Drug evidence tossed over police delay in allowing accused access to lawyer

TORONTO — Another prosecution case of a person caught with hard drugs has fallen apart because police refused him timely access to a lawyer.

In his decision, Ontario court Judge Patrice Band said admitting the drug evidence in the case of a man identified in court records only as L.D. would bring the system of justice into disrepute.

“The police violated L.D.’s right to counsel by deliberately delaying it upon arrest, and then failing to facilitate its implementation for a period totalling approximately 20 hours,” Band wrote in his decision.

“Despite the fact that the evidence is essential to the Crown’s case, the breach was so serious as to lead to the conclusion that the admission of the evidence in these proceedings would bring the administration of justice into disrepute.”

In May 2018, a five-person Toronto drug-squad team searched a car belonging to the accused as well as two homes. The searches turned up more than a kilogram of cocaine and other drugs as well as $7,500 in cash.

Det. Const. Rajan Bhogal arrested L.D., 41, and another officer advised him of his right to a lawyer. However, according to legal submissions, Bhogal told a uniformed officer to take L.D. to the police station, but to hold off on letting him call counsel. Ultimately, it would be the next day before he was able to speak to a lawyer.

L.D. argued for the exclusion of the drugs and cash as evidence on the basis police infringed his constitutional rights. The prosecution maintained that Bhogal’s decision to delay access to counsel was justified by safety concerns and preservation of evidence.

Bhogal, a 12-year member of police force at that point, testified it was sometimes important to stop a suspect from calling a lawyer to avoid others being tipped off to an impending raid. He said he decided to suspend L.D.’s rights during the arrest until it was “safe to do so” in light of the searches at the various locations.

Bhogal conceded L.D. had no known involvement with violence, gangs or firearms, but said the accused could have had partners.

Testifying in his own defence, L.D. said he asked for a lawyer on arrest and again on arrival at the police station. Despite some attempts by Bhogal to reach a lawyer, L.D. only got to speak to one the following day at bail court.

Suspending a person’s right to counsel is an “exceptional step” that should only occur in cases where urgent and dangerous circumstances arise, and then only for as long as necessary, Band said. Such circumstances didn’t exist in this case, he said. The judge also faulted Bhogal for failing to take proper notes about the lawyer issue.

While the drug evidence would be reliable, Band said the material could not be admitted even though it “gutted” the prosecution’s otherwise solid case.

“In sum, D. C. Bhogal let L.D. and his rights fall through the cracks,” Band concluded. “The charter-infringing conduct in this case was very serious and strongly favours exclusion.”

In a similar case last week, Ontario’s top court quashed a drug conviction for a man in Oshawa, Ont., because police denied him his right to a lawyer for more than three hours.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published on Nov. 8, 2019.

Colin Perkel, The Canadian Press

Just Posted

Grain shippers worried about strike as feds urge CN and union to continue talks

MONTREAL — Grain shippers are concerned about the impact of a strike… Continue reading

A lesson in excellence and success

Mary Kemmis, president of the Prairie Division of Black Press Media, and… Continue reading

More flurries expected Tuesday evening in Red Deer

It’s snowing in Red Deer. Snow began earlier this morning and is… Continue reading

Trans Mountain received $320M in government subsidies in first half 2019: report

VANCOUVER — The Trans Mountain pipeline received $320 million in subsidies from… Continue reading

EasyJet says it will operate net-zero carbon flights

LONDON — European budget airline easyJet says it will become the first… Continue reading

Central Albertans help families during holidays with Christmas Wish Breakfast

It takes a community to help a community. And Sunday morning at… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Nov. 19 The Mountview Sunnybrook Community Association will hold its AGM at… Continue reading

Opinion: Climbing cost of drinking water a drain on low-income earners

Environmentalists and water economists have long argued Canadian households have not conserved… Continue reading

U.S. support for Israeli settlements is no surprise

As British newspaper magnate Viscount Northcliffe said: “When a dog bites a… Continue reading

Opinion: The buck stops with Red Deer city council

Red Deer city council has taken measures to distance itself from decisions… Continue reading

Denis Shapovalov, Vasek Pospisil give Canada Davis Cup win over favoured Italy

MADRID — Denis Shapovalov and Vasek Pospisil kept rolling on Monday, notching… Continue reading

Canadian women’s star Hayley Wickenheiser inducted into Hockey Hall of Fame

TORONTO — Hayley Wickenheiser hasn’t had a lot of time to reflect.… Continue reading

Federal Court orders Canada’s ISPs to block piracy website for first time

TORONTO — A Federal Court is ordering Canada’s internet service providers to… Continue reading

Don’t judge ‘Cats’ film by its trailer, says Canadian music producer Greg Wells

TORONTO — Greg Wells won a Grammy for “The Greatest Showman” soundtrack,… Continue reading

Most Read