Great white tagging program off N.S. stirs debate over treatment of sharks

Great white tagging program off N.S. stirs debate over treatment of sharks

LUNENBURG, N.S. — Enthusiastic scientists aboard the research vessel MV Ocearch pumped their fists as a voice crackled over the radio announcing the expedition had hooked its 11th great white shark this fall off Nova Scotia.

But to some marine biologists, what unfolded recently on this non-profit research ship wasn’t cause for celebration — instead it raised ethical questions over methods used to attract and study the ocean predators.

About 30 minutes after it was hooked, a mature male — its tail thrashing — was brought alongside the converted American crab ship, as vessel captain Brett McBride leapt onto the submerged platform that raised the animal out of the ocean.

The massive, 3.6-metre shark briefly reared its head in protest as the mariner manoeuvred it onto its side, causing the fish to suddenly go still amid the humming sound of the hydraulic lift.

A black cloth was placed over the shark’s eyes, a tube pumped water through the gills and six scientists descended to the platform, allowing themselves 15 fast-paced minutes to take blood, parasite, muscle, fecal and semen samples.

Veterinarian Mike Hyatt of the New York Aquarium cut the shining white belly to install an acoustic tag, as University of Windsor research associate Dan Madigan drilled the satellite positioning tag — referred to as a SPOT tag — to the dorsal fin. It’s this tag which will allows thousands of people who’ve downloaded an app to follow the shark’s movements online.

But behind the excitement, an unresolved scientific debate has bubbled away over how sharks, notoriously sensitive to handling, are impacted.

During a briefing, Hyatt said blood tests taken at the beginning and end of such intense captures show the animal’s stress levels don’t rise. ”What’s quite astonishing … is working with them out of the water their stress levels stay the same and sometimes actually improve,” he explained.

However, while marine biologists interviewed by The Canadian Press concur with Hyatt’s view of the shark’s short-term reaction, they wonder what will happen to internal organs and reproductive systems in the months and years to come. Some shark researchers refuse to use the method.

At the federal Bedford Institute of Oceanography in Halifax, Heather Bowlby, the research lead at the federal Canadian Atlantic Shark Research Laboratory, has shifted away from systems that involves hooking sharks or bringing them aboard ships.

This season, her team used a lure to attract a four-metre female and then a harpoon to rapidly attach a pop-up archival tag near its dorsal fin.

The recording device will later detach and float to the surface and provide light, temperature and depth data that will help Bowlby study its habitat and habits.

“There’s been a general shift in the shark research community to move away from bringing sharks on board a boat,” she said in an interview. “All of their muscle is concentrated in their back and it does press down. They don’t have a rib cage. They’re not designed to be out of the water, and that’s why we have moved to tagging inside the water.”

Gregory Skomal, who leads a Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries study group off Cape Cod, says he uses a spotter plane and harpoon methods like Bowlby’s “to minimize invasive handling.”

He said he has questions about the impact of Ocearch’s method. “It could be creating long-term problems for the future reproductive success of the animal …. It’s an area that people are very worried about.”

Chris Lowe, a veteran shark researcher with the University of California at Long Beach, says he observed the impact on a younger shark after he bolted a SPOT tag to it, and the fin bent over and deformed over time.

“At that point I elected not to use them any more due to damage to the fin …. I don’t think we’ve developed a good enough tag design that’s designed to come off or to minimize damage,” he said.

Still, Lowe says this may not hold true of more mature sharks, and there are tradeoffs for scientists who don’t use the Ocearch methods.

He says the pop-up tags he harpoons onto sharks are less accurate in tracking the sharks’ precise journeys — and he can’t collect the volume of data on blood, genetics and parasites.

Meanwhile, Ocearch’s method can combine the positioning provided by the SPOT tags with the archival depth and temperature information from the pop-off tags. It’s a practice the group has used for females the last two years, providing a potentially rich source of data.

Chris Fischer, the expedition leader and founder of Ocearch, firmly disagrees with critics and says he’s gathering ”a whole suite” of valuable information widely available for scientists to examine and which will lead to improved fisheries management.

“These will be the most comprehensively studied individual white sharks in history here in Canada,” he said during an interview after the expedition ended its work, which ran from Sept. 13 to Oct. 4 off Cape Breton and Lunenburg.

The precision of his tagging methods could help researchers locate the “holy grail” of the nursery where mature females reproduce and give birth, he said aboard his research ship.

Meanwhile, Robert Hueter, the chief scientist with Ocearch, says photos of great whites tagged in the eastern Pacific that were observed years later after the SPOT tags came off “show no significant effect on the shark or its dorsal fin.”

The shark biologist at Florida’s Mote Marine Laboratory says criticisms about unknown, long-term impacts are ”speculation without data,” and he notes that during the operation, their team does ultrasound imaging of internal organs and has found no evidence of damage.

“Finally, we put the resulting movements of our sharks on the Ocearch Tracker for all the world to see; clearly our sharks are moving as we know white sharks to do, south in winter and north in summer, with key stops along the way,” he wrote in an email.

Still, Aaron MacNeil, the Canada Research Council chair in fisheries conservation at Dalhousie University, has become a critic of the scientific methodologies.

He recently raised the issue of the vessel fishing for sharks near waters where Nova Scotians surf and dive, saying he’s concerned it could draw the animals closer to people.

“In my view, the federal Fisheries Department still needs to establish a safe distance for shark-fishing to occur relative to recreational users and exclude shark-fishing within this zone,” he said.

Fischer contends that it is not that simple to alter shark behaviour.

A federal Fisheries Department spokeswoman said great white sharks are normally found in waters around Nova Scotia this time of year and in close proximity to coastal areas, and “therefore, it is considered that these research activities are unlikely to significantly increase risks.”

Meanwhile, as the season wrapped up, Fischer said he intends to continue his relationship with the federal Fisheries Department, which has granted him permits under the Species At Risk Act and a foreign vessel license.

He says under the conditions of its permit, Ocearch will provide the federal authorities with its tracking information, along with blood, semen, diet, genetic and other valuable information.

“The question for DFO is ‘Where do you need us to go next for you?’” said Fischer, noting he would like to return to Cape Breton next year to validate this year’s findings.

Alain Vezina, the Maritimes region director of science at the federal Fisheries Department, declined a request for an interview. In written responses, the department said Ocearch is required to provide it with an outline of its activities and the tagging data they collect, and that the organization is to submit a report by the end of this year.

“The methods are intended to minimize any potential impacts to these sharks. Monitoring will be undertaken to ensure compliance with the permit conditions,” the email from the communications department said..

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

A man wearing shorts uses trekking poles as he walks through the snow at Burnaby Mountain Park in Burnaby, B.C., on Sunday, Jan. 24, 2021. Canadians are “Angry Birds” when it comes to climate action, indicates a survey the United Nations calls the largest ever taken on the issue. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
UN survey uses Angry Birds to reveal Canadian, global opinions on climate policies

Canada seventh out of 50 countries when it comes to concern about the environment

James Scott, 19, pauses while picking through the remains of his home, which was destroyed by a tornado, on Tuesday, Jan. 26, 2021, in Fultondale, Ala. Scott, who survived with his mother and sister, had never lived anywhere else and isn’t sure where he will wind up after the storm. (AP Photo/Jay Reeves)
Killer winter tornado stuns storm-savvy Alabama town

30 injured, entire families trapped in shattered homes

A photo illustration made December 14, 2012 in Montreal shows a computer in chains. Security experts warn about “ransomware,” where computers or mobile phones are locked down by cyber thieves. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz
Cyber cops in 9 nations team up to disrupt dangerous malware

Malicious software was delivered in infected email attachments containing Word documents

Vehicles are seen in a parking lot at the General Motors Oshawa Assembly Plant in Oshawa, Ont., on June 20, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/ Tijana Martin
GM, Navistar team up to build hydrogen powered heavy trucks

GM has been researching hydrogen fuel cells for 50 years

Employment, Workforce Development and Disability Inclusion Minister Carla Qualtrough responds to a question during a news conference Thursday August 20, 2020 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Easing rules for parental benefits created inequities among parents, documents say

Documents obtained under the Access to Information Act

File - In this Saturday, Jan. 27, 2018 file photo, survivors of the Nazi death camp Auschwitz arrive for a commemoration ceremony on International Holocaust Remembrance Day at the International Monument to the Victims of Fascism inside Auschwitz-Birkenau in Oswiecim, Poland. The commemorations for the victims of the Holocaust at the International Holocaust Remembrance Day, marking the liberation of Auschwitz-Birkenau on Jan. 27, 1945, will be mostly online this year due to the coronavirus pandemic. (AP Photo/Czarek Sokolowski, file)
Auschwitz survivors mark anniversary online amid pandemic

Memorial site closed to visitors because of the pandemic

FIFA set a new target to finalizing North American host cities for the 2026 World Cup. (File photo by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS)
FIFA sets late-2021 target date to pick 2026 World Cup host cities

23 candidate cities likely need to be cut to 16

Hockey Alberta’s logo. (Photo courtesy Hockey Alberta Facebook)
Hockey Alberta sets deadline on decision for 2020-21 minor hockey season

Sustainability of league play for remainder of season under review

Well-known Rocky Mountain retreat Jasper Park Lodge has been booked out from the end of February until the end of April. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Lauren Krugel
Famous hotel in Alberta mountains reserved for nine weeks for private booking

Hotel could be a filming site according to online speculation

”Letterkenny” has signed a number of new merchandising deals, including one with collectible figurine creator Funko. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO - Bell Media, Amanda Matlovich
‘Letterkenny’ inks multiple licensing deals with merchandise companies

Expand on merchandise sold through show’s website

Toronto Maple Leafs goalie Frederik Andersen, left, makes a save on Calgary Flames forward Matthew Tkachuk during second period NHL hockey action in Calgary, Tuesday, Jan. 26, 2021.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Mitch Marner scores game winner for Maple Leafs in 4-3 win over Flames

Mitch Marner scores game winner for Maple Leafs in 4-3 win over Flames

FILE - In this Oct. 25, 2007, file photo, Boston Red Sox's Curt Schilling pitches against the Colorado Rockies in Game 2 of the baseball World Series at Fenway Park in Boston. Like many baseball writers, C. Trent Rosecrans viewed the Hall of Fame vote as a labor of love. The results of the 2021 vote will be announced Tuesday, Jan. 26, 2021, and Rosecrans was not alone in finding the task particularly agonizing this time around. With Schilling's candidacy now front and center — and Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens still on the ballot as well — voters have had to consider how much a player’s off-field behavior should affect his Hall of Fame chances. (AP Photo/Kathy Willens, File)
Baseball Hall gets no new members; Schilling 16 votes shy

Baseball Hall gets no new members; Schilling 16 votes shy

Prince Edward Island’s Birt is bubble-bound but first wants provincial title

Prince Edward Island’s Birt is bubble-bound but first wants provincial title

Most Read