Crown, defence present closing arguments in mudslide case

Closing arguments wrapped up on Monday in a court case involving a company accused of causing a mudslide on neighbouring property four years ago.

Closing arguments wrapped up on Monday in a court case involving a company accused of causing a mudslide on neighbouring property four years ago.

Auto Body Services Ltd. and its primary shareholder Harry Veenstra are co-accused. They face seven offences under provincial statutes, including the Water Act and the Alberta Environment Protection and Enhancement Act.

After a week of testimony, the Crown and defence presented their closing arguments before Judge Gordon Yake in Red Deer provincial court.

Crown prosecutor Peter Roginski, of Calgary, concluded that Veenstra should be held responsible for the damage caused by the pumping of water from a lease and onto a hayfield, where it pooled and eventually caused an escarpment to fail, partially covering a grain crop on a lower piece of the neighbouring property.

Veenstra denied knowledge or giving direction for the pumping to occur.

The Crown contends that he knew.

Roginski said in his statement to police that Veenstra was helpful and answered questions very quickly until he was confronted with the accusation that he was responsible for the mudslide. Roginski said his demeanour changed to cautious and reserved.

As well, Veenstra denied knowing he needed a permit, but Roginski pointed out that Veenstra had previously obtained a licence to temporarily pump water.

Roginski also contended that even if Veenstra did not order the water pumped off the site, he did nothing to stop it, was wilfully blind to the water being pumped and should still be held responsible for the charges he faces.

Defence counsel pointed to the fact that Veenstra and his company were only leasing the land to Orion, an oilfield rental service. Orion leased 20 acres from Veenstra for oilfield equipment storage, then in turn rented out the land to Apache Oilfield Services.

The agreement started in late spring/early summer of 2010. Equipment operator Brad Larsen was asked by Veenstra and Orion, his employer, to move some topsoil to create a berm at the north and east sides of the property, and create a retention pond in the northeast corner and a drainage ditch along the south side.

By July, Larsen talked with his employer about the heavy rains that filled the site, reaching depths of two to three metres in some places. Court heard that Larsen was told to talk with Veenstra about the water problem. Testimony claimed that Veenstra told Larsen to pump the water eastward into a ditch on the far side of a road that runs along the eastern edge of the property.

Water was pumped from the property from July 15 to 21, 2010. Larsen saw it pooling in the neighbouring field but thought it would dissipate.

No permit was obtained to pump the water.

Defence counsel Sean Moring contended that Veenstra could not be held responsible as he leased out the land and had nothing to do with Larsen’s interaction with his employer. As well, it would have been hard for Veenstra to have known if a licence to pump the water was obtained as all he told Larsen was where to pump it to.

Moring and Roginski also differed on the definition of water and how it fits within the Alberta Environmental Protection and Enhancement Act. The charges against Veenstra accuse him of allowing the release of a substance and Roginski contends that the act is deliberately broad so it could include water as a substance. Moring argued the goal of the act was to protect the environment and that water was a naturally occurring part of the environment and the terminology of substance was meant to include pollutants and not water.

The trial was originally scheduled to run for three weeks. However, Crown testimony wrapped up in a week and Moring called no witnesses, relying on his cross-examination of Crown witnesses and his closing statement.

Yake reserved his decision to July 25.

Just Posted

Red Deer city council aims to force larger non-profits to become more accountable

New bylaw defines which not-for-profits must pay for a business licence

Red Deer city council will seek public input on portable signage March 4

Council gave initial approval to retaining 100-metre separation distance

Smaller, more affordable, lots wanted in Red Deer’s Evergreen neighbourhood

Council approves first reading of requested lot-size changes

RDC’s new name to be unveiled in February

The next big milestone for Red Deer College is a new name,… Continue reading

Lacombe considering licensing cats

Council is expected to take a look at cat potential licensing regulations next month

2-for-1: Total lunar eclipse comes with supermoon bonus

On Sunday night, the moon, Earth and sun lined up to create the eclipse, which was visible throughout North and South America

Opinion: Faith in immigration must be preserved

Canada has a deserved reputation for extending its arms to newcomers, but… Continue reading

Olympian Adam van Koeverden wins federal Liberal nomination in Ontario riding

MILTON, Ont. — Former Olympic flag-bearer Adam van Koeverden will be carrying… Continue reading

World champion Osmond says it’s “really nice” not to know what future holds

SAINT JOHN, N.B. — Kaetlyn Osmond has a world title, Olympic medals… Continue reading

World economy forecast to slow in 2019 amid trade tensions

For Canada, the IMF’s estimate for growth in 2019 was 1.9 per cent, down from expected global growth of 3.5 per cent

Timberlake pops in on patients at Texas children’s hospital

DALLAS — Justin Timberlake has pulled some sunshine from his pocket for… Continue reading

UK police speak to Prince Philip about not wearing seatbelt

LONDON — British police have spoken with Prince Philip after the husband… Continue reading

‘Gotti’ leads Razzie nominations, Trump up for worst actor

The nominations were announced on Monday, Jan. 21 with some movies earning up to six nominations

Curtain rising Sunday night on total lunar eclipse

CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — The celestial curtain will be rising soon on… Continue reading

Most Read