Crown witness suggests Magnotta’s behaviour doesn’t reflect a mental disorder

A Crown psychiatrist says there were few signs Luka Rocco Magnotta was suffering from mental illness following Jun Lin's slaying but many more to suggest he could be faking or exaggerating his symptoms.

MONTREAL — A Crown psychiatrist says there were few signs Luka Rocco Magnotta was suffering from mental illness following Jun Lin’s slaying but many more to suggest he could be faking or exaggerating his symptoms.

There are numerous inconsistencies between Magnotta’s actions and his supposed illness, Dr. Gilles Chamberland testified at the accused’s murder trial Monday.

Defence psychiatrists have said they believe Magnotta was psychotic, had been untreated for schizophrenia for at least two years and was unable to tell right from wrong the night Lin was killed in May 2012.

But Chamberland testified that, in his opinion, Magnotta’s actions and version of events don’t support that theory.

Magnotta’s behaviour isn’t compatible with someone suffering from paranoid delusion, he said.

Magnotta presented himself following the slaying as someone who was mentally ill and suffering from psychotic symptoms both before and after the killing.

He gave a different version of the death to each of the two defence psychiatrists who assessed him. He also couldn’t remember many of the details.

Chamberland told the jury that people who are paranoid are often very alert, vigilant and have an excellent memory.

The surveillance video at his apartment that captures Magnotta in the days following Lin’s slaying and dismemberment doesn’t reveal any outward signs consistent with mental illness, Chamberland said.

Magnotta, 32, is charged with first-degree murder; criminally harassing Prime Minister Stephen Harper and other members of Parliament; mailing obscene and indecent material; committing an indignity to a body; and publishing obscene materials.

He has admitted to committing the acts but has pleaded not guilty by way of mental disorder.

The Crown has disputed the schizophrenia diagnosis and says Magnotta was faking his symptoms.

He gave several examples, including Magnotta filtering information and voluntarily withholding information from psychiatrists and doctors.

Chamberland said Magnotta told one psychiatrist he was fearful of government operatives outside his building and that Lin was one too. Despite the alleged fear, Magnotta is seen coming and going in the hours after Lin’s death.

In another example, Chamberland noted Magnotta kept Lin’s baseball cap despite his paranoia and after having disposed of most of his own possessions.

“It could also serve as a souvenir of a moment that marked their lives, which we find in certain people who commit these types of crimes and want to keep a memory,” he said.

While a mental illness like schizophrenia doesn’t explain Magnotta’s behaviour, the Crown psychiatrist said personality disorders do.

Chamberland said Magnotta tends to exhibit elements of borderline, histrionic and narcissistic personality disorders and those conditions are a more reasonable explanation than schizophrenia for his behaviour.

Other psychiatrists all found traits of a personality disorder, he noted.

The trial is in its 10th week and continues Tuesday.

Just Posted

Driver who backed into Red Deer pizzeria sentenced

David Andrew Amstutz sentenced for failing to remain at the crash scene

Shaw getting ready to raise prices for its main residential service, CEO says

CALGARY — Residential customers of Shaw Communications Inc. will likely see a… Continue reading

Inflation accelerates as higher airfares, vegetable prices offset cheaper gas

OTTAWA — Canada’s annual inflation rate accelerated to two per cent last… Continue reading

Alberta couple wants cash and charges dropped in meningitis death of their son

CALGARY — An Alberta couple facing a second trial in the meningitis… Continue reading

Moose Jaw wants to challenge Norway for tallest moose statue title

MOOSE JAW, Sask. — The City of Moose Jaw, Sask., is on… Continue reading

Fashion Fridays: Inspirational gym outfits

Kim XO, helps to keep you looking good on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

Canadian tattoo artist inks Toronto skyline on Blue Jays pitcher Stroman

Marcus Stroman found a way to show his appreciation for Toronto when… Continue reading

Team World sweeps opening day against Team North America at Continental Cup

LAS VEGAS — Team North America has some serious ground to make… Continue reading

SXSW to screen ‘Run This Town,’ which includes Rob Ford character

TORONTO — A drama that features a portrayal of the late Toronto… Continue reading

Fans buy ‘Little House on the Prairie’ star’s memorabilia

GENOA TOWNSHIP, Mich. — More than 200 items belonging to “Little House… Continue reading

Paying down debt should be priority for low income workers, say experts

TORONTO — Investment planning can often be seen as a luxury for… Continue reading

Russian fighter jets collide over Sea of Japan crews eject

One plane crashed after its crew ejected safely, the other crew also ejected but they have not been found

Judge to deliver verdict in British sailor’s gang rape case

The alleged gang rape took place at a Halifax-area military base in 2015

B.C. minister fears money laundering involves billions of dollars, cites reports

The government had estimated that it was a $200-million a year operation, instead estimates now peg the problem at $1 billion annually

Most Read