Duffy’s former lawyer recommended calling repayment deal a ’contract’

A former lawyer for Mike Duffy advised him to defend the secret repayment of his contested expenses as a “contract” — a characterization that could bolster the Crown’s arguments about the senator’s alleged role in the deal.

OTTAWA — A former lawyer for Mike Duffy advised him to defend the secret repayment of his contested expenses as a “contract” — a characterization that could bolster the Crown’s arguments about the senator’s alleged role in the deal.

New emails submitted as evidence Monday in Duffy’s fraud, breach of trust and bribery trial reveal some of the scrambling that occurred in May 2014 when details of the $90,000 payment broke in the media.

Harper’s former chief of staff Nigel Wright had repaid Duffy’s expenses two months earlier, while Duffy and others inside the Prime Minister’s Office held to the line that Duffy had repaid the bills.

Duffy quickly consulted with the law firm Nelligan O’Brien Payne to find out how to handle any ensuing scrutiny by the Senate ethics officer.

Lawyer Christopher Rootham told him that because firm colleague Janice Payne had helped to strike a repayment deal with Wright, the repayment should be described as a “contract.”

If it had been a gift, that would have been more problematic, Rootham said in an email.

“In my opinion, a good argument could be made that this was not a ’gift’ at all, but instead income received from a contract (negotiated by Janice),” he wrote. “The payment therefore falls under the annual ’confidential disclosure statement’ that you must make under… 1/8the Senate ethics and conflict of interest 3/8 code.”

Duffy sent a letter to Senate ethics officer Lyse Ricard a few hours later, repeating the notion of a contract with Wright and asking her to review the matter.

This characterization of the payment as a contract is potentially problematic for Duffy now, as the Crown tries to paint him as the instigator or equal partner in a scheme to have the $90,000 in dubious expense claims paid back from someone else’s pocket.

Rootham goes on to tell Duffy that the “more serious risk” is if someone alleges he breached the Parliament of Canada Act — something that some experts did bring up at the time, but which never transpired.

The Act prohibits any member of the Senate from receiving money in relation to any “controversy,” or any person from offering the money to a senator.

“If this allegation is made, IF YOU SPEAK AT ALL you will deny that you received compensation in respect of a controversy before the Senate that any arrangement that was made was bona fide and legal,” the lawyer writes.

Duffy’s defence in this trial has been that he was strong-armed into accepting a deal in which he would admit error in filing his Senate expenses, even though he felt strongly that he had done nothing wrong.

Chris Woodcock, the former director of issues management inside the PMO, testified Monday about discussions he had with Duffy around public statements the senator make about the repayment.

Woodcock was a sort of firefighter inside the PMO, trying to extinguish potentially damaging stories as they emerged in the media.

The Crown took him through email discussions in which Duffy himself appeared to actively collaborate on media strategy.

“It was collegial, co-operative,” Woodcock said of one conversation with Duffy in February 2013 about a media statement.

“Did you pressure him on the call to accept a certain statement?” asked Crown prosecutor Jason Neubauer.

“None whatsoever,” Woodcock responded.

Woodcock also testified that he was unaware that Wright had repaid Duffy’s expenses, despite being copied on a direct email in which Wright tells him of his intention.

“FYI only. No such discussions with Wallin. There was discussion re Duffy, but decided no CPC funds to be used,” Wright wrote.

“For you only: I am personally covering Duffy’s $90K.”

Wright also listed Woodcock as one of the people he told about the payment, in testimony earlier this month.

Woodcock said he didn’t read that part of the email, and found out after the story broke on CTV News.

That position bears some similarity to that of Harper’s current chief of staff, Ray Novak, who said through a spokesman that he had not read an email from Wright in which Wright tells him he is sending his cheque.

Harper has placed the blame for the Duffy scandal squarely on the shoulders of Wright and the senator, saying subordinates shouldn’t be the ones held accountable.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

This Dec. 2, 2020, file photo provided by Johnson & Johnson shows vials of the COVID-19 vaccine in the United States. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Johnson & Johnson via AP
What you need to know about Johnson & Johnson’s approved single-dose vaccine

Canada added a single-dose COVID-19 vaccine to its pandemic-fighting arsenal on Friday,… Continue reading

FILE - This March 20, 2018, file photo shows the YouTube app on an iPad in Baltimore. YouTube on Friday, March 5, 2021, said it has removed five channels run by Myanmar’s military for violating its community guidelines and terms of service. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky, File)
YouTube cancels Myanmar military-run channels, pulls videos

YouTube monitoring the situation for any content that might violate rules

Statistics Canada’s offices in Ottawa are shown on Friday, March 8, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
Canada posts $1.4B trade surplus for January, first surplus since May 2019

Total imports increased in January to $49.8 billion

The wreckage of a fatal crash involving a semi-truck and the Humboldt Broncos junior hockey team bus near Tisdale, Sask., is seen on Saturday, April, 7, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
Court to hear arguments on delay in Broncos lawsuit for proposed class action

11 lawsuits have been filed by victims and their families

Bryson, six, and Mara, eight, play with puppies from Dogs With Wings Saturday. (Photo by Sean McIntosh/Advocate staff)
WATCH: Dogs With Wings introduces Red Deer program

A program that trains puppies to be certified service, autism, facility and… Continue reading

Team Canada third John Morris follows as second Carter Rycroft (right) and lead Nolan Thiessen (left) sweep his rock during round robin competition against Team Newfoundland and Labrador at the Brier curling championship, Wednesday, March 9, 2016 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Champions at The Brier list

Brier champions since the inception of the Canadian men’s curling championship in… Continue reading

FILE - This Jan. 22, 2013 file photo shows Martin Bashir at the EA SimCity Learn. Build. Create. Inauguration After-Party, in Washington. British police said Thursday March 4, 2021, that they will not launch a criminal investigation into the journalist Martin Bashir over his 1995 interview with the late Princess Diana. (Photo by Nick Wass/Invision/AP, File)
UK police won’t probe journalist over 1995 Diana interview

Diana’s brother alleged Bashir used false documents to convince Diana

Dillon Dube scores hat trick for Flames in 7-3 win over Senators

Dillon Dube scores hat trick for Flames in 7-3 win over Senators

Walter Gretzky father of hockey hall-of-famer Wayne Gretzky waves to fans as the Buffalo Sabres play against the Toronto Maple Leafs in Toronto on Tuesday, January 17, 2017. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Walter Gretzky, father of the Great One, dies at 82

Walter Gretzky, father of the Great One, dies at 82

Liverpool's manager Jurgen Klopp gives instructions during the English Premier League soccer match between Liverpool and Chelsea at Anfield stadium in Liverpool, England, Thursday, March 4, 2021. (Phil Noble, Pool via AP)
Liverpool slumps to historic 5th straight loss at Anfield

Liverpool slumps to historic 5th straight loss at Anfield

Philadelphia Flyers' Sean Couturier (14) celebrates with teammates after scoring against Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Tristan Jarry (35) during the first period of an NHL hockey game Thursday, March 4, 2021, in Pittsburgh. (AP Photo/Keith Srakocic)
Flyers rally from early deficit to stun Penguins 4-3

Flyers rally from early deficit to stun Penguins 4-3

Most Read