The Royal Society of Canada have taken a look at what Canada has accomplished since 2012 when they last examined marine biodiversity in a story on Nov. 20, 2019. (Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Government conflict of interest a threat to fish biodiversity: scientists

Canada has made disappointingly little progress in preserving the variety of life in its oceans largely because of a contradiction in the federal department that’s supposed to protect it, says a group of senior scientists.

“The (Department of Fisheries and Oceans) is charged with conflicting responsibilities,” said Jeff Hutchings, a marine biologist at Dalhousie University in Nova Scotia.

“On the one hand, they’re there to protect and conserve. On the other hand, they are charged with the responsibility of exploiting fish stocks.”

Hutchings is part of a team of scientists from the Royal Society of Canada — a group of senior researchers in many academic disciplines — who have taken a look at what Canada has accomplished since 2012 when they last examined marine biodiversity.

They say in a report released Wednesday that there’s been significant progress in marine protected areas. The country has increased more than tenfold its area of protected oceans.

Legislation such as the Fisheries Act and the Oceans Act have been reformed and revised.

But fish stocks remain threatened by the department’s built-in conflict of interest, the researchers conclude.

They point out department policy says that once a population falls below a certain level, fisheries should be minimized. In the case of northern cod, however, quotas were recently increased by 30 per cent despite stocks remaining at less than half that level.

“That’s perhaps an example of how this regulatory conflict plays itself out,” Hutchings said.

That’s not the only example of a fishery being allowed to continue despite warnings that numbers are collapsing.

“There are policies that are meant to allow things to rebuild to achieve high-yield sustainability, but on the other hand we’ve got pressure from sectors of the fishing industry whose interests are perhaps of a shorter-term nature.”

The same problems afflict how the department applies the Species At Risk Act to marine life.

“Exceedingly few marine fish species that have been recommended to be listed as endangered or threatened have made it to the list,” Hutchings said.

The department has taken as long as a decade to rule on whether a fish should be included on the list — although recent reforms have stipulated the decision can’t take more than three years.

Nor does Canada know much about the fish that swim off its shores, other than those that are fished commercially.

“All the stock assessment, all the science that’s done on marine fish, are done on just a mere handful of species.”

There are 950 species off the East Coast, he said. Stock assessments have been done for 10 of them.

Hutchings points out that fishing targets are set by the department in consultation with industry. Scientists only provide advice.

In countries such as Australia and the United States, scientists help set the targets.

“Other countries have those targets identified by science, but we don’t.”

Adding to the problem is ministerial discretion, the report says, which allows the minister to ignore scientific recommendations in favour of other considerations. The minister doesn’t have to release the information used to make the decision.

That’s different from other countries such as those in the European Union or the U.S.

“We should always know what the science advice is,” said Hutchings. “And that is what other western democracies are doing.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Opposition promises new info on Trans Mountain costs

OTTAWA — Federal opposition parties are promising new information about the price… Continue reading

Bed Bath & Beyond rises as retailer unveils turnaround plan

Shares of Bed Bath & Beyond are moving sharply higher before the… Continue reading

Inflation rises again, hitting 2.4 per cent in January, Statistics Canada says

OTTAWA — Statistics Canada says the annual pace of inflation in Canada… Continue reading

Hereditary chiefs say they’ll meet with ministers if RCMP get out

VANCOUVER — A small, mobile RCMP detachment in a remote area of… Continue reading

City’s cardiac care is ‘a blight’

Human lives are at stake, so the provincial government can’t afford to… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Feb. 19 A Liberation of Holland event is being held at the… Continue reading

New highway to B.C. proposed

The Howse Pass shortcut to British Columbia is worth taking another look… Continue reading

Stolen car provides opportunity to try out public transit

I had my car stolen on Jan. 10, just as our one… Continue reading

Any other protesters would be sitting in jail by now

I’d really like to know why the current Indigenous pipeline blockades aren’t… Continue reading

Wolfpack hooker James Cunningham out for six months after hamstring surgery

The Toronto Wolfpack’s depleted squad has taken another hit with James Cunningham… Continue reading

Virologist: Tokyo Olympics probably couldn’t be held now

TOKYO — A respected Japanese virologist on Wednesday said if the Tokyo… Continue reading

Bong happy ‘Parasite’ succeeded despite disparity it showed

SEOUL, Korea, Republic Of — Oscar-winning “Parasite” director Bong Joon-ho said Wednesday… Continue reading

Vancouver-raised Kenneth Lum among winners of $25K Governor General’s art awards

OTTAWA — Vancouver-bred contemporary artist Kenneth Lum, whose works have challenged notions… Continue reading

Most Read