Defence challenges psychiatrist’s claims at Lindsay trial

The Crown’s key expert witness’ conclusion is Mark Damien Lindsay should be held criminally responsible for the murder of an Edmonton mother of three went under the microscope.

The Crown’s key expert witness’ conclusion is Mark Damien Lindsay should be held criminally responsible for the murder of an Edmonton mother of three went under the microscope.

Dr. Peter Todd’s conclusion came under heavy scrutiny by defence counsel Kent Tesky. After two days of Crown Prosecutor Bina Border questioning Rodd, Teskey got his crack at cross examination.

Lindsay, 29, is accused of murdering Dana Turner, 31, days after being released from jail for an assault he committed on her. Lindsay stabbed her in the face and served 50 days in custody.

Teskey questioned why Rodd only interviewed Lindsay once. Rodd said he was asked for his opinion by another psychiatrist who was examining Lindsay. The second psychiatrist, Dr. Vijay Singh, was not called to testify. However, his and Rodd’s conclusions aligned with each other.

Similar to how Border approached her cross examination of defence expert witnesses, Teskey questioned Rodd and what value and weight he gave certain reports of Lindsay’s behaviour. Teskey pointed to Lindsay’s parents testimony during the trial and early psychiatric reports that identified some of the paranoid symptoms Lindsay presented.

Rodd said in his his examination of Lindsay he tried to not restrict himself to reaching his conclusion by picking from isolated data points, but instead looked towards context and over-arching themes.

Lindsay is accused of killing Turner in August 2011. He has admitted to stabbing her in the eyes with a pencil, strangling her and then running over her with a car.

Lindsay said he believed Turner was a member of a group of serial killers called Healers. The group had sent Turner to kill him specifically.

Lindsay’s criminal responsibility is the main trial issue.

Defence expert testimony has said Lindsay’s schizophrenia enabled the psychosis that led to Lindsay killing Turner.

His paranoid delusions around Turner and the Healers are evidence of that.

Crown expert testimony said Lindsay’s actions after the murder were calculated, which showed an awareness of the wrongfulness of the act. Lindsay bought a shovel and other items in an attempt to hide Turner’s body — he ended up leaving her body in a ditch on an oil lease road west of Innisfail. Lindsay also got his resume and welding book before leaving Edmonton for an extended period of time. Rodd believes Lindsay appreciated the consequences of his actions and can be held criminally responsible.

Trial now takes a short adjournment to Thursday when closing argumenta will be held.

mcrawford@bprda.wpengine.com

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Red Deer city council to vote on mandatory face mask bylaw

The City of Red Deer’s administration is recommending a mandatory face mask… Continue reading

76 new cases of COVID-19 reported Thursday

Active cases at 1,036, 10,713 recovered cases

Lethbridge supervised drug site to shut down at the end of month

LETHBRIDGE — The operator of one of the busiest supervised drug consumption… Continue reading

Red Deer recreation facilities much less busy than previous summers

While Red Deer recreation facilities are getting busier, there still isn’t nearly… Continue reading

Rocky Mountain House residents slam mandatory mask wearing

Town council has taken no position on mandatory masking but says it’s worth discussing

Cast your votes for Best of Red Deer

The Advocate’s Best of Red Deer Readers’ Choice Awards are back. Community… Continue reading

Michael Dawe: Indecision almost prevented creation of downtown oasis

One of the crown jewels of Red Deer is City Hall Park,… Continue reading

Chicken, eggs both go first as feds roll out COVID-19 food surplus program

Chicken, eggs both go first as feds roll out COVID-19 food surplus program

Budget watchdog says COVID-19 wage subsidy might cost less than predicted

Budget watchdog says COVID-19 wage subsidy might cost less than predicted

Bolivia’s political crisis threatens hospitals and patients

Bolivia’s political crisis threatens hospitals and patients

California officer rescues disabled man from oncoming train

California officer rescues disabled man from oncoming train

Pandemic motivating more parents to get their kids the flu shot, UBC study finds

Pandemic motivating more parents to get their kids the flu shot, UBC study finds

Face masks for teachers can impact learning on young children, experts say

Face masks for teachers can impact learning on young children, experts say

Most Read