photo/John Minchillo)
Dump Trump? Kicking him off NYC golf course may not be easy

Trump Organization has been reeling after the Capitol riots

A photo illustration made December 14, 2012 in Montreal shows a computer in chains. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz
Irish health system says it’s targeted in ransomware attack

Health care systems have been a target before

A woman wearing a mask talks on her phone near an exhibition depicting a rover in Mars in Beijing on Friday, May 14, 2021. China says its Mars probe and accompanying rover are to land on the red planet sometime between early Saturday morning and Wednesday Beijing time. (AP Photo/Ng Han Guan)
China Mars rover to land between Saturday and Wednesday

Only the United States has successfully landed a spacecraft on Mars

Smoke rises following Israeli airstrikes on a building in Gaza City, Thursday, May 13, 2021. Weary Palestinians are somberly marking the end of the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, as Hamas and Israel traded more rockets and airstrikes and Jewish-Arab violence raged across Israel. (AP Photo/Hatem Moussa)
Palestinians flee as Israeli artillery pounds northern Gaza

Israel called up 9,000 reservists as fighting intensifies

Bo’s Bar and Grill owner Brennen Wowk said the hospitality industry is looking for more clarity from the province around what conditions must be met to allow for restaurants reopening. (Advocate file photo)
Frustated restaurant owners want to know government’s reopening plan

Restaurant owners feel they are in lockdown limbo

A used protective face mask is seen discarded on the ground in Vancouver, B.C. in May 2020. (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Medical exception letters required for Albertans who don’t wear masks in public areas

EDMONTON — Alberta has moved to close loopholes people might use as… Continue reading

Team Canada’s head coach Troy Ryan talks with players before the start of the of the Rivalry Series at the Save-On-Foods Memorial Centre in Victoria, B.C., on Monday, February 3, 2020. Ryan of Spryfield, N.S., has been named head coach of Canada’s women’s hockey team for the 2022 Winter Olympics in Beijing.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito
Troy Ryan to coach Canadian women’s hockey team in 2022 Winter Olympics

Ryan was Canada’s assistant coach from 2016 to 2019

FILE- In this April 19, 2021, file photo, people wearing masks as a precaution against the coronavirus wait to test for COVID-19 at a hospital in Hyderabad, India. Misinformation about the coronavirus is surging in India as the death toll from COVID-19 rises. Fueled by anguish, distrust and political polarization, the claims are further compounding India’s crisis. (AP Photo/Mahesh Kumar A, File)
Misinformation surges amid India’s COVID-19 calamity

Distrust of Western vaccines and health care also driving misinformation

FILE - In this Friday March 6, 2020, file photo, Britain’s Prince Harry visits the Silverstone Circuit, in Towcester, England. In an episode of the “Armchair Expert” podcast broadcast Thursday, May 13, 2021, Prince Harry compared his royal experience to being on “The Truman Show” and “living in a zoo.” (Peter Nicholls/Pool Photo via AP, File)
Prince Harry thought about quitting royal life in his 20s

Feared his family would have to deal with the same spotlight that was on his late mother

Mental health: Gossiping, backbiting and forming factions is unhealthy

We all know of dysfunctional organizations, which can be as troublesome as… Continue reading

Family practice physician Christina Tuomi, D.O., (right) gets Homer's first dose of Pfizer's COVID-19 vaccine from Emergency Department nurse Steve Hughes (left) on Thursday, Dec. 17, 2020 at South Peninsula Hospital in Homer, Alaska. Tuomi has been the hospital's medical lead throughout the pandemic. (Photo courtesy Derotha Ferraro/South Peninsula Hospital)
Alberta physicians: Vaccines are our path forward

As the AMA representatives for Alberta’s family physicians, we were immensely relieved… Continue reading

Vancouver Canucks' Nils Hoglander, right, is checked by Calgary Flames goalie Jacob Markstrom during third-period NHL hockey action in Calgary, Thursday, May 13, 2021.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Lindholm, Tkachuk lead Calgary Flames in 4-1 win over Vancouver Canucks

Lindholm, Tkachuk lead Calgary Flames in 4-1 win over Vancouver Canucks

Most Read