Family of Indigenous woman critical of Winnipeg police probe into her death

WINNIPEG — The family of an Indigenous woman found unclothed and injured in a train yard is criticizing how Winnipeg police investigated her death.

Police said Jaeda Vanderwal, 22, died from blunt force injury with hypothermia as a contributing factor after being struck by two trains on Jan. 5.

“I just want to know why and how she was there, found there, or how she ended up there,” her mother, Natalie Beaulieu said as she wiped tears from her eyes during a news conference at the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs’ office in Winnipeg on Thursday.

The family alleges there was evidence pointing to physical and sexual trauma and police moved too quickly when they decided her death was not criminal.

Const. Jay Murray said officers conducted interviews, watched videos and used tracks in the snow to conclude that Vanderwal was alone in the rail yard and no criminal act was committed.

“Her death is a tragedy and we sympathize with the grief that her loved ones must feel at this time,” Murray said.

At some point that evening, Vanderwal went to the entrance of the rail line, dropped some personal items in the snow and made her way through a locked gate, Murray said. She then walked around the area for awhile before she was struck by a train.

Murray said it’s believed she was suffering from paradoxical undressing linked to lethal hypothermia and removed her clothing. She began to crawl along the tracks before she was hit by another train.

Police were called to the area around 9 p.m. after train operators found her with serious injuries. She died in hospital.

Manitoba First Nations Police Service officers notified the family in Sandy Bay First Nation, which Murray said is standard protocol for people who live outside the city.

Natalie Beaulieu and Vanderwal’s grandmother, Linda Beaulieu, said they were not shown compassion when they learned of the death. Vanderwal’s aunt, Elyssa McIvor, said they also were not given adequate information about what happened.

“Jaeda deserved better treatment from the Winnipeg police. Instead from the beginning she was like many of our men and women who are thought of just as another Indigenous person who had substance abuse problems that led to their untimely deaths,” she said. “But we are more than that, we are human beings.”

Vanderwal, who was the mother of a two-year-old child, loved to laugh, her family said. Even when people were crying she would find a way to make them smile.

Vanderwal called her mother on the morning of her death and always stayed in contact, her family said. McIvor said it would be completely out of character for her to go wander in a train yard alone.

That’s why the family said they were shocked when no one was contacted by investigators to talk about the hours prior to her death. McIvor said they’ve also been given information from other people who knew Vanderwal which they believe could be important to an investigation.

She said when family reached out to police they were told to contact victim services or the medical examiner.

“In the time of reconciliation, we Indigenous are no better off than when this word became a catchphrase,” she said.

Murray said the family contacted the victim service’s unit. A meeting was arranged but the family didn’t attend. He said any information that may show a crime was committed will be investigated.

He said police Chief Danny Smyth is to meet with the family on Friday.

Grand Chief Arlen Dumas of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs said her death is reminiscent of Tina Fontaine, a 15-year-old Indigenous girl whose body was found in a river wrapped in a duvet cover weighed down by rocks in 2014.

He said it is important that police take the time to ensure that Vanderwal’s family gets answers.

“I’m very shocked and dismayed that Jaeda’s life and memory is being treated the way that it is being treated and I’m very disturbed that the family is not getting the support that they should receive.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Jan. 16, 2020

Kelly Geraldine Malone, The Canadian Press


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Red Deer gets $7M from province for an emergency 24/7 homeless shelter

Councillor says the location will be decided through community consultations

‘Finer focus on job creation:’ Alberta government files red-ink budget

EDMONTON — The Alberta budget is counting on oil and gas bouncing… Continue reading

WATCH: Tabling of the 2020 Alberta budget

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney is scheduled to reveal the provincial budget at… Continue reading

VIDEO: Grumpy sea lion resists help back to water in Washington state

Crews were able to coax her into a crate to carry her back to water

Your community calendar

Feb. 19 A Liberation of Holland event is being held at the… Continue reading

Granlund beats buzzer, scores in OT as Preds beat Flames 4-3

Predators 4 Flames 3 (OT) NASHVILLE — The Nashville Predators gambled that… Continue reading

Ministers wrap pipeline talks with hereditary chiefs for the day in B.C.

SMITHERS, B.C. — The hereditary chiefs of the Wet’suwet’en sat down Thursday… Continue reading

Gardening: Taking a break from the winter

Looking for a break from winter and dream of summer without leaving… Continue reading

Ottawa imposes new rules to protect fragile population of right whales

HALIFAX — Canada has rolled out new measures to protect the critically… Continue reading

Canada pumps nearly 900 billion litres of raw sewage into waterways since 2013

OTTAWA — Canada’s old-fashioned city sewer systems dumped nearly 900 billion litres… Continue reading

Federal government in good financial shape, provinces not so much: PBO

OTTAWA — The federal Liberals could add billions of dollars in spending… Continue reading

Ottawa’s LRT line leaves thousands out in the cold during heavy snowstorm

OTTAWA — Many transit riders in Ottawa were left out in the… Continue reading

Most Read