Family of aboriginal girl with cancer can opt for traditional medicine: Judge

The family of an 11-year-old aboriginal girl with cancer has a constitutional right to opt for traditional medicine over chemotherapy, an Ontario judge ruled Friday in what some observers called a landmark decision.

BRANTFORD, Ont. — The family of an 11-year-old aboriginal girl with cancer has a constitutional right to opt for traditional medicine over chemotherapy, an Ontario judge ruled Friday in what some observers called a landmark decision.

A hospital that had been treating the First Nations girl sought to have the child apprehended and placed back into chemotherapy after her mother had pulled her out of the treatment earlier this year, but its application was dismissed by Judge Gethin Edward.

The decision doesn’t prevent the girl from seeking treatment in a hospital in the future though, and one lawyer in the case said the child had already been referred to an oncologist at a different hospital.

The case in Brantford, Ont., west of Hamilton, saw the McMaster Children’s Hospital take the Brant Family and Children’s Services to court over the issue of the girl’s treatment.

The girl, whose name cannot be revealed due to a publication ban, was receiving chemo before her mother removed her in mid-September to take her to Florida for alternative therapy, which involved herbal treatments and lifestyle changes.

At that point, the hospital asked the BFCS to intervene to ensure the girl continued her chemotherapy but the agency refused, triggering the legal case.

The girl and her immediate family were not in court on Friday, but the decision was hailed by the chief of the Six Nations Reserve, where the child is from.

“I don’t think we’re risking our kids’ lives. Her mother loves her to the world and back,” said Chief Ava Hill. “We’ve been practising traditional medicine, we’ve never stopped, and now we’re just going to do it more openly.”

The court’s decision also sent a message about the right of aboriginal communities to look after their own, said Hill.

“No longer are we going to let people come and take our kids,” she said. “The residential school era has ended, we’re moving on, now we’ve got a lot of healing to do because of that era and we’re not going to let anybody else take our kids anymore.”

A lawyer representing the BFCS said aboriginal rights were fundamental to the case and should be recognized.

“I think this is a landmark case and I think it will ripple at length,” Mark Handelman said in an interview.

“It recognizes the traditional rights of First Nations people to practice their own medicine, secondly it’s a reminder to health practitioners that it’s important to factor into treatment proposals and recommendations the wishes, values and beliefs of the patient.”

Handelman said the BFCS refused to apprehend the girl because it took the position that she was not in need of protection, but rather in need of a treatment decision.

The judge hearing the case concluded in his ruling that traditional aboriginal treatments were in existence before First Nations communities were in contact with Europeans, and were consequently entitled to special protection in Canada.

The ruling means the girl is free to pursue traditional treatment for her leukemia instead of chemotherapy, or alternatively, she is also free to decide to return to chemotherapy in the future, Handelman said.

Indeed, the girl and her family are back in Canada after their trip to the U.S., and a referral for the girl has been made to an oncologist at a different hospital, he said.

When asked if the outcome of the case might have been different if the child had not been aboriginal, Handelman said every case was different.

“It’s impossible to answer that question because both health-care cases and child-welfare cases, every one is unique, every one depends on its own facts,” he said.

“A broader aspect to this case is a reminder to all of us that medical decisions are never made solely on the basis of the best medical result — individual wishes, values and beliefs come into play.”

The hospital was not immediately available for comment but said it planned to issue a statement later in the day.

At least one expert on constitutional rights said the ruling appeared unusual.

“There really haven’t been court decisions like this relating to this kind of care that have favoured aboriginal rights and traditional aboriginal medicine,” said Cheryl Milne, director of the Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights at the University of Toronto.

There had been some cases in the past where a court had weighed in on choice of treatment for children, Milne said, but decisions had favoured medical treatments.

In the case of a family of Jehovah’s Witnesses, Milne explained that the Supreme Court overruled a teenager’s decision not to have a blood transfusion.

“So the religious rights of the child and the family, although a factor, they were overridden by what the court deemed was in the child’s best interest.”

In this case, however, aboriginal rights appeared to have been a “huge factor,” Milne said.

“That would be different than cases involving religions freedom, for example.”

Friday’s ruling could open the door to aboriginal traditions and rights being given more weight in other cases as well.

“We do have a disproportionate number of aboriginal children in the care of the state and many of them are in non-aboriginal homes,” said Milne. “Upholding the aboriginal rights in this kind of a context really also will speak to those kinds of cases too.”

Just Posted

Photos: Red Deer barn dance entertains children, adults Tuesday

Hundreds of Central Albertans started their Westerner Days celebrations early with an… Continue reading

Manslaughter charge laid against Red Deer man more than a year after homicide

A manslaughter charge has been laid against a Red Deer man, more… Continue reading

Woman facing charges after pedestrian critically injured in hit and run

A woman is in custody in connection with an alleged hit and… Continue reading

Friday hail storm came at a bad time for farmers

Amount of damage a hail storm does often depends on how far along crops are

Record 10 homers as AL wins All-Star Game 8-6 in 10 innings

American League 8 National League 6 (1o innings) WASHINGTON — A record… Continue reading

Photos: Red Deer barn dance entertains children, adults Tuesday

Hundreds of Central Albertans started their Westerner Days celebrations early with an… Continue reading

Man suffers critical injuries, Red Deer police arrest woman in pedestrian crash

A man is in hospital with critical injuries and Mounties have arrested… Continue reading

Cull hasn’t been able to solve bunny burden in Alberta mountain town of Canmore

CANMORE, Alta. — Problems persist in an Alberta mountain town overrun with… Continue reading

Canada should help Holocaust denier on trial in Germany: civil liberties group

OTTAWA — A civil liberties group is urging the Canadian government to… Continue reading

Westerner Days: Send us your photos

Your reader photo may just make the pages of the Adovcate.

Adam Henrique signs $29.1M, 5-year extension with Ducks

ANAHEIM, Calif. — Centre Adam Henrique has signed a $29.1 million, five-year… Continue reading

Fashion firms upend design routine to focus on speed, trends

NEW YORK — Prototypes? Passe. Fashion company Betabrand saw that knitwear was… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month