File photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS Joshua Boyle, 35, has pleaded not guilty in Ontario court to offences against estranged spouse Caitlan Coleman, including assault, sexual assault and unlawful confinement.

Crown touts testimony depicting Joshua Boyle’s ‘pattern of behaviour’

OTTAWA — A Crown prosecutor says testimony about former hostage Joshua Boyle’s controlling, abusive nature should be admitted into evidence at his assault trial because it depicts a relevant pattern of behaviour.

Boyle, 35, has pleaded not guilty in Ontario court to offences against estranged spouse Caitlan Coleman, including assault, sexual assault and unlawful confinement.

The offences are alleged to have occurred in Ottawa in late 2017 after the couple returned to Canada following five years as captives of extremists who seized them in Afghanistan during an ill-fated backpacking trip.

However, Crown prosecutor Meaghan Cunningham told Judge Peter Doody, who is hearing the case without a jury, that the criminal proceedings must take into account the complete context of the couple’s relationship.

“The point of this evidence is it shows a pattern of behaviour,” Cunningham said Monday.

Boyle’s lawyer, Lawrence Greenspon, argued such evidence should not be allowed, saying it was insufficient to contend his client was generally inclined to act abusively toward Coleman.

Coleman has testified that her husband regularly punished her with spankings for arguing with him or disobeying his wishes.

She recounted how the two met online when she was 16 and began an on-and-off relationship before marrying in 2011 in Costa Rica and travelling the following year to central Asia.

She said that in the early days of their tumultuous courtship, her future spouse would often belittle her. Over time, he told her how to behave and what to wear. Emotional and verbal abuse later became punches and slaps to the face, Coleman said.

Witnesses at the trial have described Boyle as angry and domineering in the days following his release from captivity.

Janice Unger, a Global Affairs Canada official who accompanied them on the plane back to Canada, told the court that at one point during the flight Boyle abruptly demanded that she and a colleague return to their seats.

Coleman’s sister, JoAnn Rotenberry, visited the couple shortly after their return and recalled that Boyle always seemed upset and frustrated, and would speak to Caitlan in a demeaning way.

Coleman’s mother Lynda testified she felt her daughter was afraid of upsetting Boyle and catered to him and the children while he did nothing to help.

Greenspon suggested the Crown would need to do more than demonstrate Boyle had a “bad attitude” in Ottawa for the testimony to become part of the evidentiary record.

Just Posted

Red Deer Reads winning title revealed

The winning title for this year’s Red Deer Reads describes a doctor’s… Continue reading

Search on Sylvan Lake continues for young Edmontonian who is presumed drowned

Palwinder Singh disappeared underwater after his inflatable flipped

Central Alberta farm family has been community-building since 1882

Kemp family of Innisfail receives 2019 Golden Furrow Award

Search on for missing man after tubing fun takes tragic turn on Sylvan lake

SYLVAN LAKE, Alta. — A young man is missing and presumed drowned… Continue reading

WATCH: Trailer stolen from Red Deer deli

A Red Deer business has contacted police after a trailer was stolen… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Thursday The Red Deer and District Garden Club hosts its annual Flower… Continue reading

Best in the West: Eskimos host Bombers in shocase of top CFL teams

EDMONTON — From the moment they broke training camp facing a season… Continue reading

Canadians Auger-Aliassime, Shapovalov to meet again in U.S. Open first round

Felix Auger-Aliassime didn’t have much time to savour his first career appearance… Continue reading

Thomas loses cushion, shares lead in Tour Championship

ATLANTA — Xander Schauffele was six shots behind before he ever hit… Continue reading

China’s rust belt looks abroad as growth slows, tariffs bite

YINGKOU, China — From Thailand to Kenya, trains run on tracks from… Continue reading

Estate planning for Fido: How to make sure pets live the good life if you go

If four-year-old Gracie’s parents die, a trusted family member receives $10,000 from… Continue reading

CIBC hikes dividend as it reports third-quarter profit rise, beating estimates

TORONTO — The Canadian Imperial Bank Of Commerce hiked its dividend and… Continue reading

Fans choose sides in the ‘Chicken Sandwich War’ of our time

NEW YORK — A nation already polarized finds itself divided once again,… Continue reading

Most Read