Documents hint at Liberal plans to add social financing to more federal spending

OTTAWA — The Liberals are considering adding new funding streams to existing programs in a bid to make more federal spending friendly to social finance ideas that link the charitable and private sectors to help pay for and deliver services.

What makes the approach attractive to governments is that it shifts the financial risk from taxpayers to investors who give financial backing to social service providers to test new and successful ways of delivering programs.

Governments are only obliged to cover investors’ costs and profits if the programs work.

Documents obtained by The Canadian Press under the Access to Information Act show the government envisions adding social funding streams to a variety of programs in the future, including the Impact Canada Fund set up in the 2017 budget that already finances new ideas for clean technology and municipal infrastructure.

Social Development Minister Jean-Yves Duclos said the concepts underpinning social finance and social innovation — helping vulnerable populations, crafting community-specific plans, creating partnerships and addressing multiple issues at once — can be found in various forms in the ongoing talks with provinces and territories on early learning and child care, deliberations on a national poverty reduction strategy and the national housing strategy.

“It’s all part of a broad, social innovation system that … looks both similar and different depending on the angle through which you look at the system itself,” he said in an interview this week after addressing a social housing conference in the national capital.

Duclos is overseeing work on a federal strategy to be completed this year about how to unlock what the Liberals believe are billions in private cash that could finance programs and services and test new ways to deliver them.

Some of the housing providers at the conference saw an opportunity to get in on the social finance game, believing that it could open a door to a whole new world of funding. But there remains skepticism that social financing, and particularly social impact bonds, can be a panacea for cash-strapped governments trying to solve social ills.

Social impact bonds see service providers partner with private or philanthropic backers who cover the up-front costs and the government pays a return on the investment only if certain outcomes are met. In one such arrangement involving the Chicago education system, returns are set at eight per cent.

A Canadian documentary to be released next month, called “The Invisible Heart,” takes a deep look at social impact bonds and raises multiple questions for governments, including the idea of the government paying profits to investors.

As part of the film, billionaire J.B. Prtizker, who is helping funding the Chicago bond, said that his riskiest capital will create an eight per cent return.

“I’ve heard the … idea that why are we letting investors make money off of our children? Well, that’s silly. The reality is the more than 2,000 children that will be served by the Chicago social impact bond would not otherwise be served,” he says in the film, shot before his current bid for the Illinois governorship.

Filmmaker Nadine Pequeneza said she believed that social impact bonds could help with prevention of social issues, but there appears to be a sustainability issue with the financing tool, given the lawyers, accountants and evaluators who add to the cost.

“Even if you are able to bring in all of those additional funding for social services, private funding, ultimately the government is repaying that investment plus the additional transaction costs,” said Pequeneza, who spent three years on the project and spoke with domestic and international experts, investors and social service providers.

“I don’t really understand how it’s possible to use this (social impact bond) model to scale up these programs.”

Screenings begin next month and at each location there will be panels with experts and politicians who normally only talk about social impact bonds at conferences with investors.

“The discussion needs to be expanded beyond these impact investment conferences. I’ve been to a fair number of those now and it’s very limited in terms of who is in the room,” Pequeneza said.

Just Posted

WATCH: Terry Loewen named Red Deer’s Citizen of Year

Gian Carlo Estoesta named Red Deer’s Young Citizen of the Year

Red Deer councillor says addicts have accepted death as an outcome of lifestyle

Buck Buchanan says “no one wants that to happen”

Tending the fields like a pioneer near Spruce View

Weekend of horse-drawn plowing, seeding and more at Double Tree Village Museum

Red Deer County tweaks animal control bylaw

Some residents complained earlier version of animal bylaw was too restrictive

Local athletes shine on the track at CASAA Zone Track and Field Championships

Lindsay Thurber Raiders athlete Hayley Lalor was the winner in the senior girls individual aggregate

Ovechkin, Holtsby shine in Game 7, Caps beat Lightning

Capitals 4 Lightning 0 ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — Alex Ovechkin scored early… Continue reading

B.C.’s Horgan defends fight to both retain and restrict Alberta oil imports

YELLOWKNIFE — B.C. Premier John Horgan says he is fighting to both… Continue reading

Media are not an arm of the police, Vice lawyer tells Supreme Court hearing

OTTAWA — Journalists are not an investigative arm of the police, a… Continue reading

PHOTOS: Red Deer kids learning baseball skills

Red Deer Minor Baseball Rally Cap players practice in Bower Wednesday

Lacombe receives award for contribution to recreation

City received the William Matcalfe Award for major renovations to the Gary Moe Auto Group Sportsplex

‘Knees-together’ judge can practise law again

Former judge Robin Camp allowed to practise law again: Law Society of Alberta

Photo: Roundabout action on 67th Street

Construction season is in full force

Alberta demands all-party support for pipeline at western premiers meeting

Leaders from western Canadian provinces, territories holding a morning meeting today in Yellowknife

Most Read

Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month