Criminal case against top military judge collapses, charges withdrawn

OTTAWA — The criminal case against Canada’s top military judge has collapsed.

The Canadian Armed Forces’ top prosecutor announced Wednesday that he was withdrawing all four charges against chief military judge Col. Mario Dutil in a case that had been seen as a key test of the military-justice system.

Dutil was first charged by military police in January 2018 over allegations of having had an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate and signing a travel claim that contained false information. He was the first person to be charged while serving in that role.

Dutil’s deputy, Lt.-Col. Louis-Vincent d’Auteuil, presided over the court martial at first, but eventually recused himself and refused to name another military judge to take over, saying two of them had conflicts of interest and the third wasn’t bilingual enough.

Col. Bruce MacGregor, the director of military prosecutions, subsequently asked the Federal Court to order one of those judges to preside over the case.

MacGregor insisted on keeping the case within the military-justice system rather than the civilian system, arguing it was the most appropriate venue to weigh the charges against Dutil.

But Federal Court Justice Luc Martineau rejected MacGregor’s request last week, saying that an order to have one of the other judges take the case would do irreparable damage to Dutil’s constitutional right to a fair trial.

Martineau said the tidiest solution would be to name an outside civilian judge to hear the case, but also that the real problem is that the law on military justice never contemplated a scenario where the military’s top judge would face charges himself.

In announcing the withdrawal of the charges against Dutil, MacGregor said he would not appeal Martineau’s decision even as he insisted that all military personnel, “regardless of rank or appointment, are held to the same, highest standard of conduct.

“In this specific case, alleged wrongdoing was reported and investigated by proper authorities, charges were laid and moved forward in accordance with the law,” MacGregor said in a statement.

“However, after conducting a detailed review of the Federal Court’s decision to dismiss my application for judicial review, and carefully considering all circumstances surrounding this case, I believe that it is no longer in the public interest to proceed with this trial.”

Asked why MacGregor didn’t seek to have the Federal Court or the military’s appeal court hear the case, as Martineau recommended, a spokeswoman said that decision would ultimately rest with d’Auteuil “and is not an option open to the director of military prosecutions.”

While the prosecutor’s decision is independent, Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan told The Canadian Press that the government would review the case to determine what improvements need to be made to the military justice system.

“I look forward to getting briefed up from the JAG (judge advocate general) from this decision and we will look towards improving this,” Sajjan said in reference to the military’s top legal officer. ”One thing I can assure you, the military justice system will make the changes necessary.”

Dutil, who has been the chief military judge since 2006, was originally charged with eight counts in relation to allegations he had an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate and knowingly signed a travel claim for $927.60 that contained false information.

Four of the charges were dropped at the start of the court martial in June 2019, where Dutil’s lawyer served d’Auteuil with a subpoena before challenging the presiding judge’s impartiality and asking him to recuse himself.

A publication ban covered details of that portion of the hearing, which included Dutil testifying about his relationship with d’Auteuil, whom he described as a “confidant,” but was later lifted before d’Auteuil recused himself.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published March 11, 2020.

Lee Berthiaume, The Canadian Press

crime

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Central Alberta woman receives North American award for leading Red Deer Regional Health Foundation

Manon Therriault at the Red Deer Regional Health Foundation has always embraced… Continue reading

Families displaced after Red Deer fire Sunday

A structure fire displaced two families in north Red Deer Sunday morning.… Continue reading

End of CERB means uncertainty for some, new system for others

In its place is employment insurance, which the government says the majority of people will go on

The latest numbers on COVID-19 in Canada for Sept. 27

The latest numbers of confirmed COVID-19 cases in Canada as of 4:00… Continue reading

WE Charity controversy prompts examination of group’s overseas footprint

On Sept. 9, WE Charity said it would wind down its Canadian operations

QUIZ: Do you know what’s on TV?

Fall is normally the time when new television shows are released

Nearly 1M who died of COVID-19 also illuminated treatment

The nearly 1 million people around the world who have lost their… Continue reading

Toronto health officer closes 3 restaurants as result of COVID contact tracing

Toronto’s top public health official has ordered the closure of three downtown… Continue reading

Canadian ski resorts wrestle with pandemic-vs.-profit dilemma as COVID-19 persists

CALGARY — Canadian ski resort operators planning for a season that begins… Continue reading

Tenille Townes, Dean Brody and Brett Kissel top nominees at tonight’s CCMA Awards

OTTAWA — Tenille Townes could be lined up for some major wins… Continue reading

Horgan, Wilkinson trade barbs over MSP premiums, health care at campaign stops

TERRACE, B.C. — Health care in the era of COVID-19 took centre… Continue reading

Watchdog to investigate fatal Winnipeg crash that sent two kids to hospital

Winnipeg police say a woman has died and five others — including… Continue reading

The ‘relentless underdog’: Green Leader Sonia Furstenau ready for uphill battle

Green Leader Sonia Furstenau was driving Monday when she turned on the… Continue reading

Mi’kmaq power, inside and beyond Ottawa, stronger than in past fishery battles

HALIFAX — When Jaime Battiste was in his early 20s, cable news… Continue reading

Most Read