Updated: Emotional scene in court as woman pleads guilty in 2018 Sunchild First Nation stabbing death

Samantha Sharpe, 25, was stabbed to death in December 2018

Sobs could be heard in a Red Deer courtroom on Monday afternoon as the events that led to Samantha Sharpe’s stabbing death in December 2018 were recounted.

Chelsey Lagrelle has pleaded guilty to manslaughter for stabbing Sharpe, one of the wounds piercing her heart.

Following their shifts at a local truck stop, Lagrelle and Sharpe got together with Chelsey’s brother at a home on Sunchild First Nation. After several hours of heavy drinking, an argument broke out in the early hours of Dec. 12, 2018 and Chelsey, who was 23 at the time, swung a knife at her older brother several times, wounding him in the leg.

She then turned on Sharpe, stabbing her twice.

Police were called and Sharpe’s body was found near the door of the home.

Lagrelle was arrested without incident at another location and charged with manslaughter and assault with a weapon.

Nearly 20 of Sharpe’s family members and other supporters were at the Red Deer courthouse to hear Lagrelle plead guilty for a second time to manslaughter. She pleaded to the same charge last December but a legal hitch required the plea be repeated.

The Crown prosecutor withdrew the assault charge.

Valerie Goodrunning said her younger sister touched a lot of people in her life.

“She was loved by many people. She was a really good person,” said Goodrunning. “She did a lot for all of her friends.”

Sharpe was in a vehicle accident that almost cost her her life when she was 23 years old.

“She was ejected from a vehicle and the vehicle landed on top of her. She was badly burned and spent many months in the burn unit and in physio.

“She fought hard for her life,” said Goodrunning.

“She never hesitated to help somebody out.”

Another older sister, Marcella Goodrunning, said Samantha committed herself to animal rescue, helping care and provide food for abandoned dogs.

In memory of their sister and other missing and murdered Indigenous women, both sisters wore red dresses to court.

For Sharpe’s family, the journey through the court system has been a painful ordeal.

Crown prosecutors replaced the original manslaughter charge with second-degree murder after a review. However, Sharpe’s family and friends were dismayed when it was later changed back to manslaughter.

Crown prosecutor Ed Ring explained in court on Monday that because of the amount of alcohol consumption on the night of the stabbing it was determined Lagrelle did not form the intention to kill, although she did intend to stab Sharpe.

The family does not believe that being drunk should not be allowed as an excuse to avoid more serious charges.

“What happened, she didn’t deserve it,” said Valerie.

“And how it’s being handled is not enough. We thought that it should be second-degree (murder).

“She stabbed her twice, so we don’t see that as an accident.”

The family wants the maximum penalty — life in prison — to be imposed. The minimum sentence is four years in prison.

Family members were further disappointed on Monday that Lagrelle, who has been out on bail, had her release conditions eased to allow her to get a job.

Acknowledging the supporters in the gallery, Ring explained that none of the decisions around Lagrelle’s release conditions were taken lightly and they are appropriate given the circumstances.

Sentencing has been set for March 26. Before that, a psychological assessment, pre-sentence report and a Gladue report will be done. Gladue reports are available to help the court determine appropriate sentences for First Nations and Metis offenders.


Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Company walks away from massive oilsands project

VANCOUVER — Teck Resources Ltd. has withdrawn its application for a massive… Continue reading

Fort Macleod, Alta., to get special advance screening of new ‘Ghostbusters’ film

There will be something strange in the neighbourhood of Fort Macleod, Alta.,… Continue reading

Hundreds turn up at Coldest Night of Year walk in Red Deer

It wasn’t the coldest night of the year, which probably helped the… Continue reading

Police in Saskatoon shoot two dogs that attacked man, then advanced on officers

SASKATOON — Police in Saskatoon say officers had to open fire at… Continue reading

Alberta and two First Nations make deal for proposed oilsands mine

EDMONTON — The Alberta government has struck deals with two northern Alberta… Continue reading

Fashion Fridays: The 8 best quality online stores! Shop the ultimate sales

Kim XO, helps to keep you looking good on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

Your community calendar

Feb. 19 A Liberation of Holland event is being held at the… Continue reading

Sylvan Lake Wranglers comeback to nab OT win in Game 2 over Red Deer Vipers

The Sylvan Lake Wranglers have a knack for the dramatics early in… Continue reading

Wranglers win wild Game 1 double OT thriller over Red Deer Vipers

The best-of-seven series continues Sunday in Sylvan Lake

Kings and Queens basketball triumph over Ambrose, keep playoff hopes alive

Guard Sandra Garica-Bernal sets new Queens all-time steals mark

Five things to watch for in the Canadian business world in the coming week

TORONTO — Five things to watch for in the Canadian business world… Continue reading

View of a longtime economist: Slower growth but no recession

WASHINGTON — In this high-profile election year, the U.S. economy boasts an… Continue reading

Amy, chasing: Klobuchar, already beating odds, faces uphill climb

WASHINGTON — It’s been a running gag ever since she launched her… Continue reading

B.C. money laundering inquiry to begin amid hopes for answers, accountability

VANCOUVER — British Columbia’s attorney general hopes an inquiry into money laundering… Continue reading

Most Read